Photo: DPA

Demjanjuk vows to fight death camp charges

Published: 12 May 09 17:39 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/national/20090512-19237.html

An 89-year-old former Nazi death camp guard, John Demjanjuk, arrived in Germany on Tuesday after his deportation from the United States, vowing to fight charges that he assisted in the murder of over 29,000 Jews.

After losing a months-long battle to stay in the United States, Demjanjuk landed in a specially-chartered plane at an isolated area of Munich airport where he was met by officials from the state prosecutor's office.

Photos showed Demjanjuk - who his family says suffers from kidney disease and blood disorders - lying down with tubes in his nostrils, dressed in a leather jacket and a baseball cap. Doctors accompanying him on the overnight flight from Cleveland's Burke Lakefront Airport said he slept for most of the journey, according to prosecutors.

Germany issued a warrant for Demjanjuk's arrest on March 11 on charges of helping to murder 29,000 Jews during his time as a guard at the Sobibor death camp in Nazi-occupied Poland in 1943.

However, Demjanjuk's lawyer, Ulrich Busch, said his client denied that he was in Sobibor. "But even if he had been there, he should still be acquitted. He comes from Ukraine and would have been a so-called foreign guard" forced into service by the Nazis,” Busch added.

Courts in both Israel and the United States have previously stated he was a guard at Sobibor, charges he had never previously challenged.

Demjanjuk was transferred upon arrival to nearby Stadelheim prison – the same prison Adolf Hitler served a month-long sentence in 1922 for disturbing the peace. “If he is deemed fit, he will have the 21-page charge sheet read to him on Tuesday and if no new evidence surfaces, he will be formally charged "within weeks," the prosecution said.

Demjanjuk is right at the top of Nazi hunters' most-wanted list, and was
sentenced to death by an Israeli court two decades ago, suspected of being the feared death camp guard nicknamed "Ivan the Terrible" who would hack at naked prisoners with a sword. That verdict was overturned in 1993 when statements from former guards identified another man as "Ivan the Terrible."

German television reported that a survivor of the Sobibor camp could help confirm Demjanjuk's identity. The witness, 82-year-old Thomas Blatt, has described the conditions at Sobibor akin to a death factory.

"They abused us. They shot new arrivals who were old and sick and could not go on. And there were some who pushed naked people into the gas chambers with bayonets," Blatt told the latest edition of Spiegel magazine. "Sobibor was a factory. Only a few hours passed between arrival and the burning of a body."

Demjanjuk's relatives, however, say there is nothing to tie him to any deaths at the camp.

"Given the history of this case and not a shred of evidence that he ever
hurt one person let alone murdered anyone anywhere, this is inhuman even if the courts have said it is lawful," his son John wrote on Monday. "This is not justice, it is a vendetta in the falsified name of justice with the hope that somehow Germany will atone for its past."

If Demjanjuk comes to trial it "will probably be the last trial of a Nazi war criminal", Rabbi Marvin Hier of the Los Angeles-based Simon Wiesenthal Centre said.

However, Kurt Schrimm, director of the Central Investigation Centre for Nazi Crimes, told the daily Leipziger Volkszeitung: "We still have a lot ahead of us this year. There are similar cases to that of Mr Demjanjuk."

The president of the Central Council for Jews in Germany, Charlotte Knobloch, called for authorities to move swiftly.

"Now it is time to do everything legally possible to bring Demjanjuk before a court. This is a race against time," she said in a statement. "This is not about revenge but rather about justice for those crimes of which the Munich prosecutor's office accuses (Demjanjuk)."

Demjanjuk was suspect number three in the Simon Wiesenthal Centre's latest report on Nazi war criminals behind two others thought already dead. His deportation marked the end of months of legal wrangling, culminating in an appeal to the US Supreme Court, which refused to hear his case.

AFP (news@thelocal.de)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Fark It! Digg This Facebook  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

03:39 May 13, 2009 by hyam
It's time the German government end this fiasco. Declare Demjanuk unfit for trial and provide him with medical care until his demise.

