SPD attacked over Hartz IV proposals
Labour Minister Ursula von der Leyen blasted the opposition Social Democrats’ proposals for reforming Hartz IV welfare benefits Tuesday as a “backward” vision that aimed to make recipients “as comfortable as possible.”
Von der Leyen told public broadcaster ARD that the Social Democrats (SPD) would erode Germany's welfare state with its proposal to scrap the means test on Hartz IV benefits.
The SPD has also taken fire from its own side on the issue. Garrelt Duin, an SPD member of parliament and a spokesman for the party’s conservative wing, expressed doubts about the abolition of a means test.
It contradicted “the principle that only he who really needs this help can enjoy the solidarity of the taxpayer,” he told the Rheinische Post.
The SPD leadership on Monday decided to abolish such testing for welfare recipients.
Left party deputy leader Klaus Ernst questioned the credibility of the SPD on the issue.
He told the Berliner Zeitung that a change of policy by parliamentary leader Frank-Walter Steinmeier – one of the architects of the original policy – was unbelievable.
The same applied to a change of heart by former general secretary Olaf Scholz, who was “precisely the man who in 2004 as general secretary attacked myself and others precisely because of our criticism of the Hartz IV laws,'' Ernst said.
The SPD, then in a centre-left coalition with the Greens, introduced the Hartz IV reforms in 2005 under former Chancellor Gerhard Schröder.
Comments
See Also
Von der Leyen told public broadcaster ARD that the Social Democrats (SPD) would erode Germany's welfare state with its proposal to scrap the means test on Hartz IV benefits.
The SPD has also taken fire from its own side on the issue. Garrelt Duin, an SPD member of parliament and a spokesman for the party’s conservative wing, expressed doubts about the abolition of a means test.
It contradicted “the principle that only he who really needs this help can enjoy the solidarity of the taxpayer,” he told the Rheinische Post.
The SPD leadership on Monday decided to abolish such testing for welfare recipients.
Left party deputy leader Klaus Ernst questioned the credibility of the SPD on the issue.
He told the Berliner Zeitung that a change of policy by parliamentary leader Frank-Walter Steinmeier – one of the architects of the original policy – was unbelievable.
The same applied to a change of heart by former general secretary Olaf Scholz, who was “precisely the man who in 2004 as general secretary attacked myself and others precisely because of our criticism of the Hartz IV laws,'' Ernst said.
The SPD, then in a centre-left coalition with the Greens, introduced the Hartz IV reforms in 2005 under former Chancellor Gerhard Schröder.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.