- Germany edition
- Change edition:
- France |
- Norway |
- Spain |
- Sweden |
- Switzerland
Should trains become booze-free zones?
Published: 28 Nov 12 10:41 CET | Print version
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/opinion/20121128-46441.html
Most Germans want alcohol consumption on trains restricted. Should a beer on the Bremen line, or wine on the way to Würzburg, be allowed? Or does the drunken aggression of a few justify a ban? What do you think? Have your say.
- Booze ban for Nuremberg station - Society (18 Oct 12)
- Teen drinking down - but still high - Society (17 Sep 12)
A third of those questioned said they had been harassed by drunken fellow passengers. When asked what the best way to deal with people who broke any new rules, 59 percent said they thought a fine would be the best punishment, while 45 percent said those breaking a booze ban should be thrown off the train. A further 13 percent said a spoken warning would be best.
Currently there are no rules on drinking alcohol on trains in Germany, although over the last couple of years Munich and Hamburg have banned boozing on their metro systems. Some cities have also made efforts to make their train stations no-drinking zones.
What do you think? Should football fans be permitted to drink on the train to and from a match - is an after-work beer during the commute home the same kind of thing?
Would restrictions on booze be a small step in reducing the general social acceptance of drinking? Is that a desirable aim? And how could a ban aimed at reducing the aggression of drunks on the trains even be implemented by the sparse train personnel? Have your say.
Registered users of The Local may add their comments in the field below. If you haven’t signed up yet, you can do so here – it’s free and only takes a moment.
The Local/hc
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
Germany's collective blame phobia
The Germans have a particular phobia – they live in constant fear of being blamed for something. A commentary by Der Tagesspiegel's Malte Lehming. READ () »
First bison born in wild 'for centuries'
A wild bison has been born in Germany for the first time in centuries. The lead female of a herd released from captivity in April gave birth to the calf on May 5th, it was revealed on Tuesday. READ () »
Conservatives demand East German symbol ban
Germany's Christian Democrats (CDU) called on Tuesday for symbols associated with the totalitarian socialist regime of former East Germany to be banned, in the same way that it is illegal to display Nazi memorabilia. READ () »
States to toughen laws on drunken cycling
German state interior ministers are hashing out a plan to lower the amount of alcohol cyclists can legally consume before getting on their bikes. The measures come as figures show one in 10 bike accidents are the result of drunk riders. READ () »
The Doors keyboardist Ray Manzarek dies at 74
Ray Manzarek, co-founder of legendary 1960s rock band The Doors and creator of their signature organ sound, died on Monday in Germany after a long battle with cancer, his manager said. He was 74. READ () »
England fans decry 'German' football jersey
The new jersey for England’s national football team has sparked the ire of English fans for looking too much like the kit archrivals Germany wore when they won the World Cup in 1974. READ () »
'My friends call me travelling x-ray salesman'
In the latest installment of My German Career, The Local spoke with New Zealander physicist Graham Appleby about Hamburg's high intensity x-ray beams and life in Germany's scientific community. READ () »
Germany seeks 'visible' Kosovo-Serbia progress
Germany has called for "visible" progress in implementing a landmark deal between Serbia and Kosovo before securing Berlin's backing for Belgrade's bid to join the European Union. READ () »
- 16/05 'At his final heartbeat I knew I had to act' »
- 14/05 'It's time Germany got over its speed fetish' »
- 13/05 'Germans are nice thanks to my Ami accent' »
- 09/05 Beate Zschäpe: neo-Nazi of mystery »
- 07/05 'The NSU trial is an aim in itself' »
- 06/05 'Racism is in society's wallpaper' »
- 06/05 'You can get pension payments back' »
- 02/05 Boy - the world's smallest film star »
- 30/04 'Women give the Catholic church a future' »
- 25/04 'Messi? I want to be Germany's Ronaldo' »
- 21/05 Far right figure kills himself at Notre Dame »
- 21/05 French ministers face grilling over tax scandal »
More news from France at thelocal.fr
More news from Norway at thelocal.no
- 21/05 Seven arrested over Stockholm's Husby riots »
- 21/05 'The future of freedom on the internet is at stake' »
More news from Sweden at thelocal.se
- 21/05 Richemont brands sale mooted after resignation »
- 21/05 Report narrows causes of fatal Sierre bus crash »
More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch
See all ads | Join the Marketplace
-
Chambervelt Rooselain & Cie Ltd.
