February 23, 2012
Published: 30 Sep 10 09:36 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/politics/20100930-30177.html
More than half of Germans see Muslim immigrants as a drag on the country, a poll published Thursday has found.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
Germany's armed forces and police currently operate 331 high-tech drones inside and outside the country, and the government intends to swell the fleet, according to a media report that has alarmed civil rights advocates. READ (2 COMMENTS) »
Spring is coming ever closer in Germany, as mild temperatures and light rain are forecasted for the next few days. But nights will remain frosty in the south, the German Weather Service (DWD) reported. READ »
Despite plenty of transatlantic tensions over the eurozone debt crisis, US President Barack Obama phoned German Chancellor Angela Merkel to congratulate her on concluding a new Greek bailout deal. READ (10 COMMENTS) »
Frankfurt Airport's tarmac traffic controllers have called off their five-day strike after the company that runs Germany's largest air hub offered to negotiate over their wage demands. READ (6 COMMENTS) »
A 29-year-old German man has been charged with conning Walter Mixa, a former Catholic bishop who resigned following child abuse allegations, out of nearly €5,000. READ (3 COMMENTS) »
The Council of Europe's anti-torture committee on Wednesday urged Germany to abolish the surgical castration of sex offenders, warning that the operation could amount to "degrading treatment." READ (17 COMMENTS) »
Germans generally agree that Joachim Gauck is a good choice for president. But can the ex-pastor be the nation's moral authority while staying married to one woman yet living with another set to become First Lady? Have your say. READ (11 COMMENTS) »
Megaupload.com boss Kim Dotcom was freed on bail in a surprise move Wednesday, after a New Zealand judge dismissed fears he would flee the country to escape US online piracy charges. READ (2 COMMENTS) »
See all ads | Join the Marketplace
1248 jobs available
700 new jobs this week
0 new jobs today
More news from Sweden at thelocal.se
More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch
More news from France at thelocal.fr
More news from Norway at thelocal.no
Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your
style? Find a German sweetheart here.
Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather
section.
Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.
Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of
charge.
Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.
Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss
Your comments about this article:
But interesting that only 1/3 believe Germany is becoming dumber because of immigration, with so many Germans thinking that all Muslims are immigrants and coupled with the reported fact that so many Germans oppose Google's Street View on ground of privacy, I would have thought Germany was already pretty dumb.
The work permit thing happened to Europeans too, even when European law prohibited it, unless you are a German with German qualifications then "they" really don't look kindly on anything beyond the border.
_______________________________________
@Hicham1st
I'd say it is nothing wrong with Muslims, it is these closed minded biggots who are afraid of what they do not know and are too stupid to think for themselves and make their own mind up.
wake up.
its a fact that e.g. most turks ARE muslims. it's a LITTLE BIT different than europe = christians because your right THAT is most of the time not the case.
maybe you should also read a little bit about what happens to muslims who try to get out of the islam: they get deathtreats, but not only them, the hole famaly and so on.
i wonder if guys like you will ever wake up or only will do so if its all to late. how did this one great muslim say: "we conquer europe without even shooting one bullit" ...
please have more places for kindergartens!! how could my child integrate if they are always full?
As per law:
If any immigrant (or foreigner) is paying taxes (working) more than 60 months (or 5 yrs), he/she is eligible for permanent stay (Daueraufenthalt) in Germany.
The points you have mentioned about uneducated and unskilled people of getting free rooms on basis of being Asyl, getting money from government and working illegally (schwarzarbeit) is 100% true.
I meet such people everyday as Asylheim (Asylantenheim) is near to my room and i stay in a town (kleinstadt) where one meet or see same people many times in a week.
At present I am suffering from German laws to get family-reunion-visa for my wife. She is well educated (CA - charterd accountant) and working as software consultant. Even after having all the required documents with us, Ausländerbehörde is not interested to start the visa process from here. We both were in person to the Ausländerbehörde here as she is in Euope on Schengen Visa.
