My Dear Krauts
Aren't we all a little Angie? Photo: DPA

A nation of 80 million Merkels

Published: 21 Sep 09 18:48 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/opinion/20090921-22065.html

With less than a week before Germany’s election, Roger Boyes, the Berlin correspondent for British daily The Times, muses that the country’s voters like being bored by Angela Merkel and her political cohorts.

Being a foreign correspondent is a bit like being an airline pilot. There are long periods of boredom, interrupted briefly by a stewardess bringing coffee, followed by short surges of adrenaline dealing with a crisis or political turbulence.

So this Sunday I’m preparing for Germany’s election night to be the equivalent of a crash-landing: from 6 pm until about 8:30 pm I’ll be trying to absorb masses of new information, interpreting it, and making it sensible for British readers. With the clock ticking in the background, I’ll have to take a rough guess as to the future of the government and the future of the country as the paper prepares to go to press.

Average Germans, of course, will not be sharing my sense of terror – they’ll be treated to a soap opera about – ahem – average Germans.

At 6:50 pm sharp, 50 minutes after the first exit polls are released, public broadcaster ARD will interrupt the shrewd number-crunching of its analysts to roll the credits of “Lindenstrasse” – a rather dull soap based loosely on Britain’s “Coronation Street” that’s flickered on German TVs for the past quarter of a century.

The tortured possibilities of coalition arithmetic and the puffing of flush-faced Teutonic politicians will abruptly give way to the adventures of Harry the loser, Andi the taxi driver, the döner kebab snack shop owner whose best friend is a neo-Nazi, and Tanja the Lesbian hairdresser.

Now there are those who see similarities between the goings-on of Bavarian politics and the Munich-based “Lindenstrasse” gang. But to us foreigners it looks like a rather bizarre segue when the future of the national hangs in the balance. Plainly the ARD church elders decided long ago that German viewers cannot cope with too much excitement – why else show Volksmusik every Saturday evening, right? Yes, the Germans are interested in who runs their country but, well, not that interested.

It is fashionable, of course, to blame Chancellor Angela Merkel for the evaporation of interest in politics. It is her style, after all, to treat politics as just another form of decision-making. As in, shall we buy a new refrigerator, darling?

The facts are gathered in from the consumer reports experts at Stiftung Warentest and you assess the situation. The old machine sounds like a Panzer warming up for action, is uses too much electricity and it is difficult to defrost. But it works. A new fridge would cost €500, but would be quieter, hold more beer and wouldn’t stink so much. You talk about it during the advertising breaks in from Günther Jauch minting Germany’s next millionaire. You sleep on it. And then you make a calm decision.

That is how Merkel has taught us to think about politics. She has reduced it to the size of the living room. No wonder we are all so bored.

But this is not completely fair to the chancellor. The “Lindenstrasse” episode on election night was a tradition long before Ms Merkel left the laboratories of East Germany’s Institute for Physical Chemistry. The modern German miniaturises political processes; it is his or her response to the politicisation of everyday life under the Nazis and the communists. Big ideas are made small, and less threatening.

Take former Chancellor Gerhard Schröder’s Agenda 2010. An ambitious attempt to overhaul the country’s welfare state? That’s certainly how we saw it abroad. But for ordinary Germans it became largely a question of whether shops should shut at 2 pm or 6 pm on Saturdays. (Berlin significantly seems still stuck in this Amish phase – I can’t believe that the capital of Germany is considering closing shops at the main train station on Sundays.)

What was Schröder’s progressive coalition of Social Democrats and Greens to the ordinary German voter? For foreigners, it was an intriguing eight years in which Germany tried to free itself from the post-war corset. It seemed easier with itself, more sovereign. But for the average German it meant only one thing: a pricey and annoying deposits on beverage cans. The government became the unacceptable face of eco-bureaucratic rule.

Over the past year, the Merkel’s grand coalition of Christian and Social Democrats has thrown hundreds of billions of euros at fragile banks and companies. It has (usually without consulting taxpayers) propped up the economy but at the price of amassing huge debts. These have been taboo-shattering months. But what sticks in the mind of Joe Sixpack – known as Otto Normalverbraucher here? The “cash for clunkers” Abwrackprämie.

The reason is clear: Germany is a nation of bargain hunters. The strongest collective emotions are stinginess and envy and they have become the engine of German politics. Any policy that addresses or feeds these character traits will capture the attention of the voter; anything that hints of the visionary or utopian is a source of deep suspicion.

