Plan for tax fraud denunciation website in Germany causes uproar
A proposal by Germany's centre-left Greens to roll out an online tax fraud denunciation platform has prompted sharp criticism from opposition parties in the run-up to elections later this month.
The initiative, first introduced by the Green-led state of Baden-Württemberg this week, gained the backing of the party's candidate to be chancellor, Annalena Baerbock, who told TV channel ProSieben on Wednesday "we need to create places where significant fraud can be reported, when cases are known".
The backlash has been swift in a country where anonymous denunciations recall the dark period of Nazi rule and mass surveillance under the communist government of East Germany.
The best-selling Bild daily slammed plans to create what it called a "tax Stasi", a reference to the feared East German secret police who used a web of informants to keep tabs on citizens.
The Greens have "once again shown their true face", the deputy leader of the Baden-Württemberg conservatives, Thorsten Frei, said in a statement, despite his party being part of the ruling coalition in the state.
"Every hard-working and tax-paying citizen" would now be under suspicion, he added.
While digitising the tax system was important, "beginning with denunciations between neighbours is baffling", the leader of the pro-business FDP party Christian Lindner told the Frankfurter Allgemeine newspaper.
The initiative creates an "atmosphere of mistrust" said Bernd Goegel, the leader of the far-right AfD in Baden-Wuerttemberg.
Baden-Wuerttemberg's finance ministry brought the website online at the beginning of the week, promising a "secure and discreet" means of reporting potential tax crimes.
"Tax evasion is a slap in the face to all those who honestly pay their taxes," said Danyal Bayaz, the state's Green finance minister.
A few weeks before the September 26 general election, the new initiative by Germany's only Green-led state has stirred up debate in a country where tax fraud has been estimated at 50 billion euros a year.
Germany has a "big problem", said chancellor candidate Baerbock, rejecting comparisons with the Stasi as "mocking" its victims.
Comments
See Also
The initiative, first introduced by the Green-led state of Baden-Württemberg this week, gained the backing of the party's candidate to be chancellor, Annalena Baerbock, who told TV channel ProSieben on Wednesday "we need to create places where significant fraud can be reported, when cases are known".
The backlash has been swift in a country where anonymous denunciations recall the dark period of Nazi rule and mass surveillance under the communist government of East Germany.
The best-selling Bild daily slammed plans to create what it called a "tax Stasi", a reference to the feared East German secret police who used a web of informants to keep tabs on citizens.
The Greens have "once again shown their true face", the deputy leader of the Baden-Württemberg conservatives, Thorsten Frei, said in a statement, despite his party being part of the ruling coalition in the state.
"Every hard-working and tax-paying citizen" would now be under suspicion, he added.
While digitising the tax system was important, "beginning with denunciations between neighbours is baffling", the leader of the pro-business FDP party Christian Lindner told the Frankfurter Allgemeine newspaper.
The initiative creates an "atmosphere of mistrust" said Bernd Goegel, the leader of the far-right AfD in Baden-Wuerttemberg.
Baden-Wuerttemberg's finance ministry brought the website online at the beginning of the week, promising a "secure and discreet" means of reporting potential tax crimes.
"Tax evasion is a slap in the face to all those who honestly pay their taxes," said Danyal Bayaz, the state's Green finance minister.
A few weeks before the September 26 general election, the new initiative by Germany's only Green-led state has stirred up debate in a country where tax fraud has been estimated at 50 billion euros a year.
Germany has a "big problem", said chancellor candidate Baerbock, rejecting comparisons with the Stasi as "mocking" its victims.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.