Stop pandering to world Jewry and show some backbone. The Jews claim the Pope was a member of a Nazi youth group. What are you going to do? Bring charges against the Pope?

Get a life and move on.
03:46 May 13, 2009 by omarsBarNgrill
I will be glad, that in a few more years people like John will not have to be chased for Hitlers actions. In all wars good people do bad things, war sucks, but there will be another.
05:47 May 13, 2009 by danibee
I feel bad for the guy.. he's 89 years old!..WWII was horrible and the holocaust was unspeakable heartbreak and distress and I really feel for the Jews and all who suffered at the hand of the Nazi party..but how old was this guy when he was a soldier? I'm sure the mentality that he had when he was that age was compromised, and influenced by the all the brainwash. I do believe that the memory of those who died under his guard should not diminish, what happened will never be forgotten so time cannot erase what he did.. time doesnt change what he did, but I feel to deport and imprison an 89 year old man after all these years for actions he did under those circumstances is sad... sorry i'm only human.
08:08 May 13, 2009 by LeonG
I feel bad for the guy.. he's 89 years old!..WWII was horrible and the holocaust was unspeakable heartbreak and distress and I really feel for the…
I thought the Israeli had said that he was not in fact Ivan the terrible but some other Ivan. Or maybe they were both terrible. If he is 89, he would have been born in 1920 so he would have been 19-25 during the war. People who commit crimes today at age 19-25 are legally responsible, even if they were brainwashed by family, cult or otherwise. Still, I think it's getting increasingly hard to prove. Memories fade, witnesses die. Memory is not in fact photographic, memories can alter themselves and can become tied to a photo the victim has seen and they testify against that individual convinced he was the evil doer. I think he's too old and it's been too long to drag him to trial over something he may have done.
08:45 May 13, 2009 by Moonboot
I feel bad for the guy.. he's 89 years old!..WWII was horrible and the holocaust was unspeakable heartbreak and distress and I really feel for the…
I'm more sorry that most of all those who suffered at his hands never had a chance to reach the grand old age of 89.
08:54 May 13, 2009 by Crawlie
If he gets a life sentence it would be a bit of a bummer though wouldn't it? He would spend, what, 1-2 years in jail at most? Not really a life sentence now is it?
09:03 May 13, 2009 by toko
The Jews claim the Pope was a member of a Nazi youth group.
He was, so were most of German boys. Being a former Hitler youth is hardly a crime in itself. It's nothing somebody should really be blamed for.
…[/quote]That guy wasn't a soldier, but a mass murderer of scale singular to a living person (if identified as the same person).He was a slaughterer and torturer.

IMHO e should face the same punishments as his colleagues. Hanging. And i'm generally against the death penalty.
11:33 May 13, 2009 by Killer_Bee_67
I have mixed opinions on this one.

I am from Ohio and remember him from the news as a kid. I could not fathome the atrocities as I was too young to understand.

What makes this one as good as OJ's case is the time and the history of the case.

He mention he made a mistake taking the name Merchenko cause he forgot his Mothers name?

He mention that he was a prisoner as opposed to being a guard, when he was identified by others as prisoners?

He was said to be the one who designed, maintained, and operated the diesel engines that fed the gas chambers. It is ironic that he is a retired diesel mechanic from the Ford company in Cleveland Ohio.

They have video surveillance of him driving and getting out of his car to go into the supermarket after he was released from the latter of being taken from his home on a stretcher?

His alibi and his arrogance (trial in Israel) cause some reason to believe he is guilty? Now he is crying?

I don't understand the German courts and their methods, but why after so long?

State of the Art technology has enabled experts to place his signature on incriminating documents? Why so long?

If he is in fact "Ivan" , there should be no lenancy. Look at what his victims had to endure. He would have enjoyed 63 years of a good life, they never had a chance.

I have seen how he lived, I know his neighborhood, its really nice, he had a hearty life.

