Row breaks out over call to ease Germany’s ‘debt brake’ for years

A call by Chancellor Angela Merkel's chief of staff on Tuesday to allow further extensive borrowing to help bankroll a post-pandemic recovery has sparked a major ruckus ahead of general elections.

Row breaks out over call to ease Germany's 'debt brake' for years
Merkel and Braun at a cabinet meeting on Monday. Photo: DPA

Helge Braun argued that Germany should abandon its fiscal discipline — enshrined in the constitution as a rule dubbed the “debt brake” — for a few years to help dig the country out of a deep recession caused by the coronavirus pandemic.

But his suggestion immediately ran into fierce opposition from within Merkel’s conservative CDU-CSU alliance. Her spokesman Steffen Seibert moved to distance the government from what he described as Braun’s “personal opinion”, according to German media.

The “debt brake” forbids the government from borrowing more than 0.35 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in a year.

But with entire sectors idled to halt the spread of Covid-19, Merkel’s government has stepped in with over a trillion euros in aid and stimulus to tide over companies and employees.

To fund the help, Germany was forced to lift its “debt brake” for 2020 and 2021.

Braun, chief of staff at the chancellery, said it will take a few more years before Germany can report a balanced budget again.

READ ALSO: ‘Doing nothing would be more expensive’: Germany to take on debt again in 2021

“The ‘debt brake’ cannot be complied with in the coming years, even with strict spending discipline,” Braun wrote in a commentary for the Handelsblatt business daily.

It would “make sense to combine a recovery strategy for the economy in Germany with a change in the Basic Law”, he said, referring to the constitution.

The amendment should prescribe a gradual return to compliance with the debt rule “with a clear date”, he said.

The move should be viewed as a “strategic decision for economic recovery,” added Braun, who is a close ally of Merkel.

By offering more flexibility on debt, the government would be able to hold off on hikes in taxes or social charges, he argued.

Braun stressed however that Europe’s biggest economy must return gradually to its limits on new debt once the recovery is on track.


Markus Söder, who heads Merkel’s sister party CSU, said he was “sceptical” about Braun’s suggestion.

“We cannot solve the economic consequences of the pandemic in the long term with higher debt or higher taxes,” he told Die Welt daily.

“A coherent economic concept is needed. Germany stands for financial seriousness and we should stay that way,” added Söder, who has been touted as a possible successor to Merkel in Germany’s top job following elections on September 26th.

The CDU’s new leader Armin Laschet also stressed in a meeting with CDU lawmakers that his party holds firm to the no-new-debt rule, according to German media quoting sources at the talks.

Earlier, Eckhardt Rehberg, the spokesman on budgetary matters for CDU-CSU lawmakers, had said that “solid public finances are non-negotiable” for the parliamentary group.

Like Seibert, Rehberg rejected Braun’s suggestion as his “own personal opinion”, saying his group “stands firmly by the debt brake in the Basic Law.”

The German economy suffered its biggest contraction in 2020 since the 2009 financial crash because of the pandemic, although the decline was smaller than the slumps seen in other European countries.

Official forecasts predict that Germany will return to growth in 2021 after output shrank 5.0 percent last year, but clouds are darkening as the virus has shown no signs of loosening its deadly grip on Europe.

A new round of shutdowns of restaurants and sporting and leisure facilities first imposed in November and then expanded to include schools and most shops in mid-December is now set to last until mid-February.

But with virus variants first seen in Britain and South Africa that are feared to be more contagious, Merkel’s government has warned that easing restrictions too early could lead to a rapid flare-up in infections.

Economy Minister Peter Altmaier is to present the latest growth forecasts for 2021 on Wednesday, with local media reporting that the expected 4.4 percent gain for this year may be shaved to 3.0 percent.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


‘People liked the silence’: How Berlin’s club scene is struggling after lockdowns

Berlin's clubs are suffering from staff shortages, a lack of guests... and neighbours who've grown used to the silence, representatives for the scene say.

'People liked the silence': How Berlin's club scene is struggling after lockdowns

Some operators from Berlin’s club scene are bracing themselves for a difficult autumn. For months now, people have been allowed to dance again and life has returned to normal in the dark corners of Berlin’s famous nightlife scene.

But the clubs have far from recovered from the pandemic. They face staff shortages, rising prices and the prospect of a return to Covid restrictions in the autumn.

“We go into the autumn with huge fear, because the omens are totally unfavorable,” said association head Pamela Schobeß.

Spring and summer went anything but smoothly, she said. “There has been an oversupply of events. People aren’t going out as much, and some are still afraid to move around indoors.”

Money is also an issue. “A lot of people are afraid of rising energy prices.”

The industry lost workers during the pandemic and it’s hard to convince them to come back with the outlook for the autumn looking so gloomy, Schobeß says.

Her colleague Robin Schellenberg tells a similar story. People have switched to various other jobs and would even rather work on a supermarket checkout, which may have been considered less sexy in the past. Now, he says, some have learned to love not having to work nights.


Schellenberg runs the Klunkerkranich, a small club on a parking garage deck in Neukölln. Because a number of things have become more expensive, they have also had to increase their admission prices.

His impression is that people are going out less often and are deciding more spontaneously. In addition, people in the neighborhood are now more sensitive to noise. “Many people found the silence very enticing,” he said.

Some in the industry wonder what will happen next. Will club admission have to become much more expensive? Will that exclude people who can no longer afford it? And what happens if Covid infection numbers rise sharply?

If masks become mandatory indoors in October, Schobeß believes that would be bad for the clubs. “Even if we don’t get shut down by the state, we’ll actually have to close down independently ourselves,” she reckons.

Masks take all the joy out of the experience, she says. People have drinks in their hands and are “jumping around and dancing” and then security guards have to tell them “please put your mask on.”

The federal government is considering whether states should be able to make masks mandatory indoors starting in October. Exceptions should be possible, such as at cultural and sporting events, for people who have been tested, recently vaccinated and recently recovered.

In the event that Covid numbers soar, the states could then be allowed to tighten the rules and eliminate all exemptions.

READ ALSO: German court declares techno to be music