Thierse calls €1.30 Kaiser's cashier verdict 'barbaric'
Bundestag Vice President Wolfgang Thierse called a Berlin court ruling that a cashier was rightfully fired after allegedly taking €1.30 in bottle deposits “barbaric,” daily Berliner Zeitung reported on Thursday.
“It’s a barbaric verdict with an anti-social quality,” he told the paper.
On Tuesday a Berlin district court ruling upheld an August 2008 court decision that confirmed supermarket chain Kaiser’s claim that Barbara E., who worked as a cashier for 30 years, had destroyed the company’s trust in her by taking €1.30 in bottle deposits.
During the case, the 50-year-old, also known as Barbara E. and Emmely by the media, claimed that she may have lost her job because she was part of a worker’s union, but the court said it found no evidence of this.
“The court could have decided otherwise,” Thierse said. “It could have, for example, taken note that the woman had worked 31 long years for them.”
Such a verdict can destroy faith in democracy, he added.
The case has inspired union-related solidarity groups and made national headlines, making Barbara E. and her lawyer Benedikt Hopmann minor celebrities.
German courts will not allow the case to be appealed for a third time, but woman's lawyer plans to take the “unbelievable” ruling to the European Court of Justice in a “long, arduous fight with all available resources,” news agency DDP reported.
Comments
See Also
“It’s a barbaric verdict with an anti-social quality,” he told the paper.
On Tuesday a Berlin district court ruling upheld an August 2008 court decision that confirmed supermarket chain Kaiser’s claim that Barbara E., who worked as a cashier for 30 years, had destroyed the company’s trust in her by taking €1.30 in bottle deposits.
During the case, the 50-year-old, also known as Barbara E. and Emmely by the media, claimed that she may have lost her job because she was part of a worker’s union, but the court said it found no evidence of this.
“The court could have decided otherwise,” Thierse said. “It could have, for example, taken note that the woman had worked 31 long years for them.”
Such a verdict can destroy faith in democracy, he added.
The case has inspired union-related solidarity groups and made national headlines, making Barbara E. and her lawyer Benedikt Hopmann minor celebrities.
German courts will not allow the case to be appealed for a third time, but woman's lawyer plans to take the “unbelievable” ruling to the European Court of Justice in a “long, arduous fight with all available resources,” news agency DDP reported.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.