The rule is:
- She can not apply from Germany for family-reunion-visa as she is on schengen visa. OR
- She can not apply from Germany as I am not having Daueraufenthalt.
As I don't have Daueraufenthalt, I can't properly invest in my new house because I don't know when they will kick me out if i loose my job.
I wonder what they are going to prove different from the same documents in German Consulate, Mumbai.
The Ausländerbehörde person could hardly UNSTERSTAND English and can't speak English. Still we foreigners must do Integrationkurs, but not these people. My wife has some words with the person in English.
(Ich verstehe kaum, was Sie sprechen. Vielleicht meiner Kolleg versteht Sie besser als Ich.)
Next generation of uneducated and unskilled people can not be that intelligent. So i suppose, issuing visa (if possible - passports) for educated immigrants is beneficial for Germany and its future.
Regarding more laws - rules and regulations for immigrants in Germany, visit trust7 website.
Just have patience, improve German language, study their laws and take action quickly whenever you falls in any categorey of laws. That is beneficial for our career and life.
Your post is shows what I believe to be the root cause of the issues of immigration; you expect to be treated differently to the indigenous society. This "special treatment" breeds the contempt and anti-outsider feelings that the report details.
My wife and I came to live in Germany over 8 years ago, initially on a temporary contract but are 100% settled. We don't expect any special help from the state, have taught our children German and worked at understanding the traditions and culture of the country which we have chosen to make our home. WE have made these efforts, WE have integrated ourselves into the German culture, WE have educated our children with the language skills.
Anyone wishing to live in another country has to work at integrating, you cannot expect the new country to take on your native lands traditions. You take the country for what it is, the rough with the smooth and if you don't like it you move back. Too many people nowadays expect everything to be handed to them on a plate without putting in their own efforts.
So coming back to the original report I believe most of the negativity surrounding immigration is down to the expectations and willingness to integrate of the immigrants themselves. Unfortunately what I see is the Turkish and Muslim immigrants general unwillingness to integrate into the host society but instead try to change area's of the host to their own liking. (I accept this is a generalisation and I really don't want to offend any specific groups, but it is what we see) Thus articles and surveys like the one reported exist.
Theses is the the plural of Thesis.
'Die Muslime sind unser Unglück!'
hmmm...that sounds familiar somehow...
In other news, most german see "....." as a burden
In other news, most german see "fill as you wish" as a burden.
Where did I hear this story before... uhm..
History teach us that we don't learn anything from history.
You make a very good point re: the (often dubious at best) "asylum" system and how it slaps the face of those who wish to immigrate, integrate, and contribute to the host society. European leadership needs to learn that quality is more important than quantity, and that no nation, Germany included, is obligated to accept as many self-titled asylum seekers as possible, especially those with a proven track record of unwillingness to adapt and integrate.
http://www.thelocal.de/advertise.php
Is it the good practice of a publishing house when they have 7500,000 visitors a month?
i agree!
You are very ignorant. Either you have nazi thinking or your comments shows your frustration...
If you are who I think you are, I'll see you in the morning, oh and you can't play football to save your life :-)
Back on topic....
They don't want us to integrate, proof of this was given when I applied for German citizenship not to long ago. I went to the right Amt and said what I wanted, had all the relevant paperwork (or so I thought) and we started the process. The lady who was dealing with my case then asked for my Basic German Language qualification certificate, which I don't have. Granted we had been chatting away in German for about 10 minutes at this point, so she said I would have to go to the VHS and do that course before we could continue. I was somewhat dismayed and asked her to be so kind as to check that the rest of my documentation was in order, which it was. I then asked her about the Einbürgerungstest. This is what made me re-think and laugh at their system. She explained that the test consisted of 330 possible questions with 33 questions on each test paper, as she paused I then asked if it would be possible to take the test in the English version. Her face was a picture and she never saw the trap being sprung. Her reply was that it was in German only, Oh why does that not count as enough knowledge of the Germany language then? Does not compute, fatal error messages were being spewed out from her. Okay so now I'm going to the VHS to do the more advanced course, because they teach more grammar than the basic one. When I have finished the course I may go back with that certificate and try again, damn, probably won't work as I'll still need that course certificate that she recognizes. BTW I have now been here since 1984........
