An American shopping frenzy is hitting Germany, but not everyone is happy

The day of shopping bargains on Black Friday and its online counterpart Cyber Monday - both of which have origins in the US - are becoming increasingly popular in Germany. But not everyone is willing to take part in the consumerist frenzy.

An American shopping frenzy is hitting Germany, but not everyone is happy
A shopper passing by a Black Friday sign in Düsseldorf on Wednesday. Photo: DPA.

Traditionally Black Friday lands on the day after American Thanksgiving – on November 24th in 2017. In the US, consumers have used the day as a chance to do a lot of their Christmas shopping. 

With regards to where the name actually comes from, one theory is that it can be traced back to the 1950s when hoards of people in the streets and shopping malls were on the move in many American metropolises the day after Turkey-day, leading to more accidents on the roads. 

Cyber Monday, originally created by marketing companies to persuade people to shop online and often referred to as Black Friday’s less cool sibling, follows three days later.

Black Friday shoppers in Atlanta, Georgia in 2016. Photo: DPA.

Despite their American origins, both Black Friday and Cyber Monday have now gained a foothold across the pond in Germany.

This year the German Trade Association expects both days to generate additional sales of around €1.7 billion, about the same amount of additional sales recorded in 2016.

Black Friday and Cyber Monday are already today very important for trade in Germany, said Martin Fassnacht from the WHU Otto Beisheim School of Management.

“It takes such occasions to make people buy more,” he added.

But while shoppers in Deutschland are less likely to wake up before dawn to get in line for doorcrasher deals or fight over items with fellow consumers in shops on Friday, it seems the days that claim to offer shoppers massive discounts have picked up pace in the country with no signs of slowing down.

Amazon Germany for instance started its “Cyber Monday Week” on Monday, promising customers more than 55,000 deals. Electronics chain Saturn has been advertising what they’ve called their “Black Week” with “the best sales of the year.” The supermarket Real and the department store Karstadt have also been advertising special deals.

The hype surrounding Black Friday and Cyber Monday has already changed the purchasing behaviour of German citizens particularly when it comes to online shopping, according to an analysis carried out by Ebay and research institute ECC.

“There has been a shift in sales, especially from the first half of December to the second half of November,” said vice president of Ebay Germany, Eben Sermon.

But consumer protectionists advise buyers to compare prices for items and warn not to be easily swayed. Samples of the price comparison portal showed last year that only every second offer tested was really a bargain. In the end, buyers paid more for a quarter of the “special sales” advertised than they would have with competing dealers.

Even if dramatic reductions of 30, 40 or 50 percent are on offer, experts say to shop with caution as these often refer to recommended retail prices according to manufacturers – which in many cases are well above current market prices.

Experts moreover believe that the long-term consequences of the consumerist frenzy the two days bring are uncertain.

“Such discount days are a double-edged sword,” said marketing expert Fassnacht. “They increase sales. But such campaigns also strengthen the trend towards a discount society. Discounts are a powerful drug. It is becoming increasingly difficult to sell products at normal prices.”

Twitter users have likewise expressed their disdain on social media. One user tweeted: “Black Friday + Germany = pointless. Who even has money in the pocket? #endofthemonth #broke” Another user tweeted: “Black Friday in Germany? Ridiculous! We don’t have to take everything from the US.”

“Germany and Black Friday go together like the USA and special Sunday shopping,” wrote yet another Twitter user, pointing out that he didn't feel the need to shop on Black Friday.

READ ALSO: Why are shops in Germany closed on Sundays?

It is perhaps curious that traditions like Black Friday and Cyber Monday have caught on in Germany, given that with some of the strictest laws for shopping hours in Europe (if not the world), shops across the country are closed on Sundays. 

Besides, despite big names like Amazon Germany getting on board with the tradition, not all stores are taking part in the shopping frenzy.

Drugstore 'dm' for instance won't be offering any special prices on November 24th. Instead, under the name “Giving Friday,” the company will be donating five percent of its revenue on that day to various educational projects for children and young people.

With DPA

SEE ALSO: Europe embraces Black Friday sales with some reservations


Amazon workers across Germany go on strike for higher wages in build up to ‘online Xmas’

Employees of the online retailer Amazon have downed their tools at several locations across Germany in a protest against precarious wages, but the online shopping giant insists that the strike won’t impact Christmas deliveries.

Amazon workers across Germany go on strike for higher wages in build up to 'online Xmas'
Photo: DPA

In Bad Hersfeld, in the central state of Hesse, employees at an Amazon logistics centre started their strike early on Monday morning. A spokeswoman for the Verdi trade union said they expected about 500 workers at the retail company to take part. 

In Rheinberg and Werne in North Rhine-Westphalia, the strike began shortly before midnight on Sunday evening, with some 500 workers taking part and further 300 workers in the town of Werne joining in.

The union action has hit six locations across the country in total and strike action is set to last until Christmas Eve.

The trade union Verdi had called for strikes at various locations as it sought to push Amazon into recognition of the collective agreements which are commonly established established between trade unions and employer associations in Germany.

“Last week's closure of on-site retail has once again significantly increased the volume of orders placed with mail-order companies such as Amazon,” Verdi said in a statement.

“While the corporation continues to increase its billions in profits, it refuses to pay employees according to collective bargaining agreements. These are minimum conditions,” the union added.

A Verdi spokesman added that Amazon was earning “a golden profit” while workers' health suffered under the stress of delivering packages on time during the pandemic.

Additionally, the trade union said it wanted to push for better health and safety at the workplace in Amazon logistics centres. 

Amazon has always resisted joining in such agreements, claiming that it offers good wages outside of the traditional trade union structures.

Amazon said Monday that its employees already benefit from “excellent wages, excellent fringe benefits and excellent career opportunities.” 

The US-based firm also said that it made health and well-being at work a top priority. 

The company insisted that the strikes would have no impact on customer deliveries in the run up to Christmas, stating that the vast majority of employees work as normal.