Do you think justice will be served by him spending his remaining days in confinement?

If he is guily, he should be hung.

This will be a tough one. In my opinion, I believe this is something outside of the German courts.
11:41 May 13, 2009 by Conquistador
He's not Ivan the Terrible, but who knows the complete truth as to what he did.
11:44 May 13, 2009 by toko
I don't understand the German courts and their methods, but why after so long?

State of the Art technology has enabled experts to place his…
It wasn't up to German courts. If anybody knew exactly where he lived and clearly identified him,

Israel would have taken him out earlier. It wasn't all so clear. (Adolf Eichmann anybody?)

And of course he won't be hanged. Like in other cases he might spent the rest of his life in a nursery home, too ill etc.

But that has to be looked upon first. If not, he'll get a prison sentence. But he'll die in Germany i guess.
11:45 May 13, 2009 by parnell
I'm more sorry that most of all those who suffered at his hands never had a chance to reach the grand old age of 89.
Right , but it's a brave person who convicts someone on suspicion of having done unspeakable acts 60 years ago.
12:38 May 13, 2009 by adriprints
I've been following this story for the past few weeks... Some state that Demjanjuk is fit and able to walk, but later he is seen being carried in a stretcher so this automatically means he's faking his ill-health. I wonder about the validity of this because I spent my entire youth with my elderly aunts, grandparents, and other relatives... At 89 years old people have good days and bad. A current example: my grandfather is only 82 and some days he can walk on his own, and others he needs the chair for assistance. I don't think that's evidence enough of good health that they "catch" him one time walking to his car.

Where is the overwhelming video evidence? Where is the evidence he is even the person they say he is? "Demjanjuk regained his US citizenship, which was first stripped in 1981, after an appeals court ruled in 1998 that the US government recklessly withheld exculpatory evidence." This whole case just seems like a fishing expedition. It's a shame how many resources, monetary and other, that are being wasted on this case. I guess they're thinking the third time's a charm.
12:46 May 13, 2009 by Moonboot
Right , but it's a brave person who convicts someone on suspicion of having done unspeakable acts 60 years ago.
yes you are right. apparently there is video evidence. let's see what happens at the trial.
13:19 May 13, 2009 by Killer_Bee_67
The video evidence is of him going into a Supermarket after the fact that he was carried out of his home in a wheel chair.

If he has good days and bad days, try and convict him only on his good day.

Seriously, Instead of wasting one countries resources and the better chance of a fair trial, why not try him in a UN court?

If he is in fact whom everyone says he is, I would show no mercy.
13:28 May 13, 2009 by seth17
Seriously, Instead of wasting one countries resources and the better chance of a fair trial, why not try him in a UN court?
I have mixed opinions of this case also but one thing I have to wonder about is, How many times do we take a person to trial for the same crime? Until we get the outcome we want? Just keep moving locations? That hardly seems just.

Does the world seriously think the Israelis rigged the evidence in his favor?
13:31 May 13, 2009 by lilplatinum
Technically he was being tried for a different crime the first time, the first time for being a guard at Treblinka and this time for charges at being somewhere else... Or am I wrong? If not, technically not double jeopordy.
13:48 May 13, 2009 by Bipa
The whole story is complicated and confusing. Demjanjuk was born in what is now Ukraine and fought with the Russians against the Germans in WWII . He was captured by the Germans. That much is clear.

Then it becomes muddy. Trawniki camp? Sobibor? Treblinka? Even the now famous id card used by every newspaper is disputed. The Israeli court ruled that it was probably not his signature on the card and thus wasn't conclusive proof on its own.