Please show me the case when an upper cast Hindu in India fined a
lower cast woman for touching his dog.
You are a joker....or you have a gene named NAZ_I_SM_000.
dude, just ignore him. No need to reply.
He is omitting same stuff here, what he has commented on Al-Qaida News for me.
News: Al-Qaida plot to attack Germany discovered
Why did not you told me that you were Pakistani Muslim....had you have told me earlier i would have not waste my time in replying you...leave India alone...Atleast in India our Muslims brothers can read namaaz peacefully..just see in Pakistan how you are killing each other and bombing the mosques in name of Shias, sunnis,admediyahs...Illegal Pakistanis feel ashame to call themselves Pakistanis and says that they are Indians when they have to find a girlfriend or job...You can write as much as you can against India but remember we are not the BEGGAR NATION like you who always survive by begging from USA.
All of the terrorist on 9/11 were from Muslim countries.
The night club bombing in Bali, the commuter train attacks in London and Madrid, the hotel attack in Mumbai India, along with many other acts of terrorism were all done by Muslims.
The must disturbing situation of all, in the world today, is the nuclear ambitions of Iran. It is something that may lead to World war 111.
Most Germans are nice people. So are Americans, British, French, Dutch and other Western people. It's just that they would rather not have Arab/Muslims around, due to all of the problems.
Are you German?
Do you think that no-German is living as single or with-family out of Germany/Europe/US???
Many decisions are depends on present and past facts. So such surveys (this article - facts) can be useful for GERMANY to have better laws for immigrants in future.
Many educated immigrants doesn't come to Germany just to earn more and more money and to get German passport. But in return they can give much more to the country.
It is problem of Germany (from article) which has been occured by allowing here lots of such people who are illiterate (ungebildet) and/or less educated, unskilled.
For ex.: Less educated immigrants work at Amazon in packing department after issuing work-permit for him. He doesn't need German language to earn money.(or very less) Such workers can earn around 1000 Euro per month or more which is a very good amount as one can survive with around 600-700 Euro here. Around 300 Euro is his net saving which is a big amount for him because of currency value.
When you make a survey of such immigrants working in Germany (at differnt companies, shops etc) who came here illegaly, were assyl and/or less educated but holds german passports, you will wonder what kind of laws has been made that today Germany is facing such problems because of immigrants.
Amazon is just one example.
If there were better laws, today many Germans had jobs atleast on low wages.
Every coin has two sides. So all immigrants or all muslims can not be burden here.
Give and take policy creats win-win situation for immigrants and Germany.
One gentleman has commented about Hindus. Perhaps my honorable friend is devoid of any knowledge about Sanatandharm ,popularly known as Hinduism.It should be born in mind that the Muslims are in turmoil and in restless state all over the world. Have you seen Hindus? They are peace loving people and quickly mingle with the locals where ever they go. Some of them have even converted into Christianity in UK and USA.(Boby Jindal governor of Luciana state USA) Many of my friends are in Germany and are adding to the wealth of that country. Have you found a Hindu planting a bomb in Germany?Whereas my Muslim brothers break and damage the same plate they are given to eat in(not the entire community) But by and large today the entire community is restless and is busy in damaging a well established social norms and rules.THIS ISLAM NEEDS A TEACHER FROM BUDDHISM AND JAINISM TO TEACH THEM LESSONS OF PEACE , LOVE AND AFFECTION. THEY HAVE KILLED COUNTLESS NUMBER OF PEOPLE ALL OVER THE WORLD IN THE NAME OF ALLAH. IT IS MY HUMBLE REQUEST TO THE FOLLOWERS OF ISLAM TO REWRITE QURAN AND REDEFINE ISLAM SO THAT THE WORLD CAN BE A BETTER PLACE TO LIVE IN..
By the way, your CAPS LOCK is stuck.
