Can Germany’s history of fire-ravaged cathedrals offer hope to Notre-Dame?

The world watched in horror as flames consumed one of its most revered places of worship - Paris' Notre-Dame Cathedral. It's a feeling that Germans have come to know over the centuries, with many of their most significant churches the victims of fire.

Can Germany's history of fire-ravaged cathedrals offer hope to Notre-Dame?
Cologne's Cathedral lit up at night. Photo: DPA

Nearly every town and city has a place of worship devastated over the past millennia – we know of several early timber cathedrals that were utterly destroyed by marauders or lightning strikes in the early medieval period.

Poor Bremen was unfortunate enough to lose two cathedrals completely to war and lightning strikes – one of stone – before something that lasted was erected.

Bremen's Cathedral, which was burned down twice before being built in its current form today. Photo: DPA

Wars and accidents in the Middle Ages

Perhaps more significant was the blaze that consumed Cologne's cathedral in 1248 during construction work. As part of rebuilding part of the nave (the central part of the church), unwisely perhaps, fire was actually used to demolish and clear its second half – ironically to avoid demolishing it.

Predictably, the flames burned out of control, leaving a smouldering ruin. It was only through sheer bravery that the cathedral's holiest relic, the shrine of the Three Kings, was saved. The edifice we see today, Gothic in style, is the building begun after the embers had cooled.

Not unexpectedly perhaps, the period of greatest devastation for German churches and cathedrals prior to the Second World War, was the 17th century. The Thirty Years war not only led to the devastation of countless places of worship across the German lands, but depopulation, famine and economic crises led to many fine places of worship falling into disrepair.

Bremen's cathedral – again – experienced a devastating fire in 1660, two decades or so after losing one of its towers to a collapse. Speyer's cathedral was pillaged in 1689 and set alight by the French, resulting in the destruction of almost half the building.

Speyer's cathedral, situated in the southwest state of Rhineland-Palitinate and today an UNESCO World Heritage site. Photo: DPA

In 1662, Passau's cathedral was completely razed by flames, leading to the impressive edifice we see today. Consequently, the latter half of the century led to a boom in grand new baroque edfices, as decrepit, decaying churches could no longer remain standing.

Hit hard by the Second World War

Built, as they were, near large population centres, German churches were greatly endangered by bombing campaigns during the Second World War. In retaliation for the devastation caused in the English city of Coventry in late 1940, RAF bombers would use incendiary devices on urban centres during the remaining years of the war – churches caught in the inferno.

Perhaps the most well-known of the churches lost to wartime firestorms was the Dresdner Frauenkirche, devastated on February 13th, 1945. The stark ruins of the church were left as a memorial to the horrors of war by the GDR for decades, before the church was reconstructed in a mammoth construction, completed in 2005.

Alongside the ruined Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church on Berlin's Kurfürstendamm, another church devastated by sustained bombing was the city's cathedral. In 1944, an incendiary device lodged in the lantern – the cathedral's highest point atop the dome. Firefighters couldn't reach it, and subsequently much of the dome collapsed, leaving the church unusable for some time.

Located in today's Kalingrad, Russia, the Königsberg Cathedral is also a spectacular story. It burned down after two Royal Air Force night raids in 1944, and after laying in ruins for nearly 50 years, was reconstructed through private donations. German expellees from former East Prussia were eager to rebuild, despite not being able to attend services in the new cathedral themselves.

In Stuttgart, the city's magnificent Stiftskirche was another victim of allied bombs in July 1944. Fire engulfed the building as a combination of explosive and and incendiary devices rained down upon the city. A further raid later that year, in September, would flatten what remained. Luckily, however, many treasured statues were saved, and they take pride of place in the reconstructed church.

The towers of Stuttgart's Stiftskirche. Photo: DPA

Why are churches and cathedrals prone to fire?

In hindsight, it's not hard to see why the great churches of Germany have been so prone to fire. A combination of flammable building materials, neglect (despite best intentions) and conflicts have made them all too likely to have fires start in and around them.

Luckily, across the country, both the faithful and the non-religious fully understand the power that historic churches and cathedrals have. They've banded together to raise money in order to fireproof these buildings, carry out essential maintenance and make them safe for their intended use.

With their help, the holy spaces of Germany will be preserved for centuries to come, for future generations to take comfort in and enjoy.

Next time you choose to visit one of these places and admire their beauty, consider making a small donation for their upkeep. You won't miss it, and you'll be ensuring that a part of the country's heritage lives on for centuries to come.

SEE ALSO: Notre-Dame blaze: How bad is the damage to Paris' iconic cathedral?

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Germany to tighten Covid controls at French border

Germany on Sunday, February 28th, classed France's Covid-battered Moselle region as a high risk area for virus variants, triggering tougher entry requirements at the border between the two neighbours.

Germany to tighten Covid controls at French border
Image: Peter H/ Pixabay

France’s eastern Moselle region is now listed as an area “at particularly high risk of infection due to widespread occurrence of SARS-CoV-2 virus variants”, Germany’s Robert Koch Institute for disease control announced.

From Tuesday, March 2nd, cross-border travellers from Moselle will need to be able to show a recent negative coronavirus test.

Germany has already introduced tough checks at its borders with the Czech Republic and Austria’s Tyrol region, ignoring calls from Brussels to keep borders within the bloc open.

At those crossings, only Germans and non-German residents are allowed to enter, as well as cross-border commuters working in certain categories of jobs.

Every vehicle is stopped and occupants must produce a negative test that is less than 48 hours old.

The checks on the German side of the Moselle crossing are expected to be less strict, a German interior ministry spokesman told AFP.

Instead of systematic checks, police would randomly stop vehicles on the German side and ask drivers to show “a negative test and their online entry registration”, he said.

Germany has grown increasingly concerned in recent weeks about the rapid spread of new, more contagious strains of the coronavirus, especially those first detected in Britain and South Africa.

The coronavirus, including the more dangerous South African variant, is spreading faster in Moselle than elsewhere in France but French officials have pleaded with Berlin to avoid a full closure of the border.

The German classification “normally implies the extremely strict measure of a quasi-closure of borders”, France’s European Affairs minister Clement Beaune said Sunday.

“We don’t want that,” he said, adding that talks were ongoing with Berlin to find solutions for the roughly 16,000 commuters who cross from Moselle into Germany’s Saarland and Rhineland-Palatine states every day.

The German interior ministry spokesman said the two countries would discuss details of the border implications on Monday.

Asked why the French checks would not be as stringent as those along the Czech and Austrian frontiers, the spokesman said Saarland and Rhineland-Palatine had not requested border closures.

“And there is a good cooperation between the affected German and French regions,” he added.