Insurance and financial planning for English speakers in Germany -
British Corner Shop
British Corner Shop - The online supermarket for expats -
Weiss Institut
Free yourself from Smoking addictions, Sugar craving and Alcohol addictions -
PsyShrink Munich
The Expat Psychologists in Munich, Frankfurt and worldwide -
PsyShrink Frankfurt
The Expat Psychologists in Munich, Frankfurt and worldwide -
Shiply Worldwide Ltd
Shiply the Online Transport Market Place
857 jobs available
644 new jobs this week
170 new jobs today
- Application Engineer (professional level)
- Database Engineer with IAM knowhow (professional level)
- Manager for our Information Risk Management Team (m/f)
- Program Assistant (m/f)
- Assistant Student Office (f/m)
- Senior Consultant (w/m) Advisory mit Schwerpunkt Tax Performance and Advisory Services / Düsseldorf
- Social Media Practitioner/ Web-Master (m/f)
- Research Director, Telecoms, TV & Media
- Fulfilment Manager (m/f) - Marketing within FMCG sector
- Channel Marketing Specialist
- Apr/09 Touring Tempelhof – Europe’s Largest Historical Monument
- Apr/09 Spring in Berlin 2013 – Where, What Why and When!
- Mar/12 Living Like a Local – Tell us what you think and win a weekend in Berlin!
- Feb/04 Escaping the City – Our Recommended Suburban Getaways
- Feb/04 Berlin Tegel Airport Transfers – How to get into the City
Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your
style? Find a German sweetheart here.
Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather
section.
Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.
Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of
charge.
Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.
Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss
- “Preserve the proven, shape the new” – the International Bach Academy in Stuttgart
For more than thirty years, Helmuth Rilling shaped the international Bach Academy; now he is succeeded by Hans-Christoph Rademann. - ‘Open Mike’ – Fireworks with the Buddha
The Berlin ‘Open Mike’ entered this year its twentieth edition. - On the Stage, the Spoken Word Prevails
In January 2013 the annual meeting of the Dramaturgical Society took place in Munich; its theme: “Speaking on Stage – and about Theatre”... - The Magician of Images – Klaus Ensikat
With the technique of an Old Master and subtle humour, the award-winning graphic designer and illustrator Klaus Ensikat has for fifty years produced ingenious illustrations for literary classics and children’s books.... - A Picture Every Day – Philip Waechter
Philip Waechter, son of the famous illustrator and cartoonist Friedrich Karl Waechter, is one of the best-known contemporary writers and illustrators of children’s books....
- Conference - Pioneers on Dual Training Abroad
Germany‘s system of dual training is one of the foundations of its economic strength. - The all-German final in Wembley
Bayern München and Borussia Dortmund are playing in the final of the Champions League at London’s Wembley Stadium. - German first feature film in Cannes
A directorial debut from Germany makes it to the competition “Un Certain Regard” at the famous film festival on the Côte d’Azur. - Traveling Germany: Europa-Park
Think theme parks:Roller coasters, colorful rides, entertainment, thrills. Think Germany: Europa-Park is the largest amusement park in the country, second in Europe only to Disneyland Paris. - Frankfurt – the digital hub
The Internet hub in Frankfurt am Main is the largest in the world and places Germany in a leading position in the digital world.
- Theatre festival between the Saar and the Mosel
The Festival Perspectives in the German-French region around Saarbrücken is staging European theatre, dance and music productions. - The European Year of Citizens
2013 is the European Year of Citizens. - Europe Day, Robert Schuman and Class 4a
Enthusiasm for the idea of Europe – in the 60th European Competition, schoolchildren from Germany show what this could look like. - Relief organizations
The portals presented here provide information on the help programs offered by different organizations.
- (Junior) Event Manager
- Design Engineer Aerospace in Toulouse
- Design Feasibility Engineer / Craftsmanship Engineer (m/f)
- Electrical Engineer Stationary Energy Storage
- Ph.D. student - Security & Privacy in Vehicular Communication
- Product Safety Engineer – Subsea Services
- Segment Manager Marketing (m/f)
- Business Development Manager Formable
- Finance Director
- Accountant
- 19/05 Car Boot Sale Herford
- 17/05 paid internship
- 17/05 Florida resident seeks job in baden Baden Germany
- 17/05 Berlin Writing Group
- 17/05 cheap car hire
- 15/05 Queen size bed & frame
- 20:33 English-speaking graphic designers in Frankfurt
- 20:21 Claiming tax deductions
- 20:07 Taking my daughter on holiday to Pakistan
- 20:01 Annual Toytown Oktoberfest Party, 100 seats
- 19:32 Translators' meetup, monthly networking event
- 19:21 TT Munich book reading and discussion club
- 19:15 German pillow sizes
- 18:50 Is learning 'der die das' impossible?
