New assisted suicide law could criminalize doctors

AFP - [email protected]
New assisted suicide law could criminalize doctors
Photo: DPA

Germany on Friday passed a law banning professional assisted suicide services - even if practitioners say they do so purely in the interest of suffering people.


Critics warned however that this meant doctors could now face prosecution for helping their terminally ill patients to die.

The vote came after an emotional debate in parliament, as the issue is still sensitive in a country where the Nazis deployed what it called "euthanasia" to exterminate around 200,000 disabled people.

Under the new law, passed with 360 in favour out of 602 votes, assisted suicide remains permitted in Germany, but anyone who turns it into a professional service -- with or without payment -- faces three years in jail.

In practice, this means that a husband who helps his terminally ill wife to die would not be prosecuted.

But an association or a business that repeatedly offered to help people die would face prosecution.

The situation is not so clear-cut for doctors who prescribe deadly cocktails to patients.

Critic Renate Kuenast, from the opposition Greens, warned that "banning the professionalisation of assisted suicide puts doctors in danger of prosecution".

But Michael Brand, a Christian Democrat lawmaker who co-authored the bill put to parliament, argued that the intention is not to punish doctors but to ensure that patients are not coerced to die.

"Our draft law does not seek to criminalise doctors... it is aimed at protecting people from dangerous pressures," he said.

In 2012, a German assisted-suicide organisation, StHD, pre-empted the new legislation by moving to Switzerland, saying then that it feared prosecution if the German legislation passed.

According to a survey published at the end of October by Focus weekly, 74 percent of those surveyed supported suicide assisted by a doctor, while roughly 20 percent were opposed.


Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also