John Gill was part of the team defending Demjanjuk in Israel. Here's his take on the situation:

Demjanjuk's former lawyer says Germany's case is weak
Gill says more than 30 years ago prosecutors originally wanted to charge Demjanjuk with being a guard at Sobibor, a hellish Nazi concentration camp, t…
13:53 May 13, 2009 by iseeking
And try everyone involved in the destruction of Palestine, for the killing of countless Palestinians (women, children etc). If justice is served by putting on trial all Nazi criminals decades after the crimes were committed, then why not punish people for contemporary crimes?
13:54 May 13, 2009 by Conquistador
That would include trying a lot of Hamas and Fatah members.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
For comment quoting and other advanced formatting features,
try posting via this article's discussion forum page instead.
Today's headlines
TRAGEDY IN DUISBURG
Photo: DPA

Own party now turns on Duisburg mayor

Embattled Duisburg Mayor Adolf Sauerland faced demands to resign from his own conservative party on Friday over the Love Parade tragedy that left 21 people dead. READ »

Photo: DPA

Germany wins double-gold at European championships

Germany scored double-gold Thursday night at the European Athletics Championships in Barcelona, taking first place in both the women’s 100 metres sprint and the javelin throw. READ »

Photo: DPA

Skilled migrants urgently needed, says minister

With Germany industry facing a looming skills shortage, Economy Minister Rainer Brüderle revealed on Friday he was planning a major recruitment drive to attract skilled migrants. READ (1 COMMENT) »

Photo: DPA

Behemoth wine barrel to be tapped after 400 years

The world’s oldest giant wine barrel, held in a Saxony-Anhalt hunting mansion, has been refilled for the first time in its 400-year history and will be filling glasses at a festival beginning on Friday. READ (1 COMMENT) »

Photo: DPA

Elderly woman robbed by fake relative after weekend reunion

Police are searching for a woman who robbed a retiree after she claimed to be a relative and spent the weekend at her home along with a child and dog, police said on Thursday. READ »

Mothers with their children at the employment centre. Photo: DPA

Single-parent families on the rise in Germany

The number of single-parent families in Germany has risen over the past decade, with nearly one in five mothers and fathers now raising their children on their own, a national “microcensus” revealed Thursday. READ (3 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Weatherman Kachelmann released from jail

Four months after he was arrested for allegedly raping his girlfriend, weatherman Jörg Kachelmann was released from custody on Thursday. READ (3 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Home offices should be tax-deductible, court rules

Teachers, professors and other people who keep a second office at home are in for a windfall after a court ruled Thursday that tax deductions on home offices should be expanded. READ (2 COMMENTS) »

More National
Highlights
Photo: El Pais
GALLERY »
Remembering the Love Parade victims: They came from across Germany and as far as Australia, Bosnia and China. Fourteen young Germans and seven foreigners died in the hellish crush at the Love Parade in Duisburg on July 24.
Photo:Warner Bros.
LIFESTYLE »
The Local's English-language movie listings for Germany
Photo: DPA
SPONSORED ARTICLE
Beyond Oktoberfest: A guide to German beer and wine festivals

See all ads | Join the Marketplace

Jobs in Germany, in English

799 jobs available
469 new jobs this week
6 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Latest news from The Local in Sweden
Blog
Essentials

Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your style? Find a German sweetheart here.

Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather section.

Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.

Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of charge.

Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

News from the Goethe-Institut
News from Young Germany
News from DeutschlandOnline
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd
JOB: Sales position @ Globe Business College Munich
GBCM is currently seeking an experienced sales person to work in the area of student recruitment in Germany and internationally
FULL JOB DETAILS
JOB: Customer Service Agent - Munich
Mr Lodge GmbH, Germany's biggest agency for furnished apartments, is looking for an English native speaker
FULL JOB DETAILS
Sales managers - country wide
The Local is seeking talented and experienced media sales professionals for our online advertising sales in Germany
FULL JOB DETAILS
Flat rate internet + free calls to USA, UK, Canada and more
Surf‘n’Talk service from TKS offers a powerful combination of high-speed Internet connectivity along with an around-the-clock flat for calls to your “home country”. Find out more at the TKS website.
INFO > www.tkscable.com

The Local Europe GmbH
Linienstrasse 214
10119 Berlin
Germany