• Germany edition
Analysis & Opinion
Have your say
Photo: DPA

Should Germany hit the rich with a wealth tax?

Published: 11 Jul 12 16:47 CET | Print version
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/opinion/20120711-43701.html

A respected economics institute has suggested a one-off tax for the wealthiest in Germany, to raise €230 billion to shore up national debt. Would such a measure kill investment in the country or is it a fair idea? Have your say.

The German Institute for Economic Research (DIW) calculated that if the wealthier members of society were taxed a one-off chunk of ten percent of their fortunes over and above €250,000 per head, it could make a real difference to reducing the country's debt.

The tax could even be tied into a mandatory bond scheme – where the state promises to pay back the money with interest as and when it can.

The idea is that such a “capital levy” – a one-off wealth tax – would only benefit the economy as it would not reduce all-important consumer demand. Reasonable personal allowances would be drawn up to make sure the tax does not impoverish people, and there would be measures to protect businesses.

But could such a tactic destroy trust and faith in the system? Would it encourage rich people to hide their wealth, or even leave the country? Is it the kind of ‘eat the rich’ solution offered up in student debates?

A writer at the Frankfurter Rundschau argued that those hit by the levy would also be those who would most benefit most from a stabilisation of the financial system and expensive bank bailouts.

Would it be fair to expect the wealthiest among us to contribute to keeping the national debt to sustainable levels and so help keep the crisis from crossing Germany’s borders? Or would Germany be shooting itself in the foot?

Registered users of The Local may add their comments in the field below. If you haven’t signed up yet, you can do so here – it’s free and only takes a moment.

The Local/hc

What do you think? Leave your comment below.


Your comments about this article:

17:58 July 11, 2012 by IchBinKönig
The 'Rich' are/will be paying for the vast majority of the Debt anyway. It certainly won't be the 'Poor'. What you are essentially saying here, is that you would like an Advance. A down Payment, and Security Deposit for the EUs new Villa in Greece.
18:30 July 11, 2012 by Englishted
Why oh why?

Why make it only a one off ?.
20:32 July 11, 2012 by IchBinKönig
@ Englishted

'Why make it only a one off ?. '

Yes, make your industrious countrymen PAY THOSE BANKERS! Not one off. All off, yes?