Other than that, nice thought.
A million $ question to you: Who build the world wonder Taj Mahal that is main source of tourism economy of your homeland?
Pay respect to that man, talk about him and his religion with respect because he was your Muslim King!
I'm inique because I care about Deutschland the most. And as a REAL FOLLOWER OF JESUS, I wish the best very for all people.
And although I see Christianity as being the unltimate religion, yet I subscribe to the non-emotionalism of Buddhaism. It is the force that binds man to perfection.
I'm now absolutely sure, beyond even a shred of doubt, that ALL of humanity's problems can be solved through non-emotionalism. Anger, fear, bitterness and hate, depression, a lack of identity and therefore violence, could all become things of the past.
Perhaps there is hope for humans. They just have to look beyond their own world and imagine having God-like intelligence.
The issue is not religion, but mentality. Go to India, as a White foreigner, and see how you are treated (basically as a sucker with a Euro sign on your head)
As for history, let's face it, all the major monuments in India that Foreigners are charged TWICE as much as locals to visit, are not Hindu, but PERSIAN.
So shall we talk about fairness? Then it should be a two way street. Why come into the Western countries demanding We change our ways. When we go to your countries, we are expected to "respect and abide" by your cultural modes. Is it politically in-correct to demand the same courtesy? I don't think so.
We have, equally, spent hundreds of years builiding our societies and cultures, in our countries, respect and abide by them when you come our way. Our generations of work was not expected to support the entire world for free.
Welcome to our countries, now, get to work, just like the rest of us. And, as for religion, keep it private or, keep it at home.
Immigration rights SHOULD be a two way street......
check these articles...
http://www.stephen-knapp.com/was_the_taj_mahal_a_vedic_temple.htm
http://www.flex.com/~jai/satyamevajayate/tejo.html
Islam is going to exist in India.
But saying Islam brought culture to India is like saying Engineering skills was brought to Germany by Turks.
To all those patriotic Pakistanis. I do respect your love for your country & religion. But calling showering hate speech on others is why the world hates you. Grow up guys.
Just try getting permission to stay in India. Oh yes, you can get a 6month tourist visa but at the end of it you MUST leave or be fined. No way to get it renewed (verlaengert). As a foreigner you're not allowed to buy property, you can hold a lease but again, as a foreigner, only for 5 years. No current account at a bank, can't register a motorbike or car, get ripped off just about everywhere you go unless you get nasty. Cops will take bribes as a normal day to day duty if you happen to fall foul of a traffic law, the list is endless. Do any of these things to foreigners here and the law comes down on you like ton of bricks.
We must throw away all our sensible progress like democracy to avoid losing something nobody can quite define - sounds dubious to me. Particularly as the heritage that we are supposed to be protecting is actually a complete mishmash of other cultures that have gone before
(especially about Sankrit language - thanking you in advance)
1 -
which websites did you use for your research?
let me guess, Islamic or wiki or BBC?
Don't you know about Yoga, Meditation, Vedic Mathematics, Sanskrit?
There are countless yoda-meditation classes around the world.
NASA, the most advanced research center in the world for cutting edge technology, has discovered that Sanskrit, the world's oldest spiritual language, is the only unambiguous spoken language on the planet.
Sanskrit is the most ancient member of the European family of languages. It is an elder sister of Latin and Greek from which most of the modern European languages have been derived. The oldest preserved form of Sanskrit is referred to as Vedic.
Until 1100 A.D., Sanskrit was without interruption the official language of the whole of India. The dominance of Sanskrit is indicated by a wealth of literature of widely diverse genres including religious and philosophical; fiction (short story, fable, novels, and plays); scientific literature including linguistics, mathematics, astronomy, and medicine; as well as law and politics.
With the Muslim invasions from 1100 A.D. onwards, Sanskrit gradually became displaced by common languages patronized by the Muslim kings as a tactic to suppress Indian cultural and religious tradition and supplant it with their own beliefs. But they could not eliminate the literary and spiritual-ritual use of Sanskrit.
google: sankrit computer
Many to name which is present in India since thousands of years when muslims were not in existance anywhere.
