Supermarket Christmas ad is surprise downer

An ad by German supermarket chain Edeka makes an emotional plea to viewers to remember what's most important during the holidays: family. But did it make the message just a touch too dark?
The commercial opens with an old man coming home with his dog to hear a voicemail from his daughter, explaining that she and her kids can't make it for Christmas this year. Viewers then watch as it seems the old man eats Christmas dinner by himself year after year.
What finally brings the family together is meant to be a reminder of the sad consequences of not spending enough time with family, using the hashtag #heimkommen - come home.
The commercial, posted on YouTube on Saturday, had already been viewed nearly 4.5 million times by Monday morning, and seemed to garner an emotional response on Twitter around the world.
The commercial has already been touted by some as better than certain British chains like John Lewis and Sainsbury's, which are known for their holiday season heart-warmers.
.@EDEKA_D sees #JohnLewisXmasAd and @AldiUK's spoof... and raises them one with #Heimkommen via @ysalannoy https://t.co/oX7jUk6PvQ
— Tom van Laer (@tvanlaer) November 29, 2015
Sorry Britain, but the best Christmas ad this year comes from Germany. https://t.co/zf6MGDUi5W #edeka
— Peter Brönnimann (@PBroennimann) November 28, 2015
Ich glaube noch niemals hat mich eine Werbung so sehr berührt, wie diese : https://t.co/RJr8LshEIK Ich hab geheult wie ein Baby
— BibisBeautyPalace (@BibisBeauty) November 28, 2015
"I don't think an advertisement has ever moved me as much as this one. I cried like a baby."
The ad is a stark contrast to Edeka's previous viral ad campaigns which involved more laughs than tears, like the comical "Supergeil" music video of last year, or the adverts that asked viewers to guess "sushi or orgasm"?
But not everyone found the commercial so touching, with some on social media saying it actually quite misses the mark. Some question whether the video is really moving or rather "tasteless".
Oh God look at this Edeka clip, this is German attempt at doing a sob story Xmas ad https://t.co/zmJ9eH1P8Q BUT IT'S EVIL AND HILARIOUS
— Riotmama (@JacintaNandi) November 29, 2015
Was die #socialmedia Welt derzeit bewegt: Der neue Werbespot von @EDEKA_D https://t.co/7aKKh4bKVS. Rührend oder geschmacklos? #heimkommen
— Carolin Denz (@WildKatCarolin) November 30, 2015
"What is currently stirring the the social media world: The new advert from Edeka. Touching or tasteless?"
A Spanish lottery ad has also tugged at heart strings already at the start of the holiday season, with nearly 3.7 million views over the past two weeks.
Comments
See Also
The commercial opens with an old man coming home with his dog to hear a voicemail from his daughter, explaining that she and her kids can't make it for Christmas this year. Viewers then watch as it seems the old man eats Christmas dinner by himself year after year.
What finally brings the family together is meant to be a reminder of the sad consequences of not spending enough time with family, using the hashtag #heimkommen - come home.
The commercial, posted on YouTube on Saturday, had already been viewed nearly 4.5 million times by Monday morning, and seemed to garner an emotional response on Twitter around the world.
The commercial has already been touted by some as better than certain British chains like John Lewis and Sainsbury's, which are known for their holiday season heart-warmers.
.@EDEKA_D sees #JohnLewisXmasAd and @AldiUK's spoof... and raises them one with #Heimkommen via @ysalannoy https://t.co/oX7jUk6PvQ
— Tom van Laer (@tvanlaer) November 29, 2015
Sorry Britain, but the best Christmas ad this year comes from Germany. https://t.co/zf6MGDUi5W #edeka
— Peter Brönnimann (@PBroennimann) November 28, 2015
Ich glaube noch niemals hat mich eine Werbung so sehr berührt, wie diese : https://t.co/RJr8LshEIK Ich hab geheult wie ein Baby
— BibisBeautyPalace (@BibisBeauty) November 28, 2015
"I don't think an advertisement has ever moved me as much as this one. I cried like a baby."
The ad is a stark contrast to Edeka's previous viral ad campaigns which involved more laughs than tears, like the comical "Supergeil" music video of last year, or the adverts that asked viewers to guess "sushi or orgasm"?
But not everyone found the commercial so touching, with some on social media saying it actually quite misses the mark. Some question whether the video is really moving or rather "tasteless".
Oh God look at this Edeka clip, this is German attempt at doing a sob story Xmas ad https://t.co/zmJ9eH1P8Q BUT IT'S EVIL AND HILARIOUS
— Riotmama (@JacintaNandi) November 29, 2015
Was die #socialmedia Welt derzeit bewegt: Der neue Werbespot von @EDEKA_D https://t.co/7aKKh4bKVS. Rührend oder geschmacklos? #heimkommen
— Carolin Denz (@WildKatCarolin) November 30, 2015
"What is currently stirring the the social media world: The new advert from Edeka. Touching or tasteless?"
A Spanish lottery ad has also tugged at heart strings already at the start of the holiday season, with nearly 3.7 million views over the past two weeks.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.