SHARE
COPY LINK

RAIL

Woman seeks compensation for wetting herself on train

A woman from southern Germany wet herself when the only toilet on her train was out of order. A court case on Friday will hear whether German Rail (DB) should pay up.

Woman seeks compensation for wetting herself on train
Photo: Wikipedia Commons

The journey took place in October 2014 between Koblenz and Trier and has been described by the woman in question as two hours of torture.

She urgently needed the toilet but the only one on the train was out of order.

Unable to relieve herself, she had to suffer in painful silence for two hours until the train arrived at Trier train station, her lawyer has said.

When the train finally arrived, the woman rushed out to use the station toilet, but unfortunately she didn’t make it in time.

Because of this most uncomfortable and embarrassing of experiences, the woman sued rail operator DB for €400.

A court in Trier sided with her in July and ordered to DB to pay the woman €200.

The state-owned train company had failed in its duty twofold, the judges ruled. Firstly, it had not provided a functioning toilet and secondly it had not given passengers a viable alternative.

But despite the minuscule amount of money being demanded, DB are refusing to pay, and on Friday a court of appeal will hear their case.

“In principle there is a toilet on our trains, but we are of the opinion that passengers don’t have a legal right to have one,” the rail operator's lawyer said.

According to consumer group Pro Bahn, DB doesn’t want to cough up the money “because they see it as setting a precedent.”

It is true that passengers don’t have a right to a toilet on regional trains, but there is a “right to have what you are accustomed to”, Pro Bahn’s Karl-Peter Naumann argued.

This isn’t the first time that DB has left passengers exposed after not taking care of their loos, Naumann added.

A year or two ago, when the toilet on a train in the Rhine region was broken, the train company gave a man a bucket to do his business into, Naumann recalls.

As German society becomes ever older, it is more urgent than ever that proper, working toilets are provided on trains, since pensioners are more regular visitors to the rest room than most, Naumann says.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

STRIKES

How to navigate the Deutsche Bahn train strikes in your region of Germany

A standoff between the GDL train drivers’ union and Deutsche Bahn means that rail services will be crippled nationwide in Germany for five days. Here’s the information you need to navigate the strikes in your region.

How to navigate the Deutsche Bahn train strikes in your region of Germany
Berlin central station on Thursday morning. Photo: dpa | Paul Zinken

Deutsche Bahn is encouraging travellers to download the DB Navigator app and to use it immediately before they travel in order to see which services are currently running.

There is some information in English but the detailed lists of which lines are still running are in German. We provide links here to those pages and a brief overview of the main lines that have been affected. (tip: if it says Linie eingestellt, trains aren’t running on that line. 20-Minuten Takt means they’re running every 20 minutes).

SEE ALSO: What you need to know about the German rail strikes

Berlin

In the capital, S-Bahn services and regional train services have been severely impacted by the strike but the U-Bahn is not run by Deutsche Bahn so is running normally. That means that trying to get around by bus and U-Bahn (both run by BVG) should help you avoid the strikes.

If you’re happy to do plan ahead, there are still some S-Bahn services running. This website (in German) details which lines have been completely closed and which ones still run a train every 20 minutes.

In terms of the key lines: the Ringbahn is not running at all in either direction. Nor is the north-south S26 line, the S45 to the airport (the S9 to BER is still running), and the S75 from Wartemberg in the north-east into the city.

All other S-Bahn lines are running every 20 minutes with the exception of the S8 which is running every 40 mins. Not all of them are doing the full route though.

You can plug your journey into this English page run by Deutsche Bahn and it will show you how to best avoid the strike action.

In terms of regional trains to and from satellite towns, there is a detailed list of which lines have been completely halted for the strike and which have a form of replacement service.

The following lines are not running at all: FEX, RB10, – RB11, RB13, RB20, RB21, RB22, RB23, RB31, RB49, RB55, RE/RB66

Other lines connecting Magdeburg, Dessau, Eberswalde, Stralsund, Rostock and Cottbus with the capital are running reduced services.

Frankfurt

The German finance capital is also seriously affected by strikes on both its S-Bahn and regional services.

A full list of the lines that are not running reduced services can be found in German here.

Be careful to check for updates, as the page is updated every day at 11 am for the following day. 

Here are the current services for Thursday and Friday: The S2, S4, S7 and S9 are not running at all. Other lines are running on basic services but often only every hour.

NRW

A large number of regional and S-Bahn services in the west of the country have been completely stopped. These include the RE8 over Mönchengladbach, Cologne and Bonn, the RE9 between Aachen, Cologne and Siegen, and the RB33 between Essen and Aachen.

The S4 through Dortmund, the S8 through Düsseldorf and the S68 to Wuppertal have also been completely stopped. See here for further details.

Updates will be posted daily at 10:30am on the www.bahn.de website.

Bavaria

In Munich, a replacement S-Bahn timetable has been put in place for the duration of the strikes, with long delays expected on most lines.

The S1, which normally runs between the city and the airport, will be running every 20-40 minutes, but won’t go as far as the airport. The S2, S3, S4 and S6 will equally be running a partial service every 20-40 minutes and won’t stop at all stations. 

The S7 will only be running on an hourly basis, while the S8 will be running every 20 minutes between Pasing and the airport, and will also be running every 40-60 minutes to stations further along the line.

The S20 will not be running at all during the strike.

DB has not yet published a detailed list available of which regional trains have been affected in Bavaria, but cross-border services into Austria, Italy and Hungary and likely to be heavily impacted.

However DB say that they will update the travel planner website for Bavaria every day at 12:00 for the following day. You can plug your departure point and destination into that site here or check for general travel updates on here.

Other areas of the country

Various other parts of the are facing impediments to travel due to the strike. The east of the country is particularly affected. For an exhaustive list of all of the regions of the country where lines are not running according to schedule you can peruse this web page (in German).

READ ALSO: Germany’s train strikes: What rights do you have as a passenger?

SHOW COMMENTS