When you talk muslims brought civilisation in India, then you MUST not be aware about present financial situation of Pakistan, growth curve and developments there.
Population of hindus is continously decreasing there. Reason behind it can be scary than imagination. But muslims population is continuously increasing in each country whereever they have spreaded.
2-
India is a developing country so there are still many negative aspects where we should do improvements.
Despite many loop holes we have organised Commonwealth Games in India which is going to start from tommorrow. We hope that the competition bring succes to our nation and it happens peacefully.
"Britain's Prince Charles and wife Camilla Parker Bowles, the Duchess of Cornwell, arrived in New Delhi on Saturday on a three-day visit to India during which they will attend the Opening Ceremony of the Commonwealth Games
In addition, Charles spend time with athletes from a broad cross-section of Commonwealth countries.
This is the biggest Commonwealth Games ever, featuring around 7000 athletes and officials from 71 countries, who are currently based at the swanky Games Village on the banks of the river Yamuna."
As I said earlier, every coin has two sides.
So, it's upto you which side to notice and make your mind about India.
the comment should have been made on ``middle east`` and not MUSLIMS generally.
The people using Islam to cover up for terrorism are only doing that for their pockets. I wonder why Saudi Arabia is not involved
good one mehta ji.
@supernova..
"Dhua dhua ho raha hai sama kahi tho hai aag lagi"
http://greatreporter.com/mambo/content/view/372/8/
I know you are ripping foreigners off by offering Ayurveda and meditative crap even by using your women for giving birth for barren parents with money but this is NOT the point here. The argument focuses on ignorant inhuman practices, as mentioned above, regulated by Hindus in India including suppression of minorities in states like Jammu & Kashmir etc....
seems you too paki like your other barking fellows.
there were many kashmiri pandits, kashmiri Brahmins in Jammu and Kashmir. Such pandits and brahmins were never minor and are not minor. As, many terrorists killed such kashmiris that could make many pakis (muslims) to capture pakistan. that's why there is POK (pakistan occupied kashmir) now. Pakis are illegaly and forcefully entering in India.
If you can bring civilisation and know well about making life better with excellent thoughts, then why do you keep begging in front of USA? Why can not you develop after receiving hell of financial help? Who are talibanis? Where are the originally from?
Our problem is we keep tolerating you for sake of having peace between neighbouring countries. Whenever we have taken any step to create peace, pakis backstabbed us.
The problems you and your countrymen are mentioning about India doesn't create violence around the world. What terrorists are doing in name of Islam or Allah is dangerous to every nations where muslims have migrated.
If you muslims are so civilised people then,
- why there is flow from people from Pakistan to India and not otherway around? (for ex. participation in reality shows, singers etc)
- why hindu population is decreasing in pakistan?
- Why many Pakis are having 'Indian Restaurants', 'Indians Shops' all around the world?
You use name of India to earn money for yourself and your family and at the end of the day you keep abusing India.
Germans are very developed, having many patents on their name, having latest technologies, still keep improving which is possible because of their education, efforts and willing to contribute to their nation.
Muslims give first preference to religion and then to country. So when there will be days when muslims will give in return something good to the countries where they are surviving?
Will German-muslims be like Germans to come up with innovation, better technologies here in Germany?
Time for others, particularly middle-eastern immigrants to live up to the West's standards and level of tolerance. The onus is quite obviously not on the West to prove that they have contributed largely to society as a whole, nor that they are tolerant of other cultures and beliefs. Last I heard, Germany itself had the most liberal immigration policy in the world.
Now is the time for an Islamic Reformation. Muslims everywhere. Take a look in the mirror. Now remove the beam from your eyes before continuing to point out the splinters in the eyes of Westerners. I'm sure you understand.
Westerners, stand up for yourselves and be united. Your cowardice makes me almost as sick as the double standards of the middle east.
have a look on youtube for: Muslim Demographics
video: 7:31 min