It is in other words not the politicians who are letting us down with their mediocrity, their inability to enchant or inspire. The political class has become boring because that’s the way we want it to be. The problem lies in the low expectations of the average voter. The Germans may pretend to love US President Barack Obama, but they really wouldn’t want him over here. They want what’s small and manageable not grand and bold.

They want “Lindenstrasse” at 6:50 pm on election night and, by God, that’s what they’re going to get.

For more Roger Boyes, check out his website here.

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Survey
Fark It! Digg This Facebook  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

20:56 September 21, 2009 by HerrDinksbumps
Angie rocks..
21:18 September 21, 2009 by lordkorner
My god you are so right,if only the poor bored Germans had the likes of Gordon Brown to liven up their lives, as for stinginess and envy...now what ever became of the British Motor industry,or any industry for that matter.
23:05 September 21, 2009 by Bell the cat
Hmmm, I read the article and then wondered how welcome I would find reading an article written by a German journalist that was the equivalent long bitter sneer but instead at the stpidity of British voters. Why does it not surprise me that the idiot who wrote the above toe-curlingly patronising article writes normally for the Times . . .
23:28 September 21, 2009 by MonksTown
I was going to say that I epected a nasty little rant, a hefty portion of xenophobia and the Murdoch political agenda. But no, I thought, I can't possibly say that based purely on the fact that he was writing for the Times about Germany.

Then I read the article and found out I was right.

Quite frankly if this man is going to be a major source for people in the UK to understand what is happenning in the election of on its largest partners then no womder the British have a warped view of Germany sometimes.

Germany is most certainly NOT a nation of 80 million Merkels.

Her party is polling in the 30s and there is no guarantee she will get a solid majority with the liberals next Sunday.

There is quite clearly opposition.

Even within her own party there is hefty discussion in just the last week:

The employees section within the CDU have had a go at the neo-liberals.

The industrialists section have demanded a more business friendly position.

State premiers Wulff and Koch have been sharpening the knives as they have a patholgical (misogynist?) hatred of Merkel.

And the Bavarian CSU is doing its own thing as always.

Did the journalist actually BOTHER to do any research?

Or ask for advice from people who do know their hinten from the flexible arm joint?

And do a big diss of a popular soap opera on a public TV network that tackles social issues.

Not that there is ANY conflict of interest there, is there?
14:35 September 22, 2009 by Bell the cat
Alastair Campbell actually wrote a far more balanced and enthusiatic article about the election for Le Figaro, he carries this English version on his blog
15:48 September 22, 2009 by poppet
Angie rocks..
Funnily enough I don'r remember ever seeing a picture of her in a 'Rock'
15:56 September 22, 2009 by kato
http://www.nordbayerischer-kurier.de/images_news/Juli2009_05/wagzwei05.jpg

First google hit on "rock merkel".
16:14 September 22, 2009 by poppet
well I don't think that counts - She's obviously got trousers on underneath.
19:46 September 22, 2009 by Scottrocks9
Talk about boring-this article bored me to sleep-I couldn't finish it. I have to ask again, does this Boyes get money for this drivel? If he is living in Berlin, the Berliners should run his ass all the way back to whatever backwater he came from in the UK. Freeloader, schmarotzer! Can the Local not find more skilled English speaking writers than this?
14:04 September 23, 2009 by swimmer
It's just one perspective. You could say that, if there aren 80m just like her, she's an "everywoman". That's how I see her - she could be your ma, sister, aunt, neighbour, co-worker, shop asssistant, the middle-aged woman chasing the football team round Euro 2008, CEO, Head of Government, or most powerful woman in the world. It's a wide appeal, just in a downbeat way. Hence why her personal rating exceeds that of her party.

That's what the author might see if he looked beneath the surface.

poppet - you must surely have seen that notorious low-cut "weapons of mass distraction" ballgown at the Opera in Oslo ?
20:55 September 23, 2009 by Druid67
Sorry, I don't wish to over intellectualize this debate, but there might not be 80m of her, but there is hell of a lot of women who resemble her without the ball gown down my local over 30's disco on a Saturday night. Alas.....
21:13 September 23, 2009 by MonksTown
Yeah she's an "Everywoman", that's her downbeat election campaign all right.

She has a higher popularity raiting than her party but that's not a huge surprise and that personal vote is slipping.

