Scholz pushes mandatory jabs as resistance grows in Germany
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz insisted Friday that his plan to introduce mandatory coronavirus jabs was on track, despite fierce debate about the controversial move and growing resistance from his own coalition partners.
Scholz, who recently took over as chancellor from Angela Merkel, in late November touted compulsory jabs for all adults as the surest way out of the pandemic.
The centre-left Social Democrat asked MPs in the lower of house parliament to draft the necessary legislation with the goal of introducing the measure in "late February or early March".
Little progress has been made since then however, and the fast-spreading but less severe Omicron strain has raised fresh doubts about the project, particularly among the pro-business FDP party.
Speaking after a meeting with the leaders of Germany's 16 states on tighter coronavirus curbs, Scholz reiterated that "it would be good if we ended up with a general vaccine mandate".
READ ALSO: KEY POINTS: Germany's plans to soften the impact of Omicron
He said all of Germany's state premiers had declared their backing for the plan.
"I feel fully supported" by them, he said.
The same cannot be said for the FDP, who along with the Greens make up Scholz's three-way coalition government.
Although coronavirus cases are rising, Germany has so far been spared the steep Omicron surge that has swept other nations -- prompting Justice Minister Marco Buschmann from the FDP to call for a wait-and-see approach on a general vaccine mandate.
FDP chief Christian Lindner said new findings "could play a role in the decision", in a nod to Omicron infecting even the triple jabbed, and studies suggesting a lower hospitalisation rate than with the Delta variant.
"Protecting human health and life is highly desirable. But our greatest asset... is and remains our freedom," he said on Thursday.
Germany's first parliamentary debate on compulsory jabs is only scheduled for late January, even though Scholz himself had originally aimed to have lawmakers discuss the issue before 2021 was out.
This has fuelled speculation that Scholz won't be able to stick to his timetable for introducing the measure.
"The longer the discussion about mandatory vaccinations lasts... the more the project wobbles," wrote Sueddeutsche newspaper and Der Spiegel weekly called it "a headless project without a plan".
Hundreds, at times thousands, of protesters have taken to the streets to rail against the government's Covid approach and vaccine plan in recent weeks, occasionally resulting in clashes with police.
Austrian example
Although it is home to BioNTech, the company that co-created the widely used Comirnaty vaccine, with just over 71 percent of the population double jabbed, Germany has a lower coronavirus vaccination rate than France, Italy or Spain as shown in the below chart from Our World in Data.
Almost 42 percent of Germans have had their booster shot, considered crucial in the fight against Omicron.
Like several other countries, Germany has already announced vaccine mandates for those in certain professions, including soldiers and health workers.
Neighbouring Austria has gone further and is on the verge of introducing a general vaccine mandate, in what could be the first in Europe.
READ ALSO: Austria presents first draft of vaccine mandate law: Here's what we know
While it has stirred controversy there too, the measure is backed by all the political parties except Austria's far-right FPOe.
"Compulsory vaccination will come, all experts agree on the high protective effect, also against Omicron and hospitalisations," said Austrian Chancellor Karl Nehammer.
'Sensitive topic'
A government spokeswoman on Friday rejected media suggestions that Scholz has lost the grip on his timetable, saying mandatory vaccination was a "sensitive topic" that merited a "public and wide" discussion.
Several MPs from the FDP, a party traditionally in favour of low government intervention, have said they will table a motion against the plan.
FDP lawmaker and health expert Andrew Ullmann suggested a compromise, saying he would propose mandatory jabs for the over-50s only, after Italy's example.
The opposition meanwhile has attacked Scholz for passing the buck to parliament instead of having the government spearhead the draft legislation.
"We need speed and leadership," said Hendrik Wuest, the premier of North Rhine-Westphalia state from the centre-right CDU, cautioning against "political manoeuvring" in the battle against the pandemic.
Health Minister Karl Lauterbach, an epidemiologist from Scholz's Social Democrats, said compulsory jabs had to come quickly to avoid the worst of what Omicron -- and future variants -- could have in store.
Hoping that Omicron would spread so rapidly that the vaccine debate becomes "obsolete" would be a mistake, he told Spiegel.
Even with Omicron, patients could suffer severe illness and lasting damage, he said.
"A lot of unvaccinated people would die."
"Mandatory vaccination is the path that's necessary for Germany," he told broadcaster RTL.
