• Germany edition
Photo: DPA

Court rules insurance must pay for ex-soldier's breast surgery

Published: 22 Oct 09 09:09 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/society/20091022-22739.html

A transsexual has won a lawsuit against her German health insurance, which will now have to pay for the former British soldier's re-constructive breast surgery, news magazine Der Spiegel reported late on Wednesday.

Sarah Jane Smith, 51, has been living as a woman since she began the sex change process three years ago in Hannover. But the hormones prescribed by her doctor made her breasts grow from the side of her chest, the magazine reported.

She suffered so greatly from forcing her breasts into corsets and bras that Smith applied to have a corrective operation with the DAK health insurer, with which she has been insured since 1998.

But DAK refused to pay for the €6,000-operation.

Smith took the case to court, and the judge ruled on Wednesday that DAK would have to pay for the surgery.

According to a DAK spokesperson Jörg Bodanowitz, German insurance oversight organisation MDK found that Smith fulfilled the same criteria as a born woman.

“And this examination showed that there is actually a case of malpositioned breasts,” Bodanowitz said, adding that the DAK would follow the recommendation to operate.

According to Der Spiegel Smith discovered her will to be a woman at an early age, and after marrying a German woman used every opportunity alone to dress in female clothing. She divorced in 2003.

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Fark It! Digg This  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

14:39 October 24, 2009 by habitual_line_stepper
I'm sure there are plenty of real women who develop psychological issues because they have small breasts. That doesn't mean that insurance should pay for breast implants. If this person was psychologically traumatized (the story doesn't say that, but clearly there are those who will assume this to be true) by feeling like a woman in a man's body, I am sorry for them. But a lot of people suffer from things they can't change about themselves without surgery, etc. That does not mean that insurance should pay for it. Insurance was originally intended to pay for major losses, not for every little thing the way we expect it to now. And for the record, I think insurance companies are evil as far as most of their practices go. The person in this story has every right to live their life as a man or woman, but they do not have the right to expect insurance to pay for what they need to make them feel better. Nor should insurance pay to clean up the mess they created themselves.
09:11 October 25, 2009 by oopster
The big issue here seems to be "I don't want my insurance premiums paying for this 'man' to become a woman, he chose this", well guess what, SHE didn't choose this. This is a medical condition where the brain and the body don't match, and the only known way to correct the situation at this point in time is surgery to bring the body in line with the brain.

If you want to ban all medical procedures based on what people choose to do in order to lower your insurance premiums then you have to do it for everyone, that means anyone with cancer who smoked, sorry, you've no longer covered, you CHOSE to smoke. Anyone with kidney problems who drinks alocohol, sorry, you're no longer covered as you CHOSE to drink. Anyone getting pregnant who CHOSE to get pregnant, sorry, but you CHOSE to get pregnant.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Today's headlines
Photo: DPA

Europe’s German agenda

As Europe continues to fumble its way through its debt crisis, can Germany’s reforms from a decade ago really serve as an example for the rest of the Continent? The Local’s Marc Young look back to see an agenda for the future. READ (9 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Bestiality brothels spur call for animal sex ban

Animal sex abuse is on the rise in Germany, with bestiality brothels being set up across the country, according to a state animal protection officer demanding stronger laws to protect mankind's furry and feathered friends. READ (19 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Hamburg sues over pricey, late concert hall

Hamburg city is suing the firm building its landmark new concert hall for going tens of millions of euros over-budget and being at least four years late. READ (1 COMMENT) »

Italian children remember people killed by the Nazis. Photo: DPA

Germany not responsible for Nazi-era crimes

The United Nations’ highest court declared Friday that modern day Germany isn’t responsible for Nazi war crimes in Italy, saying Rome breached international laws when its courts allowed compensation claims to be made. READ (19 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Cake in the face for 'Baron Cut-and-Paste'

Critics of disgraced former German Defence Minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg hit him in the face with a big cake on Thursday night, while he was meeting a Pirate Party politician in a Berlin café. READ (14 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Most Germans want president to resign

Most Germans now want President Christian Wulff to resign, as the flow of allegations over his behaviour and investigations into his relationships with businesses continues to damage his credibility. READ (4 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Thousands of US troops leaving Bavaria

The US military will close bases at Bamberg and Schweinfurt in the German state of Bavaria by 2015 as part of a planned drawdown of its forces stationed in Europe. READ (11 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Judge jails wrong-way crash driver indefinitely

A 35-year-old man who deliberately drove the wrong way down a south German motorway and crashed head-on into a car, killing one person has been jailed for 12 years but may be held indefinitely under preventative detention rules. READ (7 COMMENTS) »

More Society
Highlights
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
Germany’s public transportation largely operates on the honour system, which makes fare dodging easy. You can have your say on how Germany should deal with the problem.
Photo: DPA
SOCIETY »
Macho German football legend Rudi Assauer says he has Alzheimer’s Disease, an admission one expert told The Local could help stoke discussion of an illness often considered taboo.
Photo: DPA
SOCIETY »
A 64-year-old tub of American lard has been deemed fit for human consumption by food safety authorities in the eastern German state of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania.
Photo: Yves Gabriel
LIFESTYLE »
What's on in Germany: February 2 - 8
Photo: Columbia Pictures
LIFESTYLE »
The Local's English-language movie listings for Germany
Photo: DPA
LIFESTYLE »
As Hamburg’s legendary Reeperbahn strip gentrifies, Stephen Lowman reports how the city’s “sinful mile” is changing.
Photo: DPA
SOCIETY »
The urban street slang spoken by young Germans is so distinct that one language expert is arguing for it to be recognised as a proper dialect.
Photo: Bavarian International School
SPONSORED ARTICLE
A global education - a Bavarian community
Photo ECLA
SPONSORED ARTICLE
A truly international education at the heart of Berlin



See all ads | Join the Marketplace

Jobs in Germany, in English

1305 jobs available
783 new jobs this week
0 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Blog
Essentials

Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your style? Find a German sweetheart here.

Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather section.

Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.

Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of charge.

Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

News from the Goethe-Institut
News from Young Germany
News from DeutschlandOnline

Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd
English-speaking educators (native level)

Hotel reservations in Berlin
Visiting Berlin anytime soon? Book your hotel in Berlin here.
Rental apartments in Berlin
For home-from-home holiday accommodation, search for a Berlin apartment to rent.
Trade CFDs with InterTrader.com
Start trading shares, equities, forex, etc. No commission on equities; Low min. margins. Apply for a CFDs account now!