- 18:30 Let's cocktail! Ladies Night in Frankfurt =)
- 18:19 Semesterticket price in Heidelberg and living cost
Start trading shares, equities, forex, etc. No commission on equities; Low min. margins. Apply for a CFDs account now!
'Charming, old, beamed cottage for holiday let in Jesus Pobre, Alicante, Spain
www.littlehouseinspain.com/
Professional and qualified consultancy on all insurance and finance matters in Germany, Telephone: +49 2163 571 1740, Email: bg@albatross-assurance.com
www.albatross-assurance.com
Visiting Berlin anytime soon? Book your hotel in Berlin here.
For home-from-home holiday accommodation, search for a Berlin apartment to rent.
Your comments about this article:
1. I was travelling for a field day to München with my family and at the very day, there was an important football game of Bayern M. Train was full of drunk people who behaved least to say inappropriate. I didn't know how to explain my kid such a behavior, awful.
2. Normal Friday night, traveled to Airport using regional bahn. Also full of drunk and stupid people... I was literally scared for my family as I saw some of them, being totally wasted.
BAN DRINKING ON PUBLIC TRANSPORT!
2. While I don't like drunk companies myself, I do occasionally have drink on the train without disturbing other passengers. So, could anybody explain why I should suffer from this stupid drinking ban?
3. ICE trains have silent cars, which is a great idea. Why not introduce such silent cars in regional trains? Problem will be solved.
4. Because drinking in public is one of the few freedoms remained in Germany in comparison with other countries.
5. I lived in a country with drinking ban and there still were loads of drunk people on the train (see no. 1), no difference from Germany.
I'm mostly in agreement with you there.
Point 1 agree - although they will quite often carry on on the train, often with crate of beer they have brought themselves.
Point 2 fully agree.
Point 3. Germans obey the signs they want to. Every time I am in a "quiet" carriage, someone is on his/her mobile .. and ironically they are often quieter than some of the fellow passengers just talking. These are people who are sober. When drunk, most people probably couldn't spell "quiet".
Point 4. Hmmm Jury's still out on that one as far as I am concerned.
Point 5. I have nothing to compare with.
My suggestion would be to ban alcohol on all trains where it isn't sold, and only allow consumption of alcohol bought in the train. Sadly, as you say, most people will get drunk first.
Let the people drink, but control those who are disturbing others
PS. Let us have a beer on the U-Bahn before reaching the party again please!
I agree that most people get on the train are intoxicated prior to getting on.
Restricting the consumption of alcohol will only affect the everyday person that is not being disruptive.
Most importantly, where do the restrictions stop? Once the government imposes restrictions the government¦#39;s power grows and the citizen¦#39;s freedoms are slowly taken away one at a time.
I think DOZ was being sarcastic.
Yes, I agree. Ban alcohol on trains. I am sick and tired of walking on sticky floors because drunks spill more beer than they put in their mouths. Also the amount of broken bottles in Berlin on a weekend night is beyond a joke.
I feel that it should be better controlled and/or restricted to the Restaurant/Snack car on long distance (IC) trains only. It should be completely ban on short city trains, S-bahn and str Bahn. Why should everyone else have to put up with a bunch of people drinking, singing and acting like idiots?
Otherwise,, party on..............
Ban alcohol (booze) on trains: Yes or No.
No.
Why: banning things doesn't do anything to kurb its usage.
As many have pointed out, the reason we are discussing this, is that people are load, rude and aggressive when drunk.
Solution: Ban drinking on trains (a closed environment where people don't have the opportunity to walk away from the problem).
Will this work, no.
Why: because people can still jump on trains/trams totally smashed and travel somewhere (usually home after the party or event).
In a country where more beer is consumed than water in many third world countries (per capita) it's a simple solution that unfortunatly won't be effective.
One of the things I enjoy the most about Germany is it is (mostly) NOT a nanny state. Drink in public, just don't be a jerk. Ban being loud. That is really the problem, not the alcohol. The alcohol only makes it easier to be a jerk.
Absolutely and people behave responsibly in public because of it. Take a look at nanny states - the problem is worse there because the loony fringe is always trying to bend the rules and there are not enough enforcers due to budget cuts.
I've been regularly connected with Germany (residence, visits) for almost 50 years and I can't recall any instances of loutish drunks on trains. The few groups of drunks I have encountered in public were generally subdued.
Bans are easy to put in place. Enforcement is not and there could be unintended consequences like pitched battles between gangs of drunks and gangs of police at 250km/hr. German trains are beautiful, clean, tidy, a credit to the nation. We don't want them wrecked.
Why not compromise and only sell low alcohol beer?
No.
Even if someone already is drunk when they get on the train, letting them drink more will only make it worse. If you cannot handle an hour or two without a drink, you've got some serious thinking to do.