This was the end of the Occupy Wall St. Movement wasn't it? When the Occupiers realized THEY WANTED the Bankers paid off.
22:37 July 11, 2012 by finanzdoktor
First, if they were to levy such a tax as one-off, it probably wouldn't stay that way. Instead, once it found it could get away with it, there would be more of these levies. Second, how would you implement it so as not to adversely affect small-business owners, who employ more individuals than large corporations? The devil is always in the details. And, lastly, always hear about how taxes should be "fair" and yet in most developed countries, the higher income earners are taxed or pay a great proportion of taxes versus other income groups. Is that fair to make it more? Or, as the article mentions, are shooting ourselves in the foot?
23:14 July 11, 2012 by taimoorbhatti
Why not tax slightly the huge sums of money stored in banks? Rather than reward people for not spending, the government should tax that money!
23:44 July 11, 2012 by wxman
Only if you want them to move to Norway!
07:56 July 12, 2012 by paynet2128
This is the dumbest thing I have ever heard of. The Governments would realize that they could get away with it against the rich, in later years it will become the middle class and then maybe even the poorer classes. I suggest European countries try to live within their means instead of borrowing money to pay for social programs.
10:10 July 12, 2012 by DoubleDTown
where/when did these "respected economists" get their doctorates? In East Germany pre-1989?
13:23 July 12, 2012 by Insel-Affe
I think it's a good idea, but it should only apply to private persons who are hoarding cash, and they should leave investors alone. I wonder how much they could whip up, then?
20:00 July 13, 2012 by gtaglia
No! Never! The problem here is not insufficient revenue, but excessive government spending. If government took everything from everyone, it would still not be enough. Taxes are already far too high and governments continue to borrow and spend more than they take in, which eventually builds up a debt that cannot and will not be repaid. The only difference between Greece and the rest of the EU is a matter of time. Most of the things government spends money on either shouldn't be done at all, or could be done better and cheaper by individuals themselves (if they weren't being taxed into poverty), or private industry. As Frederic Bastiat said, "Government is the great fiction through which everybody endeavors to live at the expense of everybody else", the wealth to pay for it does not exist and continued borrowing will eventually result in disaster.
10:37 July 15, 2012 by raandy
Taxing based on a percentage of earned income is reasonably fair,taxing the rich for being rich is reasonably unfair.
11:48 July 15, 2012 by Wrench
The former US presidential candidate Ross Perot wanted to do away with the Internal Revenue Service by taxing every working stiff in the US 15% no matter how much your earnings. Seems fair to me. The same thing applies here. Why don't we also have a income tax on politicians.
11:55 July 15, 2012 by asteriks
At one side, debt is caused by politicians and their lack of knowledge to lead economy, at other side, riches escape to Asia in any case, so, better to take money from them before they escape. Their profit is created by workers but money taken by the state finish in pockets of politicians and not in pockets of workers. Politicians and the state are expensive, burden on the back of workers and on the back of capitalists. Even better measure would be forbidding to sell products in Germany if someone closed company in Germany and opened somewhere else, it can be covered with story about fight against slavery. Foxcon workers jumped from roof many times, therefore Apple products should be forbidden for German market until Apple change their politics in choosing subcontractors. Solution should be long term and not short term taking money from riches. Then riches would keep business in Germany rather than to move it to Asia with aim to make bigger profit for themselves. If it is not done, Europe will become poorer and poorer and Asia richer and richer, so in the end, one day Europeans will not have money to buy products manufactured in Asia. Ask Mercedes where they sell more cars, in Europe or in Asia, then you will see that already now Europe became weak for Asia. Solution is not one time tax for riches, solution is cheaper administration, cheaper politicians, and pushing riches to keep factories in Europe.
20:11 July 15, 2012 by pjnt
Lots of good input here. 2 main points:

If they do it once and get away with it, they will do it again.

It is the incompatence of the existing government that need addressing.

It is not that I don't agree that the wealth should be more equally spread out, but not this way. Stop spending money you don't have, stop giving others money you won't get back and don't have to give. Debt and Deficits are only one side of the coin, I would highly recommend we try Savings and Surplus!

It should be made manditory that outside of a national emergency you may not borrow. And banks gambling away their clients money is not an emergency.
00:06 July 16, 2012 by Berlin fuer alles
The article should be about "should the rich hit Germany with a productivity tax". That is what will happen if you mess with those with money and produce wealth.
18:19 July 16, 2012 by Eric1
This is just pure greed to take more money from the wealthy. They are being screwed from every side. Totally immoral.

"A respected economic institute", respected by whom? Joseph Stalin.
16:11 July 19, 2012 by neunElf
Governments think they have a revenue problem, not a spending problem, therefore it will ,only get worse as they will begin eating the goose that lays the golden eggs!

Government consumes, the private sector produces, that metric will never change.

