SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

RACISM

OPINION: When will Germany deal with its casual racism problem?

Whether it's in the supermarket, gym or office, microaggressions against marginalised people are happening every day in Germany, writes Barbara Woolsey. Will this change anytime soon?

OPINION: When will Germany deal with its casual racism problem?
People at a Black Lives Matter protest in Berlin in July 2020. Photo: DPA

I keep thinking about a recent conversation with a Black friend who, after living in Germany for over a decade, has decided to leave for good. The uniquely laidback lifestyle and vibrant cultural scene in Berlin are a couple of the things he’ll miss. But one thing he won’t? “All the casual racism. For sure.”

Being a foreigner of colour myself, I know what he’s talking about. Microaggressions. Like the good beer and bureaucracy, they are also a local fixture.

Microaggressions are everyday expressions of discrimination that make marginalised folks feel othered and uncomfortable.

They can be offhand and fleeting, intentional or not. Frustratingly, sometimes microaggressions come so out of left field you don’t even register them in the moment. Like the Five Point Palm Exploding Heart Technique from Kill Bill, you’re already a few steps away before thinking: “Wait a second – what did they just say?”

A couple of years ago, the #MeTwo campaign on Twitter, started by a German-Turkish activist inspired by #MeToo, brought commonplace instances of ethnic and racial discrimination in Germany to light.

Glib comments like being asked, “Where are you really from?” (The answer? Frankfurt) to remarks with far-reaching consequences, like teachers discriminating against students from ethnic minorities.

The tweet below shows the German Green party Cem Özdemir, who is of Turkish origin, discussing racism in schools.

Of my experiences, the one that first comes to mind is the many times that men here have referred to my Asian looks as “exotic” (often coupled with a creepy smile). As if I’m a flamingo or something.

READ ALSO: My experiences of everday racism in Germany

'I'm having a lot of difficult conversations'

Germany is a lodestar of liberal and progressive values. Yes, this is the same place where, in recent years, thousands nationwide have marched in demonstrations against populism and far-right sentiment.

That allowed over a million refugees during the refugee crisis to enter the country, and cheered them on with signs reading, “Welcome to Germany”. According to the Allensbach Institute, over half of Germany’s population aged 16 and over offered assistance to newcomers during those first few months.

Yet, whether in the supermarket checkout line or at the fitness studio, I still see and hear microaggressions happening all the time. A culture exists in Germany where microaggressions have room to thrive.

Germans are fiercely protective of order and status quo. Uniformity and unwavering adherence to the rules ensures that past mistakes do not repeat.

When someone’s in the wrong, they will surely and swiftly be corrected, often loud and publicly. This reality allows for microaggressions to surface as Freudian slips. Their prevalence speaks to a larger systemic problem of discrimination beneath a society that wants to be known as accepting and tolerant.

A Black activist, for example, recently told me that local activist circles speak about Germany as being at least 20 years behind in how topics like race and discrimination are talked about compared to the United States.

 An Asian-American friend, a recent transplant to Berlin, confirms this. “I feel the need to emphasize my American-ness in everyday situations to turn the focus away from the fact that I'm not white,” she says. “I’m having a lot of difficult conversations that I thought I was done having, like, 15 years ago.”

Although Germans are known for being straight-shooters in both the private and professional spheres, difficult topics like racism and sexism are still fumbled and shied away from.

There is fear associated with being viewed as unfair. A core belief in egalitarianism can often be misconstrued. An example: the Germans on social media who accidentally used the hashtag #AllLivesMatter to support Black Lives Matter, garnering comments like, “Er, I think you mean…”

READ ALSO: 'Black lives need to matter in Germany': New project to uncover everyday racism

How can Germany deal with this?

An obvious solution in advancing the conversation is more diverse representation in the leadership of German corporations and government. Case in point: Germany’s Cabinet Committee Responsible for Combating Right-Wing Extremism and Racism which does not have a person of colour.

This has garnered considerable discussion on Twitter, including from white male wonks who are keen to point out that cabinet committees can only be formed by certain top government members, making the choice limited.

It also led to memes like this one on Instagram.

Another solution would be for more German schools, universities, and companies to collect anonymized data on race, religion, sexual orientation, and so on. Many don’t. This would create more transparency in tackling discrimination, and its symptoms like microaggressions.

Berlin’s State Office for Equal Treatment and Against Discrimination (LADS) is making a progressive step. Earlier this year, Berlin became the first German state to pass an anti-discrimination law forbidding public authorities to show bias based on factors like skin colour and gender. With the new antidiscrimination app, AnDi, LADS says it hopes to “play a scientific role in investigating discrimination” and disseminating information about it.

