Deutsche Telekom spying scandal shocks Germany

Germany has been hit by another privacy scandal, with telecoms giant Deutsche Telekom joining discount food chain Lidl and the state among those accused of secretly tracking individuals.

Deutsche Telekom spying scandal shocks Germany
Photo: DPA

On Monday, Deutsche Telekom, the biggest European telecoms operator by revenue, was in full damage control mode, with chief executive Rene Obermann telling the mass circulation daily newspaper Bild that all cases of surveillance “must be clarified and result in severe consequences.”

The company acknowledged Saturday it had hired an outside firm to track hundreds of thousands of phone calls by senior executives and journalists to identify sources of leaks to the press.

Deutsche Telekom was responding to a report in the news weekly Der Spiegel, which noted that Obermann was not in charge when the spying took place.

He has since announced that state prosecutors and a law firm in Cologne were investigating the affair.

Deutsche Telekom said it made “ill-advised use of communications data” in 2005 and probably 2006.

But the telecoms operator also insisted it had not listened to conversations or ordered the use of wiretaps by the company involved, which was not identified.

The “personal data of our millions of fixed-line and mobile clients was secure,” Obermann told Bild.

A finance ministry spokesman termed the action a “serious breach of trust,” while union leader Lothar Schroeder, who is vice president of the Deutsche Telekom supervisory board, called the affair “an enormous scandal.”

The state is Deutsche Telekom’s dominant shareholder with a stake of 32 percent, and the ministry spokesman said: “We are assuming that everything is being done to shed light” on the affair.

An editorial in the newspaper Die Welt summed up sentiment of many, however, saying: “Citizens now have a right to demand whether their data is in good hands at Deutsche Telekom.”

Since January 1, information on mobile telephone communications, including the identity of correspondents, the time, place and length of calls must be stored by telecoms operators for a period of six months.

The measure is aimed at helping authorities fight terrorism and places Deutsche Telekom on the front line because it is the biggest mobile operator in the country.

For the left of center daily Tageszeitung, the latest scandal was “more proof that data storage is disproportional and anti-constitutional.”

The German law, drawn up to satisfy a European Union directive, raised howls of protest in the country which because of its history is especially worried by the spectre of a police state.

Measures such as installing secret cameras in terror suspects’ homes and including biometric data on passports have riled civil liberties groups. The country’s constitutional court revised the law in March following formal complaints by more than 30,000 people.

A few weeks later, it emerged that discount food retailer Lidl had hired detectives to install micro cameras that tracked employees, with graphic details and images shocking the population.

Lidl recorded employees when they used the toilet, their conversations while on break and kept track of who their friends outside work were, reports said.

Similar reports then surfaced concerning other distributors, including the Schlecker chain of household goods, further fueling fears of invasion of privacy.

Lidl’s image took an immediate hit from the revelations, while Deutsche Telekom looked set for a similar reaction by clients, millions of whom have already dumped the group’s fixed-line services.


Vodafone makes bid for Kabel Deutschland

British mobile phone giant Vodafone said on Wednesday it had made a preliminary approach to Kabel Deutschland over a possible offer for the firm, Germany's biggest cable operator.

Vodafone makes bid for Kabel Deutschland
Photo: DPA

“Vodafone Group Plc notes the recent speculation regarding a potential offer for Kabel Deutschland Holding AG and confirms that it has made a preliminary approach to KD regarding a possible offer for the company,” the British group said in a short statement.

“There is no certainty that any offer will ultimately be made nor as to the terms on which any such offer might be made,” Vodafone added.

In reaction, Vodafone shares slumped 5.20 percent to 182 pence in London, while in Frankfurt Kabel Deutschland surged 6.92 percent to €79.90 in early deals.