“In agreement with state police, Mayor Sven Gerich decided to have the statue removed as security could no longer be guaranteed,” the city's government said on Twitter on Wednesday.
Firefighters arrived shortly after midnight with a crane to lift the four-metre (13-feet) tall golden effigy of Erdogan from the central German Unity Square, where it had been placed on Monday as part of Wiesbaden's Biennale art festival.
Organisers had hoped the statue would provoke public debate relevant to this year's theme of “bad news”.
Since a failed 2016 coup attempt in Ankara, Erdogan's crackdown on political opponents and journalists – including some German nationals – has been closely followed in Germany, home to a large Turkish community.
The statue, which had been posed to point boldly into the distance, was quickly defaced with insults like “Turkish Hitler”.
A “slightly aggressive atmosphere” developed, a police spokesman told the DPA news agency, while city councillor Oliver Franz told the Wiesbadener Kurier newspaper that verbal confrontations had escalated into scuffles and “bladed weapons were spotted”.
“We put up the statue to discuss Erdogan,” Wiesbaden city theatre chief Eric Laufenberg told DPA.
“In a democracy, we have to put up with all kinds of opinions”.
But Emil Saenze, a local representative of far-right, anti-immigrant party Alternative for Germany (AfD) blamed the outcry on “stupidity” by the organizers, who had “given a stage to a despot who spends his time humiliating Germans”.