• Germany edition
 
Hundreds of great job opportunities for foreign professionals at Germany's top employers - in cooperation with Monster, Experteer, Stepstone, and CareerBuilder.
What
Where
3,299
jobs available
Find English-speaking professionals with The Local.
Advertise a vacancy
Spaniards, Greeks, cut off from German benefits
Photo: DPA

Spaniards, Greeks, cut off from German benefits

Published: 09 Mar 2012 10:07 CET

The Frankfurter Rundschau newspaper has seen a leaked directive from the Labour Ministry to the Federal Employment Agency - dated February 23 – which bars people who move to Germany from 14 EU countries, plus Norway, Iceland and Turkey, from claiming the basic unemployment benefit known as Hartz IV.

The European Union countries banned include Greece, Spain and Portugal, which has led the German media to interpret the move as an attempt to head off people moving to Germany before they have found work.

Up until now, immigrants from the 17 signatories to the European Convention on Social and Medical Assistance (EFA), signed in 1953, were entitled to claim unemployment benefit in each other’s countries while they looked for work. The ministry has effectively unilaterally ended this agreement, justifying the move by saying that all EU immigrants should be entitled to equal benefit rights.

EU immigrants have only been able to claim benefits in Germany since October 2010, when a French man used the EFA agreement to claim the right in a federal court. Since then, the German job centre has had to pay benefits to immigrants from EFA signatories even if they have come to Germany exclusively to look for work.

“To give EU citizens entitlement to Hartz IV from day one does run the risk of abuse, since anyone can say they are looking for a job,” Ferdinand Wollenschläger, a European law professor from the University of Augsburg told the paper. “But you have to ask how realistic it is that young, educated Spanish people leave their home country to live on Hartz IV in Germany.”

The opposition said it was mystified by the ministry’s decision. “The number of immigrants that start claiming Hartz IV as soon as they arrive is almost zero,” Elke Ferner, deputy parliamentary chairwoman of the centre-left Social Democratic Party (SPD) told the Frankfurter Rundschau.

The Federal Employment Office also said that the directive would have little effect on its work, since immigrants heading straight into the social security system were seen “only in individual cases.” They described the Labour Ministry’s move as a “preventative measure.”

The Local/bk

The Local (news@thelocal.de)


Don't miss...X
Left Right

Your comments about this article:

The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.

ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Your German Career
What do German bosses need to do to get more out of their staff? Frankfurt-based business consultant Justin Bariso has this advice.
Germany's Federal Employment Agency has identified the job sectors the country is most short of workers for. JobTalk looks at where the vacancies lie.
Students at German universities have shown themselves to be a risk-free lot in a survey by Ernst & Young. The civil service is their most popular choice of future profession, while job security is valued above all else.
Jenny Core, originally from Bolton, England, shares her tips in this week’s My German Career on being an artist in Berlin. The 27-year-old exhibits her work regularly in the city, including next to a Turner Prize shortlister.
In this week's JobTalk, Tanya Schober, who is originally from India, talks us through her journey to German citizenship.
In this week's My German Career, Anupama Gopalakrishna, who is originally from Bangalore in India, tells The Local about her new life in Frankfurt.
German Employment News
What kind of companies are hiring foreigners in Germany? And which type of firm should you target for your next career move? Recruitment expert Chris Pyak reveals all to JobTalk.
German employees do the most overtime of any workers in the European Union, Social Affairs Commissioner Lazlo Andor said on Monday.
What do German bosses need to do to get more out of their staff? Frankfurt-based business consultant Justin Bariso has this advice.
Germany’s Labour Minister Andrea Nahles has given her backing to an anti-stress law, announcing a study into workers' mental health on Tuesday.
Germans could foot the bill for unemployment benefits in other European countries under an EU plan to tax the union's richest states.
What do Germans do in their spare time? More and more of them are working a second job, according to one study. Is work no longer paying enough and can your boss stop you taking a second job?

Reporter
The Local in Spain is seeking a reporter to join our growing team of internationally-minded, ambitious, and clued-up journalists. You will be based in our Madrid office covering news and events in Spain for thelocal.es and building this young site's audience.
FULL JOB AD »

IT Officer (Hardware/Networking)
VFS TasHeel, leaders in Visa Processing and Delivery, is looking for an IT Officer (Frankfurt Office) who will be primary responsible for User Level Support of all VFST/VASCO systems
FULL JOB AD »

Assistant for distribution process management
You will be working in conjunction with our wholesale retailer partners and will be responsible for managing and distribution process of various consumer products. As an effective assistant for distribution process management you will organize product delivery to domestic and international customers, ensure that our clients will receive excellent service experience that we are known for.
FULL JOB AD »

Motorhome Bookers
Tlde
Added 09/16/14

PwC
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bigpoint GmbH
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bigpoint GmbH
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bertrandt AG
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bigpoint GmbH
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

EagleBurgmann Germany GmbH & Co. KG
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bosch Sicherheitssysteme GmbH, Grasbrunn
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bosch Sicherheitssysteme GmbH, Grasbrunn
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14

Bosch Sicherheitssysteme GmbH, Grasbrunn
Stepstone
Added 09/16/14