November 20, 2009
Published: 8 Nov 09 11:16 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/money/20091108-23103.html
After last week’s shock decision by General Motors to hold onto Opel rather than selling it to the Canadian company Magna, a new poll shows that a clear majority of Germans against offering aid to the company if it asks for state aid.
DPA/The Local (news@thelocal.de)
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
German rail operator Deutsche Bahn is set to sign a contract worth "billions of euros" to build railways in Qatar and Bahrain, a spokesman for Deutsche Bahn told AFP on Friday. READ »
Germany's ambitious plans to fight climate change will cost Europe's largest economy €310 billion, Manager Magazin reported on Friday. READ (22 COMMENTS) »
Volkswagen, Europe's biggest carmaker, said on Friday that its supervisory board had cleared the way for its planned takeover of Porsche. READ »
German media giant Axel Springer said on Thursday it had agreed to buy a 29-percent stake in Turkey's biggest independent media group Dogan for €161 million ($239 million). READ »
Conspicuously absent in the debate over two big-hitting EU posts up for grabs on Thursday, heavyweight Germany has aroused suspicions that it wants another job – president of the European Central Bank. READ »
Two German utilities – Vattenfall and EWE – announced on Wednesday they would dramatically raise electricity prices for their customers starting next year, blaming the higher cost of renewable energy. READ (10 COMMENTS) »
A massive fraud ring in Spain has sparked a growing recall of German credit cards, with customers of nearly all banks in the country affected. Some 100,000 cards been affected so far. READ (1 COMMENT) »
With an eye towards possible acquisitions, Europe’s biggest software firm SAP is on the verge of a substantial “wave of growth,” company CEO Léo Apotheker said on Tuesday in Berlin. READ »
Germany’s top airline Lufthansa said on Tuesday it plans to boost efficiency on its European routes by copying low-cost carriers offering less space and service. READ (3 COMMENTS) »
Thousands of Lufthansa “Miles & More” credit cards have been frozen because of fears they were vulnerable to a major fraud ring in Spain, the airline announced Monday. READ »
See all ads | Join the Marketplace
578 jobs in Germany, in English
343 new jobs this week
67 new jobs today
Your comments about this article:
Part of the problem, which the German side won't talk about, is that Opel's sales aren't as strong as their production capacity, but the German labor restrictions are so strong, they won't allow a company to adapt to changes like this, and account for increased competition and distribution of sales across competitors.
The bottom line on this is the Germans had the opportunity to release Opel from American control, yet they let the deal sit and fester until it was pulled off the table, which is how business is and should be done. They lost their opportunity, plain and simple. However, I know the German side will spin this to generate anti-American sentiment, rather than admit their own fault in this to their own people.
Why shouldn't the parent money be able to take the money generated by a subsidiary? The Germans' problem is they look at Opel as a single entity, while Opel is part of a giant corporation they sold it to in 1929. The average German still seems to try and apply the single-entity thinking to Opel, when it is a part of a whole corporation, so no doubt, as much as I don't care for GM and mismanagement, no heads rolled and no one went to prison, as pulling the money out of Opel to bring back to GM was fully legal. This fear that the German government are creating is unfounded, as it can be stipulated the money shall not leave this area. This is simply a matter of fear-mongering, posturing, and "razing the land", with respect to sealing the future of Opel with a damaged reputation.
I have not made an argument that GM wasn't incompetent, but additionally, you're speaking of Opel being run into the ground, which is far from the truth. Opel was running quite well, though with reduced buying of the product for some time as the economy went down and competition went up. Additionally, they had some ?3bn in cash reserve-so much for them being run into the ground. They don't have that cash now because it was sent back to GM in the US, as is rightfully allowed. 10000 employees is exactly the ratio for the 33% more capacity they have than sales, and I think it's fair, but as with everything in Germany, they want all or nothing, and will lose anyhow.
As far as Ford goes, you didn't make a convincing argument against the existence of anti-Americanism by only introducing their name. Unfortunately, I have some German classes, and this is one hot topic, along with reading the German papers and watching the news.
The issue with opel is on this side, too. Not just the highlighting of GM's problems on the other side of the world.
Why shouldn't the parent money be able to take the money generated by a subsidiary? The Germans' problem is they look at Opel as a single entity, while Opel is part of a giant corporation they sold it to in 1929. The average German still seems to try and apply the single-entity thinking to Opel, when it is a part of a whole corporation, so no doubt, as much as I don't care for GM and mismanagement, no heads rolled and no one went to prison, as pulling the money out of Opel to bring back to GM was fully legal. This fear that the German government are creating is unfounded, as it can be stipulated the money shall not leave this area. This is simply a matter of fear-mongering, posturing, and "razing the land", with respect to sealing the future of Opel with a damaged reputation.
There are just two ways to make sure the money stays with Opel:
1) Have the government audit every single transaction between Opel and GMNA. That means check the price of every little brake caliper, light switch or control arm design Opel buys from GMNA (and vice versa).
2) Have two separate companies.
If GM tells Opel 'we'll be paying you $3M for this front control arm design', how would the German government determine whether that's a fair price or whether it's actually worth $10M and GM just quietly pulled $7M out of Opel?
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/09/world/europe/09iht-reunif.html?_r=1&hpw=&pagewanted=all
While the government shouted foul over G.M.?s change of heart after originally accepting the sale, two Germans who had been members of the Opel Trust, overseeing the company while it was seeking a buyer, described Berlin?s preference as entirely politicized. In Dirk Pfeil?s case, he clearly complained too much, and was fired. His apparent mistake was to detail how a ?4.5 billion state credit to Magna and its Russian partner would be spent:
?More than ?600 million were to be used for the modernization of the Russian automobile industry. That means the transfer to Russia of specialized German knowledge and, later, the destruction of jobs [in Germany]. Perhaps the reasons for this are based in foreign policy. Perhaps [they are] a counterpart to general agreements with Putin.?