READ MORE:
- 2G-plus: Germany tightens Covid rules for restaurants, bars and cafes
- 'I was against vaccine mandates in Germany - until hospitals got overwhelmed'
Comments (1)
See Also
Scholz, who recently took over as chancellor from Angela Merkel, in late November touted compulsory jabs for all adults as the surest way out of the pandemic.
The centre-left Social Democrat asked MPs in the lower of house parliament to draft the necessary legislation with the goal of introducing the measure in "late February or early March".
Little progress has been made since then however, and the fast-spreading but less severe Omicron strain has raised fresh doubts about the project, particularly among the pro-business FDP party.
Speaking after a meeting with the leaders of Germany's 16 states on tighter coronavirus curbs, Scholz reiterated that "it would be good if we ended up with a general vaccine mandate".
READ ALSO: KEY POINTS: Germany's plans to soften the impact of Omicron
He said all of Germany's state premiers had declared their backing for the plan.
"I feel fully supported" by them, he said.
The same cannot be said for the FDP, who along with the Greens make up Scholz's three-way coalition government.
Although coronavirus cases are rising, Germany has so far been spared the steep Omicron surge that has swept other nations -- prompting Justice Minister Marco Buschmann from the FDP to call for a wait-and-see approach on a general vaccine mandate.
FDP chief Christian Lindner said new findings "could play a role in the decision", in a nod to Omicron infecting even the triple jabbed, and studies suggesting a lower hospitalisation rate than with the Delta variant.
"Protecting human health and life is highly desirable. But our greatest asset... is and remains our freedom," he said on Thursday.
Germany's first parliamentary debate on compulsory jabs is only scheduled for late January, even though Scholz himself had originally aimed to have lawmakers discuss the issue before 2021 was out.
This has fuelled speculation that Scholz won't be able to stick to his timetable for introducing the measure.
"The longer the discussion about mandatory vaccinations lasts... the more the project wobbles," wrote Sueddeutsche newspaper and Der Spiegel weekly called it "a headless project without a plan".
Hundreds, at times thousands, of protesters have taken to the streets to rail against the government's Covid approach and vaccine plan in recent weeks, occasionally resulting in clashes with police.
Austrian example
Although it is home to BioNTech, the company that co-created the widely used Comirnaty vaccine, with just over 71 percent of the population double jabbed, Germany has a lower coronavirus vaccination rate than France, Italy or Spain as shown in the below chart from Our World in Data.
Almost 42 percent of Germans have had their booster shot, considered crucial in the fight against Omicron.
Like several other countries, Germany has already announced vaccine mandates for those in certain professions, including soldiers and health workers.
Neighbouring Austria has gone further and is on the verge of introducing a general vaccine mandate, in what could be the first in Europe.
READ ALSO: Austria presents first draft of vaccine mandate law: Here's what we know
While it has stirred controversy there too, the measure is backed by all the political parties except Austria's far-right FPOe.
"Compulsory vaccination will come, all experts agree on the high protective effect, also against Omicron and hospitalisations," said Austrian Chancellor Karl Nehammer.
'Sensitive topic'
A government spokeswoman on Friday rejected media suggestions that Scholz has lost the grip on his timetable, saying mandatory vaccination was a "sensitive topic" that merited a "public and wide" discussion.
Several MPs from the FDP, a party traditionally in favour of low government intervention, have said they will table a motion against the plan.
FDP lawmaker and health expert Andrew Ullmann suggested a compromise, saying he would propose mandatory jabs for the over-50s only, after Italy's example.
The opposition meanwhile has attacked Scholz for passing the buck to parliament instead of having the government spearhead the draft legislation.
"We need speed and leadership," said Hendrik Wuest, the premier of North Rhine-Westphalia state from the centre-right CDU, cautioning against "political manoeuvring" in the battle against the pandemic.
Health Minister Karl Lauterbach, an epidemiologist from Scholz's Social Democrats, said compulsory jabs had to come quickly to avoid the worst of what Omicron -- and future variants -- could have in store.
Hoping that Omicron would spread so rapidly that the vaccine debate becomes "obsolete" would be a mistake, he told Spiegel.
Even with Omicron, patients could suffer severe illness and lasting damage, he said.
"A lot of unvaccinated people would die."
"Mandatory vaccination is the path that's necessary for Germany," he told broadcaster RTL.
READ MORE:
- 2G-plus: Germany tightens Covid rules for restaurants, bars and cafes
- 'I was against vaccine mandates in Germany - until hospitals got overwhelmed'
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.