Why could Germany’s €49 ticket threaten semester tickets for students?
A recent legal opinion suggests that Germany's €49 monthly ticket deal could jeopordise the future of the 'Semesterticket'.
Around three million students in Germany have a semester ticket - a special tariff which enables them to use local public transport at a fixed, low cost for a six-month period. The ticket operates on a so-called solidarity model, which means that all students are required to purchase it, regardless of whether they want to use it or not.
Although the Semesterticket was considered a significant social achievement when it was first introduced in 1991, it has faced criticism and legal challenges over the years. Until now, these have been unsuccessful.
But the Deutschlandticket, which allows holders to use nationwide public transport for €49 per month, could pose a threat to the semester ticket model.
Why does the Deutschlandticket pose a problem for the Semesterticket?
A recent legal opinion commissioned by the Student Union (AStA) from the Technical University of Dortmund found that future lawsuits against the semester ticket model could be successful, because, in many cases, it is no longer significantly cheaper than other available transport options.
READ ALSO: Who benefits the most (and least) from Germany's new €49 ticket?
The opinion refers to an argument made by the Federal Administrative Court in an earlier legal case, which said that a solidarity model ticket should only offer a ticket that is significantly cheaper than all other public transport options.
The price for the Semesterticket varies depending on where you are in Germany. In Schweinfurt, in Franconia, the semester ticket currently costs less than €7 per month, but in larger cities like Berlin or Hamburg, it costs over €30, which is almost the same as the new "Deutschlandticket Jobticket" introduced for employees. In Cologne, Düsseldorf, or Aachen, the price for the semester ticket even exceeds €35.
The price difference compared to the €49 ticket could therefore be considered too small, especially considering that students can use it nationwide.
As a result, one university in Brandenburg has already withdrawn from the Semesterticket agreement with the Berlin-Brandenburg transport association (VBB), while a Berlin university has also suspended Semesterticket contracts from the winter semester onwards, and others are considering the same step.
Student representatives now fear that, if local transport authorities don't make the €49 ticket cheaper for students, the Semesterticket model could be at risk of legal challenges.
"If the transport companies do not make the Semesterticket cheaper, we have to terminate the contracts," David Wiegmann, the AStA chairman of TU Dortmund, told the German news site taz.
Matthias Anbuhl, the Chairman of the German National Association for Student Affairs, also said: "The solidarity model is a social achievement that is now in danger of collapsing."
What solutions are being proposed?
The Conference of Transport Ministers (VMK), has formed a working group of representatives from the federal and state governments to develop proposals for a more affordable version of the €49 ticket targeting low-income groups like students.
READ ALSO: Germany's most popular state plans discounted €49 ticket
According to the spokesperson for NRW Transport Minister Oliver Krischer (Greens), who currently leads the Conference of State Transport Ministers, their objective is to introduce a discounted model by the winter semester, though no concrete outcomes have been achieved so far.
One potential solution could be a nationwide semester ticket that is considerably cheaper than the €49 ticket. This alternative has already been given a name: the "Deutschlandticket Uni" (Germany Ticket for Universities).
But introducing this would require an agreement between the federal government and Germany's 16 states, not only on the question of whether and how much funding they are willing to provide but also on reaching a consensus on the conditions.
Comments
See Also
Around three million students in Germany have a semester ticket - a special tariff which enables them to use local public transport at a fixed, low cost for a six-month period. The ticket operates on a so-called solidarity model, which means that all students are required to purchase it, regardless of whether they want to use it or not.
Although the Semesterticket was considered a significant social achievement when it was first introduced in 1991, it has faced criticism and legal challenges over the years. Until now, these have been unsuccessful.
But the Deutschlandticket, which allows holders to use nationwide public transport for €49 per month, could pose a threat to the semester ticket model.
Why does the Deutschlandticket pose a problem for the Semesterticket?
A recent legal opinion commissioned by the Student Union (AStA) from the Technical University of Dortmund found that future lawsuits against the semester ticket model could be successful, because, in many cases, it is no longer significantly cheaper than other available transport options.
READ ALSO: Who benefits the most (and least) from Germany's new €49 ticket?
The opinion refers to an argument made by the Federal Administrative Court in an earlier legal case, which said that a solidarity model ticket should only offer a ticket that is significantly cheaper than all other public transport options.
The price for the Semesterticket varies depending on where you are in Germany. In Schweinfurt, in Franconia, the semester ticket currently costs less than €7 per month, but in larger cities like Berlin or Hamburg, it costs over €30, which is almost the same as the new "Deutschlandticket Jobticket" introduced for employees. In Cologne, Düsseldorf, or Aachen, the price for the semester ticket even exceeds €35.
The price difference compared to the €49 ticket could therefore be considered too small, especially considering that students can use it nationwide.
As a result, one university in Brandenburg has already withdrawn from the Semesterticket agreement with the Berlin-Brandenburg transport association (VBB), while a Berlin university has also suspended Semesterticket contracts from the winter semester onwards, and others are considering the same step.
Student representatives now fear that, if local transport authorities don't make the €49 ticket cheaper for students, the Semesterticket model could be at risk of legal challenges.
"If the transport companies do not make the Semesterticket cheaper, we have to terminate the contracts," David Wiegmann, the AStA chairman of TU Dortmund, told the German news site taz.
Matthias Anbuhl, the Chairman of the German National Association for Student Affairs, also said: "The solidarity model is a social achievement that is now in danger of collapsing."
What solutions are being proposed?
The Conference of Transport Ministers (VMK), has formed a working group of representatives from the federal and state governments to develop proposals for a more affordable version of the €49 ticket targeting low-income groups like students.
READ ALSO: Germany's most popular state plans discounted €49 ticket
According to the spokesperson for NRW Transport Minister Oliver Krischer (Greens), who currently leads the Conference of State Transport Ministers, their objective is to introduce a discounted model by the winter semester, though no concrete outcomes have been achieved so far.
One potential solution could be a nationwide semester ticket that is considerably cheaper than the €49 ticket. This alternative has already been given a name: the "Deutschlandticket Uni" (Germany Ticket for Universities).
But introducing this would require an agreement between the federal government and Germany's 16 states, not only on the question of whether and how much funding they are willing to provide but also on reaching a consensus on the conditions.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.