READ ALSO: 'I'm an American and I was racially profiled in Berlin 23 times'

Let’s see the way forward. Let’s see if “microaggression” finds its way into dialogue in Germany, perhaps even the Duden dictionary (maybe the term will already be antiquated – its already being rejected by anti-racism activists, like the author of “How to be Antiracist” Ibram X. Kendi, for reducing the severity of racist abuse).

Let’s see how widely the AnDi app will be used and whether it goes beyond a performative role. After all, speaking up about discrimination and microaggressions can be difficult emotional labour for marginalized folks.

Knowing change doesn’t happen in silence, I recently drummed up the courage to email a local business. An employee’s discriminatory comments during a one-on-one appointment made me feel scared and uncomfortable, and I didn’t want someone else to feel that way either.

Of course, there’s been no reply.

Member comments

  1. What a lazily executed, mess of an article. If you took any of this seriously you wouldn’t have put out such poorly supported slop. Cute meme though.

  2. What a lazily executed, mess of an article. If you took any of this seriously you wouldn’t have put out such poorly supported slop. Cute meme though.

  3. The writer obviously didn’t bother consulting the recent poll results concerning Merkel’s ill considered “We can do this!” refugee response, or if she did, choose to ignore them as they didn’t fit her happy-happy views on mass immigration. This article seems to have disappeared from the Local.de front page to be replaced by this one…Anyway, the figures were pretty clear – 33% were and still are opposed to admitting refugees but more telling is the 13% who were in favour of Merkel’s policy but no longer are. I lived in Thailand for over 5 years and was subject to racism there as a westerner but I accepted it as human nature – I did not for one moment consider it to be a fault with Thai society as a whole that required changes in the law or immigration policy. I spoke with a German friend at the time in London when Merkel made her decision and warned him that it would not end well – seems like many in Germany agree with me but as per usual are being ignored by the mainstream media or, at best, dismissed as “far-right” when in reality they are quite happy with the society they have built over thousands of years that they do not want to see destroyed in a few decades. Simple answer is this, the welcome mat has been worn-out and rolled up.

  4. Not sure what is the problem with the article in the previous comments. I agree that as a person of colour I can encounter this quite often to the point thaht i started to feel as an expected behaviourin the society

  5. The comments here from “Britfire” and “-” are obviously white people uncomfortable with acknowledging that racism even exists in Germany. Here they are gaslighting a person of colour for her perspective. You are exactly the problem.

    The people in Germany who oppose(d) the welcoming of refugees is a perfect example of how rampant racism is in this country.

  6. The comments here from “Britfire” and “-” are obviously white people uncomfortable with acknowledging that racism even exists in Germany. Here they are gaslighting a person of colour for her perspective. You are exactly the problem.

    The people in Germany who oppose(d) the welcoming of refugees is a perfect example of how rampant racism is in this country.

  7. I don’t question that racism exists – did you not read the part about racist attitudes I’d experienced in Thailand? But I forget, racism is only something that happens to coloured folk, right? More importantly, it didn’t stop me from working, paying my taxes, learning the language, obeying the law, respecting local customs and in all respects being a useful member of society, in other words, the exact opposite of too many of the immigrants/refugees to Europe. The people who oppose excessive immigration are those who have seen first hand the effect it has had on there communities and let me assure you the numbers will continue to increase both in Germany and across Europe. So, I’m comfortable with the idea of racism in Germany, it’s called protecting your way of life, are you comfortable discussing the causes of racism? I’ll name a few – drugs, unclean habits, gangs, crime, terrorism and welfare state drain. Now, over to you, what are the positives?

  8. Britain voted Brexit because Racism has a proper foothold there. The equivalent in Germany would be the AfD who are a small fringe party. Does anyone really want people looking for things that might possibly be considered an insult to those of other races. It was even proposed that the Moor in Christmas cribs should be banned. I suspect only extreme racists would throw out the black king?

  9. Keep on believing that Brexit was about racism, Michael, it makes it so much easier than confronting the mess the EU half-wits have made of Europe. Let me say it clearly, Brexit is not about racism. It’s about having control over who you let into your country, it’s about freedom from the EU’s awful bureaucracy and the freedom to act in your countries best interest without overbearing oversight from Brussels. I’m interested to know what you think of the nearly 50% of Germans (at leat in one poll) who don’t agree with Merkel’s mass influx of refugees. They can’t all be AfD, because that’s only “a small fringe party”, so why is it Germany has so many “racists”, Michael? Because, by your own reasoning, if Brexit was all about racism then pretty soon we can expect Germany to be leaving the EU…

  10. Hi Britfire, I am pleased that over half the population of Britain now ‘have Control’ I did not get a vote on the matter but do not feel any more in control than before. I do see that many car producers are not producing their latest models in the UK, Finance houses and banks relocating out of the city and trade to the EU is being lost, but then it is those that are taking control not their (British) employees.