If governments want long term stability they should be doing all possible to foster growth, instead they are doing just the opposite.
18:25 July 20, 2012 by Berlin fuer alles
Tax your way out of trouble. Great idea. Don't know of any example of it ever working. Hopefully the rest of the EU does not let Dr. Merkyl and Mr. Hyde lead them down this road.
08:17 July 24, 2012 by Ozichick
Germany is fast becoming like Australia: it penalises the hard-working, highly-taxed citizens and rewards the lazy, non-contributing parasites who demand everything on the proverbial silver platter. Jealousy is a curse!
16:36 July 24, 2012 by majorityrules
NO! Another bad idea from peole who have a bad vision for your future. Higher taxes only bring on more- higher taxes. eventually for everybody. Why you ask.? The people who have this wonderful idea of class warfare only have one solution to all of their made up problems - higher taxes on "alleged rich people" - A class of people those big govt idiots will no doubt 'create based on an income level they FEEL is rght"... Higer taxes for what purpose? More taxes has been proven in most every country to never work for the people or even the govt. It takes from people and gives it to govt which wastes it on lousy ideas. And by the way, Govt, and the idiot representitives which work there, never votes itself to get smaller. Govt is by nature a chronic Taker therefore Tax payers are always on the losing end. The Robin hood theory of taxing the rich and giving to the poor has been tried over and over and over in many different countries and regardless if rich people stay rich, one thing is for sure, higher taxes have never ever helped remove the poor from remaining poor.
14:29 August 5, 2012 by devpriya
Absolutely ! Throughout the banking history of the past 500 years there have again and again been times, when the wealthy needed to give back a part of what they have taken from those, who actually do the hard work.

A one-time-tax of 10% on accumulated wealth is more than fair.

Our system promotes those, who have lots of money - the real crime against humanity is the concept of compound interest. Those who have a lot get even more, just by keeping their money idle on bank accounts and collecting interest.

Actually our system has to change, from receiving interest on idle money to having to pay tax on all money, which is not invested into REAL business - into production, environmental sustainance, land, communal and social projects and more.

This 10%-tax could be modified - i would rather leave it up to the wealthy, in which projects they want to invest, assumed that they can prove, that it serves the people, the 99%, who can't hoard money on accounts, because they hardly earn enough to survive.

It's time to stop the concept of . Money is a symbol for the exchange of energy. When we become aware, that around 6000 people worldwide hold about 90% of the planets ressources, we can easily see, that this exchange has been working from down to up in the past few hundred years. Which makes the wealthy richer, and the simple people more poor.

Enough of this. It's 2012. If all people and countries stopped paying bank debts, within a few weeks all banks would be willing to make new deals.

Just look at Iceland - unheard of the world, Mainstream media don't report on it, because this would be contagious to all Euro-countries, they changed government, refused to pay debts within the harsh conditions the banks wanted to press them in, arrested many banksters and are now economically in a much better position than when their process started in 2008.

Time for a change...
22:40 August 7, 2012 by neunElf
"Our system promotes those, who have lots of money - the real crime against humanity is the concept of compound interest. Those who have a lot get even more, just by keeping their money idle on bank accounts and collecting interest."

Do you know why and how they are p[aid interest?

Because their deposits have been used to invest or loan money to someone that EARNS interest, they are paid from the proceeds, THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE DEPOSITED MONEY DOES NOT MEAN THAT THE$ MONEY IS NOT BEING USED IN THE ECONOMY!

NO ONE PAYS YOU INTEREST JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE A SAVINGS ACCOUNT, the money must be used to earn income.

Please stop this ridiculous claim about people hoarding cash as if they are not contributing!

Thank god someone is saving money.
13:49 September 2, 2012 by narfmaster
There are rich people right now (Warren Buffet, Maurice Lévy, etc) who have ASKED to be taxed more because even they realize the tax situation in most countries is quite ridiculous. People who earn millions have more money than they know what to do with. They know that other people work just as hard as they do and those people sometimes don't eat to pay for the heating. Circumstances are not always fair.

Do governments need more money? Well, yes, they do. Most governments around the world are in debt, and for some (Greece, Spain, etc.) it is causing those countries major difficulties. It's bad for business. However, if the rich people in those countries would pay a bit more (or in the case of Greece, just pay what they owe) these problems wouldn't exist. It makes financial sense for them to pay their taxes or a bit more because then their businesses can earn more money in the calm business climate. Instead, these countries are having lots of problems and it is costing them money anyway.

So, yes, Germany needs some cash. Some Germans have some cash. If they contribute a bit more, their country will keep its credit rating and German business will continue to thrive. What's the problem with that?

