Perception or reality: Is Germany really gripped by a crime epidemic?

The stabbing of a German in Chemnitz has flared anti-migrant hysteria in Germany. The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) claims Germany is gripped by an epidemic of “knifing immigrants,” but some experts attribute national concern about violent immigrants to paranoia and sensationalist media coverage.

Perception or reality: Is Germany really gripped by a crime epidemic?
Anti-immigrant protesters at Oberkirchplatz in Brandenburg holding placards with the signs "Fed up!" and "Had enough!" Photo: DPA

Murders and rapists have flooded the country with crime – according to Germany’s far-right party Alternative for Germany (AfD). If Alice Weidel, the AfD party leader is right, Germany is in a dire situation. The security situation has “dramatically increased” and statistics from the Federal Criminal Police Office are “in black and white,” she said last Thursday.

Thomas Hestermann, media researcher at Hamburg University of Applied Sciences, however, has reached a very different conclusion.

“The country has become safer despite taking in many refugees,” he said. “It hasn’t been this safe in a long time – but it doesn’t feel that way for many people.”

Crime has fallen sharply in the last 20 years according to the number of crime recorded nationwide in 2017.

“However, the obvious decline in crime in recent police statistics hasn’t given people any reassurance,” said Hestermann.

Rising paranoia

Criminologist Thomas Feltes at Ruhr-University Bochum suggested that Germans are experiencing paranoia about rising crime.

“The citizens are more afraid, although they have less reason to do so,” he said.

Measuring perception of crime risks against real risk, Feltes discovered that public anxiety was 65 times higher than the real risk.

For example, out of the 3,500 representatives Ruhr-University Bochum surveyed in 2016, almost one in five people (19 percent) anticipated being the victim of a robbery, when the real risk was only 0.3 percent.

These results compare starkly to the last survey conducted in 1998, when 65 percent fewer people claimed to have been victims of assault.

Respondents from the 2016 survey also said that they reported crime much more frequently than they did in the past, so the number of unregistered crimes should have decreased rather than increased.

SEE ALSO: What we learned from this year's crime statistics, and what we didn't

Are the statistics skewed?

However, there is a disproportionate number of criminal suspects who are immigrants.

These immigrants are predominantly male and younger and poorer than the average German. But if you compare their criminal activity to a corresponding German group, the fact that they are immigrants becomes mostly irrelevant.

Crime statistics have other pitfalls that distorts the national picture. They include crimes committed by foreign tourists and business travelers in Germany. In a city like Berlin, which attracts 8 million tourists a year, this is noteworthy.

Conversely, the statistics doesn’t account for German offenses committed abroad.

Hestermann attributed increased immigrant anxiety in Germany to media reportage of isolated attacks.

“The German media have once again morphed the violent immigrant into a figure of fear. This approach is completely different from the coverage after the New Year’s Eve incident in Cologne,” he said referring to the sexual assaults and muggings that took place in January 2016 and involved around 1,000 drunk immigrant men. 

The number of television reports of criminal foreigners has quadrupled since 2014, yet the proportion of non-German suspects in crime statistics has increased by only one-third.

Meanwhile, the number of reports of foreign victims of violence has halved but statistics should increase in foreign victims of crimes.

However, Feltes argued that this fact does not necessarily lighten the burden on the immigrant community since the vast majority of violent crimes against immigrants are perpetrated by immigrants.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


German police probe fatal knife attack on schoolgirl

Police were on Tuesday investigating a motive behind the fatal stabbing of a 14-year-old girl on her way to school in Baden-Württemberg in a case that made national headlines.

German police probe fatal knife attack on schoolgirl

According to police, a 27-year-old man attacked two girls on the street with a knife as they walked to school Monday morning in the small town of Illerkirchberg near Ulm.

The victim, a German girl with a Turkish family background, was revived at the scene but later died in hospital, police said.

A 13-year-old girl was also hurt in the incident but did not suffer
life-threatening injuries.

Police apprehended the suspect at “nearby asylum seekers’ accommodation”, they said.

The alleged aggressor was injured when he was stopped by police and was taken to receive medical treatment. He was currently being held in hospital under guard.

Google Maps shows the town of Illerkirchberg, which has a little over 5,000 residents, and sits on the border with Bavaria.

“We will fully investigate this terrible act,” announced Thomas Strobl, Baden-Württemberg’s Interior Minister on Monday. “We are deeply affected…when the life of an innocent child is so brutally taken.”

The crime has taken on a political dimension because the suspect is an asylum seeker from Eritrea. Several politicians from Germany’s far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) used the crime to question the country’s immigration policies. 

In the statement, a police spokesperson asked people “not to harbour general suspicions against strangers, or asylum seekers in general, or to encourage or support such suspicions.”

She said she was aware “that events of this kind stir up fears and emotions.”

The Turkish ambassador to Germany, Ahmet Basar Sen, was set to visit the scene of the crime Tuesday with  Strobl, and the mayor of Illerkirchberg.

“I mourn the girl who was killed and sincerely hope that the injured girl will recover,” Federal Interior Minister Nancy Faeser posted on Twitter Monday.

“The police are urgently investigating the background” of the attack, she said.