Will it be enough for Angie and her corporatist style come Sunday?

We'll have to wait and see, it's going to be close.
21:15 September 23, 2009 by stuartmartin
Close?????????? No chance She will walz through it

And we wont be voting
21:21 September 23, 2009 by MonksTown
Waltz through it?

She's likely to be the next Bundeskanzlerin sure, how long for though is another issue.

The big question is, which parties are going to be in the government, which one wills will tolerate the government and which ones will be in opposition.

And that is no waltz for the official goal of the CDU-CSU and FDP to form a centre-right government together.

They were polling about 47% combined this morning.
21:31 September 23, 2009 by HerrDinksbumps
Merkel and Westerwelle FTW!!! (there needs to be a more cheesy head-banging type emoticon...)
21:39 September 23, 2009 by swimmer
Indeed, that idea's gradually slipping away, so it looks like no change. Some Linke guys I was talking to tonight are amazingly positive...expect to come third, ahead of FDP!

As to the earlier point on how Merkel is perceived. The German election is reported by UK journalists as if the system here is identical to the UK's, as if being a federal republic means zip. However, someone mentioned the lovely Mr Koch and really (in Hessen) he and his Wiesbaden government are far more my "political leadership" than Merkel and Berlin. Actuially, who the heck the chancellor is seems to be of less local interest than the recent state election.
21:51 September 23, 2009 by RainyDays
I find the article pretty ill-humoured and not very thoroughly researched. Perhaps the "long periods of boredom" got to the author? Not a word about the debate on the problem of Überhangmandate. Each voter has two votes, with the first, the candidate for his/her constituency is elected, with the second the list of a party. If the number of candidates who acquire a direct mandate is higher than the number of seats per Land gained by the lists, the Überhangmandate create additional seats in parliament, which in this election could lead to a decisive majority of Christian Democrats and Liberals. The Constitutional Court decided that this aspect of the German voting system needs to be changed because of its potential for distorting the electorate's will.

A considerable part of the electorate could vote tactically or for small parties with both their votes, so I don't see an army of Merkels.
22:12 September 23, 2009 by MonksTown
@ Swimmer, I would warn the Linke of over-confidence but it is not without the realms of possibility that they poll in third place.

If that were to happen it would be interesting to see the blood letting in the Greens as they decide whether to join a R-R-G (minority?) government or a Jamaica coalition.

We'll have to see what the last couple of days of the campaign bring.

If Lafo has been drinking the blood of newly born kittens, expect to see it co-incidently appear as the headline of the Bild on Friday.

I'd had a few beverages when I posted on the Schwesterwelle thread yesterday, soz for that, am trying to keep it highbrow and provide some analysis and news that the UK's oldest newspaper is clearly unilling or unable to do.

What I am picking up is a STOP WESTERWELLE trend with people considering how to vote tacticly to keep him out of the federal government. And quite possibly Angie would be happy with that. She's vews herself as a steady hand that could possibly govern better with the SPD than the the slash and burn neo-liberals.
23:28 September 23, 2009 by MonksTown
Atom Angie

Who says the Germans have no sense of humour.
04:10 September 24, 2009 by DavidtheNorseman
Madame Merkel's media image is one of trustworthiness and practical good sense (and as a male I find her oddly desirable). Her media support, especially in photographs where you can make or ruin a politician, is superlative.
08:00 September 24, 2009 by MonksTown
There is a real contrast in her official photos - smiling, pastel coloured jacket - to the unnofficial one - sour faced haaridan.
11:06 September 24, 2009 by Kuzzer
And we wont be voting
Indeed not; the "no taxation without representation" chestnut falls from the tree once more.

Moving on: anyone fancy joining me on Sunday in tipping a boxful of Rindswurst into the Main on Sunday in a loose re-enactment of the Boston Tea Party?

K
19:50 September 24, 2009 by MonksTown
Still too WAY too early to call but I've been noticing on some of the sites and blogs I read that the more right wing, free market posters close to the CDU-CSU have been turning up the agression and sheer downright nastiness over the last 24 hours.