On a side not, the worst offenders are those who live off of inheritance and don't work. They are not job creators. They do not contribute to society. The world would be better without them and I for one would not cry if there was a massive tax put on them. If it were large enough, perhaps they would be encouraged to find jobs and work like the rest of us.
05:50 September 4, 2012 by bassplayer
Governments waste so much money; time to revolt; the rich got there by hard work and managing their money, so it should not be available for government and idiot politicians to waste.
05:44 September 6, 2012 by sally#
Some people says that the rich get the most benefit from the country,so of course they shoulder most responsibilities to the country. But if you change the perspective, the rich accumulate the wealth by their hard work and intelligence.There's no reason to charge more and it's nothing wrong with rich itself as long as earned in the legal way. Furthermore,even if taxing the rich can relieve national debt, it's just an utterly inadequate method in dealing with a severe situation.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Today's headlines
Obama in Berlin 2013
Photo: DPA

Nuclear cuts top Obama's Berlin speech

President Barack Obama said Russian and US nuclear weapons should be slashed by up to a third in a keynote speech in front of Berlin's iconic Brandenburg Gate in which he called for a world of "peace and justice." READ () »

Photo: DPA

Dentist cut off own finger for insurance cash

A German dentist who was so desperate for cash that he cut off his own finger for the insurance money has been found guilty of fraud and sentenced to a year in prison to be served on parole. The man said he was the victim of an attack. READ () »

The Local Zeitgeist
Photo: Kate Ferguson

'Michelle is more popular than her husband'

The Local met a colourful crowd gathered to glimpse First Lady Michelle Obama in Berlin on Wednesday - from the Dutch man who came all the way to Germany to see her, to the commuter annoyed to find his way to work barred by police. READ () »

Photo: DPA

Germany home to one million millionaires

Germany has the third highest population of millionaires of any country in the world, and according to a study released on Wednesday, their piles of gold are growing faster than the world economy. READ () »

The Local’s movie listings
Photo: DPA

New in German cinemas: ‘Monsters University’

Find movies playing in English in Germany with The Local’s cinema guide. READ () »

Photo: DPA

Bahn feels heat as cooling systems fail

With temperatures creeping up into the high thirties on Wednesday Deutsche Bahn said broken air conditioning systems could see train cancellations across the country. The network is still battling to get back on track after the floods. READ () »

Photo: DPA

Centre-left SPD party plummet in polls

It's been a tough few days for Social Democrat chancellor candidate Peer Steinbrück. At the weekend he made headlines for crying at a party event and just three months before the election, support for his party is at an all-year low. READ () »

The Local List
Photo: DPA

Six famous American quotes about Germany

Barack Obama follows JFK and Ronald Reagan in his Berlin speech on Wednesday. Can he match being a Berliner or calling for Gorbachev to tear down that wall? The Local List has six other famous US quotes about Germany. READ () »

