Germany's top court could open way to bans on diesel cars

AFP - [email protected]
Germany's top court could open way to bans on diesel cars
A congested street in Düsseldorf. Photo: DPA

One of Germany's top courts will decide on Thursday whether some diesel vehicles can be banned from parts of cities like Stuttgart and Düsseldorf to reduce air pollution, a possible landmark judgement for the "car nation".


Eyes have turned to the Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig after years of failure by federal, state and local governments to slash harmful emissions.

Fine particle pollution and nitrogen oxides (NOx) contribute to as many as 400,000 premature deaths from respiratory and cardiovascular disease per year in the European Union.

That has brought Germany and other air quality sinners like France or Italy into the European Commission's sights for possible legal action.

Some 70 cities in Europe's most populous nation suffered from average annual nitrogen dioxide levels above EU thresholds last year, with Munich, Stuttgart and Cologne the worst offenders.

READ ALSO: Everything that changes in Germany from February 2018

"The air is bad here, you cough and you get a scratchy throat, especially in winter," clean air campaigner Peter Erben told AFP standing beside the exhaust-blackened facades of Stuttgart's busy Neckartor main road.

"We want immediate action, and there is no more immediate action than reducing traffic."

After years of warnings, environmental campaign group Deutsche Umwelthilfe (DUH) took dozens of municipalities to court to force them into tougher action.

Thursday's case is an appeal by Baden-Württemberg and North Rhine-Westphalia states after lower-level judges ruled they could impose bans on some diesels in their respective capitals Stuttgart and Düsseldorf.

An in-principle decision could be announced during the day after deliberations begin at 1000 GMT.

"It's a question of jurisdiction: can or must a state act, or is it up to the federal government to do it?" Baden-Württemberg transport minister Winfried Hermann told AFP.

'Car chancellor'

In Stuttgart, local drivers and business leaders are against even limited driving bans, joined by the city branch of Chancellor Angela Merkel's conservative Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and the pro-business Free Democrats (FDP).

In their thinking, "we can't limit people's freedom, we can't dispossess diesel owners," explained Hermann -- himself a member of the ecologist Greens.

A ruling would affect all vehicles sold before so-called "Euro 6" standards arrived in September 2015.

To fend off bans and protect the keystone auto industry with its 800,000 jobs, Berlin has offered a cascade of initiatives, including a billion-euro ($1.2 billion) fund for cities to upgrade public transport and buy electric vehicles.

Ministers even suggested to the European Commission they could offer free public transport to cut down on urban car use, although without a detailed plan or budget.

SEE ALSO: Your reactions to Germany's 'free public transport' idea

Nevertheless, Merkel -- sometimes known as the "car chancellor" for her close ties to the industry -- and her government have been "too timid" in dealing with bosses, Association of German Cities chief Helmut Dedy told magazine Der Spiegel.

Experts and environmentalist groups agree government and industry efforts fall far short.

Berlin's proposals "are just a drop in the ocean" said Ferdinand Dudenhoeffer, of the CAR automobile research centre.

While he has called for extensive modifications to the diesel engine, a longstanding symbol of German engineering prowess, the carmakers argue they would be too costly and complex.

Instead, manufacturers Volkswagen, Daimler and BMW have offered software upgrades to millions of vehicles to reduce polluting emissions or trade-ins for newer, cleaner models.

Since Volkswagen confessed in 2015 to a global scheme to cheat regulatory NOx tests on millions of diesel vehicles, the fuel's share of the new car market has plunged, from 48 percent to around 39 percent last year.

Right to drive?

Minister Hermann expects the judges in Leipzig to confirm that "people's health is more important than the right to drive a car".

Upholding the court decisions in Stuttgart and Düsseldorf would open the way to local authorities imposing a patchwork of bans.

Stuttgart and Baden-Württemberg state have called instead for a standardized, nationwide "blue badge" that would identify the least polluting cars, but so far the federal government has demurred.

A ruling from the highest administrative court would also send an important signal to other tribunals and put pressure on Berlin.

"I would be very surprised if we escape diesel bans" on Thursday, cities' association chief Dedy said.



Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also