  11. Well Michael, nobody knows what the ultimate result of Brexit will be. What we do know is the EU had a fair crack of the whip, 25 years or so, to impress the citizens of the UK, and failed. You know, people go on about how the result of the Brexit vote was narrow but, let’s be honest, when you have anywhere near 50% of the vote against you, you have failed. As I have said all along doing business in the UK is good, what we don’t need is a great lumbering, power mad monster like the EU.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

RACISM

Black people in Germany face ‘widespread’ racism, survey finds

In the Afrocensus, a first-of-its-kind survey charting the lived experiences of black people in Germany, the vast majority revealed they experienced 'extensive' discrimination in almost all aspects of public life.

Dr Karamba Diaby
Dr Karamba Diaby, an SPD politician and anti-racism advocate, carries out voluntary work in his constituency of Halle, Saxony-Anhalt. Photo: picture alliance/dpa/dpa-Zentralbild | Hendrik Schmidt

“The results of the Afrocensus indicate that anti-Black racism is widespread in Germany and anchored in institutions,” the authors of the new report said in a press release on Tuesday. “There is no area of life in which discrimination and racism are not extensive problems.”

Though the overwhelming majority of respondents said they had experienced discrimination at least ‘sometimes’ in almost all areas of life, housing was the area where they said they were discriminated against most often.

Just two percent of respondents to the Afrocensus said they had ‘rarely’ or ‘never’ experienced racism in the housing market, compared to more than 90 percent who said they had experienced it ‘often’ or ‘very often’.

READ ALSO: ‘Black lives need to matter in Germany’ New project to uncover racism in everyday life

Experiences with police and security personnel also counted among areas of life where racism was particularly prevalent: 88 percent of respondents had experienced discrimination from security staff ‘often’ or ‘very often’, while around 85 percent had had the same experience with police.

More than 85 percent had also experienced racism in their education or in the workplace ‘often’ or ‘very often’ in Germany. One in seven had lost their job during the Covid crisis. 

According to the report, 90 percent of respondents had also experienced having their hair grabbed, while more than half (56 percent) had been stopped by the police or asked for drugs by strangers.

Meanwhile, 80 percent said people had made comments about the colour of their skin or sexualised comments about their race on dating apps. A vast majority – 90 percent – also revealed they hadn’t been believed when they’d spoken out about racism in the past, or that people had said they were “too sensitive”. 

READ ALSO: OPINION: My experiences of everyday racism in Germany

In spite of widespread discrimination, almost half (47 percent) of the respondents were engaged and active in their community – mostly carrying out some form of social or voluntary work.

First of its kind

Based on wide-ranging data, the findings paint a vivid and concerning picture of what life is like for the one million or so black people living in Germany today.

To produce the report, researchers from Berlin-based Black community group Each One Teach One and Citizens for Europe conducted an extended survey of 6,000 black people from the Africans and Afrodiasporic community to try and discover more about on the everyday lives and experiences of this group. The survey was carried out between July and September 2020. 

It represents one of the first attempts to gather a wealth of quantitative data on this subject, and as such offers some of the first truly scientific insights into anti-Black racism in modern Germany.

“With the Afrocensus, we have succeeded in doing exactly what has long been demanded within the black community for a long time: making the realities of our lives visible within the framework of qualitative, but above all quantitative research,” Dr. Pierrette Herzberger-Fofana und Dr. Karamba Diaby wrote in a foreword to the report. 

Diaby, a high-profile politician within the centre-left SPD party, was one of only two Afro-German politicians in parliament when he first took his seat in 2013. He has since become known for promoting political engagement and empowerment within the migrant and black community. 

In January 2020, an unknown gunman fired shots through the window of his constituency office in Halle, Saxony-Anhalt, in a suspected racially motivated attack. 

READ ALSO: How people with migrant backgrounds remain underrepresented in German politics

Since the Second World War, Germany has avoided gathering data that allows people to be traced by ethnicity as a means of protecting persecuted groups.

However, critics say this approach only works to make the issues faced by these groups invisible. 

Writing on Twitter, Daniel Gyamerah, Division Lead at Citizens For Europe, called for an “action plan for tackling anti-Black racism and for empowering black, African and Afrodiasporic people” and the establishment of advice centres for people facing racism and discrimination.

More research into the intersectional experience of black people in Germany is needed, he added. 

SHOW COMMENTS