Berlin treads China human rights tightrope

Author thumbnail
Berlin treads China human rights tightrope

Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle has offered a bright perspective on human rights in China, saying that long-term progress was possible despite some short-term speed bumps such as the jailing of artist Ai Weiwei.


“You have to be aware that we didn’t achieve our Western system overnight either,” he told broadcaster Deutschlandfunk as Germany hosted Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao.

The hosts are facing the delicate job of standing firm on human rights without openly berating its often-sensitive guest and also taking advantage of the considerable economic opportunities.

Germany and China will hold an historic joint cabinet meeting Tuesday and ink several lucrative business contracts, though human rights disputes were still expected to cast a long shadow.

Westerwelle said long-term progress in China was possible despite recent setbacks. He said Germany’s job now was to continue to press China on sensitive issues such as how it treats its dissidents.

“Human rights are not an internal affair,” he said.

Germany recognised its economic opportunities in China but could not lose its internal compass on moral issues.

Previously on Monday night, Westerwelle had told broadcaster ZDF: "Of course you cannot separate trade and development from the issue of human rights, the rule of law, civil rights and also freedom for art and culture. If things are discussed in a face-saving, reasonable way, you can talk about everything, even the most difficult questions."

Chancellor Angela Merkel, Premier Jiabao and a total of 23 ministers are to sign 22 state co-operation pacts while a business delegation agrees deals worth "several billion euros," a senior German government source said.

The globe's number two economy, China, and number four, Germany, have seen trade volume rise by leaps and bounds in recent years, to hit a record €130 billion.

Wen arrived in Berlin late Monday from London where he and British Prime Minister David Cameron signed trade deals worth €1.6 billion while Wen brushed aside questions over Beijing's rights record.

The German-Chinese contracts, which both sides have agreed to keep under wraps until a press conference later Tuesday, are expected to involve cars, chemicals and aeronautics, said the German official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

Berlin has rolled out the red carpet, starting with an informal dinner for Wen and his inner circle hosted by Merkel at a lakeside villa Monday night.

Germany welcomed the release of prominent Chinese dissident Hu Jia Sunday just days after outspoken artist Ai Weiwei returned home following nearly three months in police custody, amid a government crackdown on dissent.

Western nations including Germany had repeatedly called for Ai's immediate release.

But Berlin has expressed serious concerns about restrictions they have apparently been placed under including their freedom to speak to the media.

"I think you have to put the word 'release' in quotation marks," the German official said, while declining to comment about speculation that the end of their custody was timed for Wen's European tour.

Human Rights Watch urged Berlin to place the issue front-and-centre at the talks, saying that Ai's release showed "that political pressure on the Chinese government works."

Activists pledged to hit the streets during Wen's two-day stay.

A group called Tibet Initiative Deutschland said that while Merkel welcomes Wen to her chancellery with military honours, it would release 300 black balloons to call attention to the reported detention of 300 Buddhist monks from the Kirti monastery in Sichuan province.

Relations between China and Germany hit a low point in September 2007 when Merkel welcomed the Dalai Lama, Tibet's exiled spiritual leader whom Beijing brands a dangerous separatist.

Wen told reporters in London Monday that China would not accept "finger-wagging" over human rights.

On the first leg of his three-nation European tour, Wen promised officials in Hungary that China would continue to support its faltering economy, and pledged to similarly aid the eurozone as it is rocked by a debt crisis.

The German official said the issue of China buying more government bonds from debt-wracked countries was certain to be discussed.

Analysts estimate that China has already bought more than €40 billion of European assets this year but this has done little to curb the crisis.

AFP/DAPD/The Local/djw


Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also