There's a lot more polling going on than gets into the public domain and I'm thinking they are seeing any majority they have had for schwarz-gelb melting away.......
19:54 September 24, 2009 by Kommentarlos
... am trying to keep it highbrow and provide some analysis and news that the UK's oldest newspaper is clearly unilling or unable to do.
Has been already noted and is appreciated. Am enjoying your insight.
07:43 September 26, 2009 by SensibleAli
Adenauer once demanded 'Keine Experimente' in dealing with the Soviet aggression. - We're fed with a history of going to the brink of extinction. That's stuck in our collective minds. We have a sense of doom and failure. The 20th century hasn't been over yet for very long. Only now are signs emerging of a revival of our wits. We deserve better than your derision, Mr. Boyes!
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
For comment quoting and other advanced formatting features,
try posting via this article's discussion forum page instead.
Today's headlines
Development Minister Dirk Niebel in Congo. Photo: DPA

Development minister stokes foreign aid debate

Development Minister Dirk Niebel once demanded his ministry be abolished. But the former paratrooper is earning applause for plans to streamline Berlin's foreign aid apparatus - and condemnation for how much he wants to spend on the poor. READ (3 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Zoo opens Body Worlds anatomical exhibition for animals

The controversial creator of Body Worlds is bringing a new anatomical exhibition to the Neunkirchen Zoo. The show features some of the world’s largest animals preserved in various states of dissection using a plastination process. READ »

Photo: DPA

Educational web game by Nestlé sparks privacy concerns

A German educational foundation for reading faced criticism on Thursday for allowing food company Nestlé to collect information on children via an online learning game. But the group claims it was unaware of the practice. READ »

Photo: DPA

Leipzig Book Fair opens

The Leipzig Book Fair opened its doors to the public on Thursday, emphasising new publishers among 2,071 exhibitors from 39 countries. READ »

Photo: DPA

Hipp baby food turns to hip-replacement generation

The German baby food firm Hipp has found a recipe for growth even as the nation’s birth rate stays low and its population ages – feeding its products to elderly adults. READ (1 COMMENT) »

Photo: DPA

Guttenberg under fire for handling of Kunduz air strike affair

German Defence Minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg was slammed by the opposition on Thursday for his handling of the aftermath of a deadly air strike in Afghanistan currently under investigation by a parliamentary inquiry. READ (5 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Politicians call on government to save German shipbuilding

Politicians from Germany’s coastal states on Thursday called on the government to help save the country's shipbuilding industry. READ (3 COMMENTS) »

The remaining three fugitives. Photo: DPA

Second poker heist bandit arrested

After a man turned himself in earlier this week a second suspect has been arrested for a heist on a high-stakes German poker tournament that netted the thieves nearly a quarter of a million euros, authorities said late on Wednesday. READ (9 COMMENTS) »

More Analysis & Opinion
Highlights
Photo: BeMe Theatre
LIFESTYLE »
The Local's series "Making it in Germany" presents Elisa Moolecherry, the Canadian actor and entrepreneur behind Munich’s English-language BeMe Theatre.

See all ads | Join the Marketplace

Jobs in Germany, in English

676 jobs in Germany, in English
335 new jobs this week
0 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Latest news from The Local in Sweden
Blog
Essentials

Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your style? Find a German sweetheart here.

Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather section.

Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.

Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of charge.

Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

News from the Goethe-Institut
News from Young Germany
News from DeutschlandOnline
JOB: Junior Project Manager (m/f)
ProCredit Holding is offering an exciting position in its Frankfurt-based marketing team
FULL JOB DETAILS
JOB: Scandinavian sales people wanted
Danish and Norwegian sales people wanted in Berlin. No experience required. Salary €1600 + provision (average salary €2300).
Danish? Norwegian? Work in Berlin!
Advertising 2.0
MARKETPLACE - promote your business to half a million targeted readers a month on The Local. Find great products and services in Germany or tell The Local's readers about your own business.
CLICK HERE>>>
Sales managers - country wide
The Local is seeking talented and experienced media sales professionals for our online advertising sales in Germany
FULL JOB DETAILS
Best Foreign exchange rates dealing - all major currencies
Foreign Currency Direct voted as offering the best exchange rates. All currency exchange transactions are managed by Ben Amrany. We guarantee that readers of The Local/Toytown receive a 5 star service
FULL DETAILS HERE>>>
Are you paying too much for health insurance?
Qualitura Independent Broker - Native English speaking German insurance specialist able to find the best solution for health insurance; many of our clients saved up to €2,400 a year. Get a free quote!
MORE INFO

The Local Europe GmbH
Linienstrasse 214
10119 Berlin
Germany