• Germany's news in English
German judges' associations call for headscarf ban in court
Photo: DPA

German judges' associations call for headscarf ban in court

DPA/The Local · 8 Aug 2016, 17:09

Published: 08 Aug 2016 17:05 GMT+02:00
Updated: 08 Aug 2016 17:09 GMT+02:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

At present, the German Constitution does not ban citizens from wearing religious symbols. Only in Berlin does a ban exist for employees of city authorities (see below).

But two judicial organisations - the Association of German Administrative Judges and the German Association of Judges - as well as the Ministers for Justice in the states of Baden-Württemberg and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, are suggesting that judges and junior lawyers should be prevented from wearing the headscarf when they are in court. 

They argue that the external expression of religious conviction means that the judicial duty of neutrality is not upheld in the courtroom. 

Augsburg case

The current debate surrounding the wearing of headscarves by judges and trainee lawyers was sparked off by a case in the Bavarian town of Augsburg in June earlier this year during which a 25-year-old trainee lawyer took the Bavarian legal system to court because they banned her from wearing a headscarf. She subsequently won the case.

The Augsburg Administrative Court declared that the headscarf ban for legal trainees, which had been issued by the Federal Ministry of Justice in 2008, was an attack on religious freedom and had no legal basis, as Bavaria does not have a law which prevents trainees from wearing symbols of their faith. 

This was the first complaint of its kind against the headscarf ban for judges and trainee lawyers in Bavarian law courts.

Advocates of the headscarf ban

Following the Augsburg there have been several calls to impose a headscarf ban in courts.

Guido Wolf, Minister for Justice in the state of Baden-Württemberg and member of Angela Merkel's conservative Christian Democratic Union (CDU), is currently working on a law to ban judges and trainee lawyers from wearing a headscarf.

Additionally, Uta-Maria Kuder, Minister for Justice in the state of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and also a member of the CDU, said that obvious expressions of religion in court are inappropriate, because judges and prosecutors represent the state.

“Because there is a particularly strict requirement for state neutrality in the courtroom, every external indication of a lack of objectivity should be avoided,” Kuder added.

Neutral clothing is a symbol of impartiality

So, why are a number of judges' associations advocating the headscarf ban for judges and trainee lawyers at the moment?

Ministries of justice throughout Germany currently require judges to wear a standard uniform consisting of a black robe with a white shirt or blouse underneath, as well as a white bow tie, cravat or neckerchief.

The fact that “male and female judges are all dressed the same indicates to the parties involved that [...] it [the outcome of the case] does not depend on the person, but solely on what the law says”, maintains Chairman of the Association of German Administrative Judges, Robert Seegmüller.

In cases where the litigants have other religious convictions than Islam, it is especially important that neutrality of clothing is maintained, he went on to say.

If judges were to wear headscarves in addition to their basic uniform, people’s trust in the impartiality of the justice system could be shaken, the German Federation of Administrative Judges also stated.

Previous cases

But this isn’t the first time that the headscarf question has been debated.

Back in September 2013, a Muslim lawyer was forbidden from wearing a headscarf in a Berlin courtroom, the reason being that she should show religious neutrality when working as “an organ of the legal system”. 

Under the Neutralitätsgesetz (Neutrality Law) in Berlin, employees of any of the city authorities are banned from wearing any kind of religious or ideological symbol. However, discrimination on religious grounds is not permitted at all.

“The Neutrality Law has nothing to do with indifference to religion or limitation of religious freedom. [...] It is called the Neutrality Law because there are areas like schools, courts and the police, in which the state must maintain strict neutrality,” Mayor of Berlin Michael Müller told Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung.

Story continues below…

In June 2015, a Muslim trainee lawyer was offered a traineeship at a local state authority in Berlin but was subsequently told that they would have to review their decision after seeing that she wore a headscarf. After an exception was made for traineeships, she was then informed that she would be allowed to work there after all.

Weighing up religious freedom with judicial impartiality

At the heart of the headscarf debate lies the issue of balancing judicial requirements and personal rights.