More Analysis & Opinion
RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Highlights
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
Karamba Diaby hopes to become the first black member of the Bundestag this September, making him our German of Week.
Photo: DPA
SOCIETY »
'I come to Germany for prostitutes - it's like Aldi.' An American tells The Local about coming to Germany three times a year to visit brothels.
Photo: DPA
NATIONAL »
The Local List: Nine weird German weather phenomena
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
As Germany contends with historic flooding, Tagesspiegel's Robert Ide argues that money has been wasted on trying to contain rivers with concrete, rather than giving them vital space.
Photo: Private
SOCIETY »
Germans might not know it, but they desperately need the moral guidance of a re-instated royal family, says the great-great grandson of the last Kaiser, Prince Philip Kiril of Prussia.
Photo: DPA
LIFESTYLE »
Americans have had a love affair with Heidelberg since Mark Twain visited the city. Matthew Luxmoore reports on the impact of the US Army's imminent withdrawal after 68 years.
Photo: DPA
SCIENCE & TECH »
Germany's longest word Rindfleischetikettierungsüberwachungsaufgabenübertragung sgesetz is no longer.
Photo: wikipedia
LIFESTYLE »
German cuisine is far more inventive than most people realize. Ever had "Fake Rabbit" or "Lost Eggs" for dinner? The Local List serves up some of the more colourfully named dishes.
Photo: Private
LIFESTYLE »
'Young cancer sufferers have specific problems'. Survivor Friederike Kaup tells The Local about why she wants to set up a shared flat for chemotherapy patients.
Photo: Private
OPINION »
Are Germans ready to elect a Jewish chancellor? UK journalist David Crossland has written a novel exploring racism and neo-Nazi violence in Germany. The Local has excerpts.
Photo: DPA
LIFESTYLE »
The German language has some rather colourful terms for describing parts of the human body. Turn to The Local List this week for a few anatomical alternatives.
Photo: DPA
NATIONAL »
Germany is the most popular country in the world!
Photo: DPA
LIFESTYLE »
Harmless pink fun or a bad influence on young girls? A life-size Barbie dream house attraction opened in Berlin to protests including a topless woman burning a doll in effigy.
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
It might be politically toxic, but it's time to hit the brakes on Germany's reckless driving culture, argues The Local's Ben Knight.
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
Confused about the hundreds of euros missing from your pay packet? Don't panic - the latest in The Local's JobTalk series looks at German social security payments.
Photo: DPA
LIFESTYLE »
Is that your Handy ringing? This week's Local List takes a look at 12 misused English words in German.
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
What are the hidden rules of etiquette foreigners need to watch out for while doing business in Germany? The Local's JobTalk series has tips for keeping on the right side of your colleagues.
Photo: DPA
NATIONAL »
All of The Local's 'Germans of the Week' so far
Photo: DPA
NATIONAL »
Every town and city from The Local's My Germany series
Monster/jobpilot.de
SPONSORED ARTICLE
Eighty per cent of Germans apply for jobs online
Furniture Leasing Corporation
SPONSORED ARTICLE
The furniture-free way to relocate to Germany
Photo: Henrik Trygg/imagebank.sweden.se
SPONSORED ARTICLE
Top five reasons to enrol on an Executive MBA
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
Germans of the Week are the thousands of volunteers helping to sandbag against rising floodwaters.



Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

See all ads | Join the Marketplace

Jobs in Germany, in English

886 jobs available
665 new jobs this week
124 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Blog
Essentials

Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your style? Find a German sweetheart here.

Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather section.

Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.

Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of charge.

Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

News from the Goethe-Institut
News from Young Germany
  • Germany's Guerilla Knitters
    A tree in a sweater? A statue wearing mittens? A sign post with a scarf? Guerilla knitters are brightening urban spaces in Germany with a new kind of graffiti.
  • The Best of Germany: Städelschule
    At the heart of Frankfurt’s art scene is a school that has attracted many international art students to Germany. The Städelschule has a reputation for a high level of instruction and for nurturing students working at the forefront of conceptual and experimental contemporary art.
  • US President Obama in Germany
    The American President Barack Obama visits Berlin.
  • Hollywood Stars Filming in Germany
    Hollywood stars such as George Clooney, Cate Blanchett and Oscar award-winner Geoffrey Rush are making films in and around Potsdam.
  • Design Festival in Berlin
    Creative young designers from around the world showcase their work at the DMY International Design Festival at Berlin’s former Tempelhof airport.
News from DeutschlandOnline

Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd
Trade CFDs with InterTrader.com
Start trading shares, equities, forex, etc. No commission on equities; Low min. margins. Apply for a CFDs account now!
Little house in Spain
'Charming, old, beamed cottage for holiday let in Jesus Pobre, Alicante, Spain
www.littlehouseinspain.com/
Albatross Insurance
Professional and qualified consultancy on all insurance and finance matters in Germany, Telephone: +49 2163 571 1740, Email: bg@albatross-assurance.com
www.albatross-assurance.com
Hotel reservations in Berlin
Visiting Berlin anytime soon? Book your hotel in Berlin here.
Rental apartments in Berlin
For home-from-home holiday accommodation, search for a Berlin apartment to rent.