Lawyer can call politician 'product of inbreeding': court

The Local
The Local - [email protected] • 9 May, 2016 Updated Mon 9 May 2016 09:01 CEST
image alt text

A lawyer from southern Germany faced a fine for calling the Bavarian interior minister inbred. But a court has ruled that he is free to use the insult.

This most peculiar case, decided by a court in Karlsruhe, Baden-Württemberg, has its origins in a headline-grabbing comment by Joachim Herrmann, Bavaria’s interior minister, during a debate on public television about refugees last summer.

Insisting that he didn't have a problem with immigration, Herrmann described Roberto Blanco, a crooner from the 1970s with African roots, as a “wonderful Negro.”

The comment swiftly elicited a mixture of derision and outrage on social media and in the press.

Blanco himself took the mangled compliment in his stride, describing Hermann in turn as a “wonderful white man.”

But others were less than pleased that the Bavarian politician could get away with using such an outdated term.

David Schneider-Addae-Mensah, a lawyer from Karlsruhe who himself is of African heritage, retorted by writing Hermann a letter criticizing his “racist mindset”, the Süddeutsche Zeitung reported on Sunday.

He signed off by writing “Mr Herrmann, you are a really wonderful product of inbreeding.”

The interior minister was less than pleased with the insult. Rather than treating it as a case of a lesson learned, he reported the lawyer to police.

Prosecutors agreed that the insult had gone too far, and argued in court that Schneider-Addae-Mensah should pay a fine.

The Karlsruhe judiciary, though, saw things differently.

The use of the word Negro was “a derogatory racist description” the judge argued, adding that the accusation of racism in Schneider-Addae-Mensah’s letter was therefore accurate and not punishable.

As for the claim Herrmann was a product of incest, the judge said that Schneider-Addae-Mensah had “a right to hit back” - which is a legal entitlement for those whose honour has been damaged by excessive criticism.

In such an instance the affected person can “respond drastically and sharply”, the judge said.




The Local 2016/05/09 09:01

Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also