When asked whether judges and junior lawyers should be allowed to wear a headscarf in the courtroom, Jens Gnisa, the Chairman of the German Association of Judges, maintained that it’s about weighing up the personal right to freedom of religion with the judicial duty of neutrality.

“It is important for citizens that the legal system decides on their case in a recognisably impartial way,” Gnisa went on to say.

Constitution must be altered

If the headscarf ban is to come into effect, “it must be made into legislation at the very least; it might even be necessary to change the Constitution,” claimed Robert Seegmüller from the Association of German Administrative Judges.

However, if the Constitution were to be altered to enforce the headscarf ban for judges, the ban would also have to be applied to other pieces of religious clothing and other religious symbols, he added.

For more news from Germany, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

DPA/The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Long-vanished German car brand joins electric race
Photo: DPA

Cars bearing the stamp of once-defunct manufacturer Borgward will once again roll off an assembly line in north Germany from 2018, the firm said Wednesday.

Eurowings cabin crew union to strike all day Thursday
Photo: DPA.

UPDATE: A union representing cabin crews on Lufthansa's budget airline Eurowings has announced that strikes will last all day Thursday as ongoing contract negotiations continue to falter.

Hesse hopes to set example by building Iraqi orphanages
Refugee children in northern Iraq. Photo: DPA

The wealthy central German state of Hesse has set aside €1 million to build a school, family homes and an orphanage in northern Iraq, in an effort to help refugees there.

The Local List
10 German clichés that foreigners get very wrong
David Hasselhoff. Photo: DPA

Whether it be efficiency, humourlessness or a love of a certain Baywatch star, there are many cliches stuck in the heads of foreigners about Germany. But how true are they?

Fake Germanwings victim relative convicted in Cologne
A torn piece of metal at the crash site in 2015. Photo: DPA

A German court on Wednesday gave a woman a year's suspended jail sentence for posing as the cousin of a victim in last year's Germanwings plane crash and obtaining compensation offered by the airline.

Couple accused of torturing, murdering women go on trial
The so-called 'house of horrors' in Höxter where the couple allegedly tortured and killed women. Photo: DPA.

A couple accused of luring women to their village home with personal ads started trial on Wednesday over charges that they tortured and killed at least two of their victims.

After July attacks, govt drafts new video surveillance law
Photo: DPA

The Interior Ministry is drafting a law which will enable public spaces to be filmed for surveillance purposes as a reaction to deadly attacks in July, according to a newspaper report.

Merkel: murky internet giants distort perception of reality
Angela Merkel. Photo: DPA.

Chancellor Angela Merkel called on Tuesday for internet giants to make public their closely-guarded algorithms, claiming that they are not giving people diverse enough information.

Pegida leader 'paid court costs with group's money'
Pegida leader Lutz Bachmann. Photo: DPA.

The leader of the anti-Islam movement reportedly used money from Pegida's coffers to pay for two personal court cases, German media reported this week.

Anger as Berlin scraps Turkey concert on Armenia genocide
The Dresden Symphony Orchestra. Photo: DPA

Germany's foreign ministry Tuesday scrapped a planned symphony performance on the Armenian "genocide" in its Istanbul consulate, sparking accusations that it was caving in to Turkish pressure.

10 ways German completely messes up your English
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Germany's 10 most weird and wonderful landmarks
10 things you never knew about socialist East Germany
How Germans fell in love with America's favourite squash
How I ditched London for Berlin and became a published author
12 clever German idioms that'll make you sound like a pro
23 fascinating facts you never knew about Berlin
9 unmissable events to check out in Germany this October
10 things you never knew about German reunification
10 things you're sure to notice after an Oktoberfest visit
Germany's 10 most Instagram-able places
15 pics that prove Germany is absolutely enchanting in autumn
10 German films you have to watch before you die
6 things about Munich that’ll stay with you forever
10 pieces of German slang you'll never learn in class
Ouch! Naked swimmer hospitalized after angler hooks his penis
Six reasons why Berlin is now known as 'the failed city'
15 tell-tale signs you’ll never quite master German
7 American habits that make Germans very, very uncomfortable
Story of a fugitive cow who outwitted police for weeks before capture
Eleven famous Germans with surnames that'll make your sides split
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd