Photo: DPA

Cheap coffee as tasty as pricey java

Published: 25 Apr 09 09:35 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/society/20090425-18863.html

A test by professional coffee tasters tried 31 kinds of coffee and gave brands from discounters Lidl and Aldi top marks, Bild reported Saturday.

The Bellarom Gold and Markus Gold brands from Lidl and Aldi won the taste-off against more expensive organic and fair-trade brands.

“These coffee brands were also the best value in the test and each cost €2.49 for 500 grammes,” Hubertus Primus, a tester with the Stiftung Warentest foundation, which organised the battle of the beans.

Twenty of the 31 brands tested received the grade of “good.” Some brands fared much worse though. Tchibo’s Gran Cafe, Tip Gold from Metro and the A&P brand from Kaisers all got the score of “mediocre” for “musty” flavouring. The Gala Nr. 1 brand from coffee house Eduscho got the worst score. Testers said it tasted “of wet paper.”

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Fark It! Digg This  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

15:15 April 27, 2009 by Moondancer
If we are gonna talk about coffee. We used to get coffee from Tegut called "Pedro". You could get beans or ground. All of a sudden it disappeared. I have looked everywhere for this brand, cause it is truly the best coffee we have ever had. Does anyone know where Pedro is still sold? Especially anywhere in the Frankfurt area or near by.

Thanks
15:32 April 27, 2009 by Bipa
Here's a table with results from Stiftung Warentest. The coffee I buy isn't there, but who cares as long as my husband and I like it. In the end it doesn't really matter what other folks like since you're the one drinking it.

NB: For those who can't see the embedded link:

"http://www.test.de/themen/essen-trinken/test/-Kaffee/1772611/1772611/1771568/1773145/"
15:44 April 27, 2009 by keepingtime
I agree with Bipa that it does not matter. Drink what you like. Aldi brand coffee is good. I can not stand starbucks. Tchibo is okay. I like the Aldi Earl Grey tea. If there was a tea test I would like to know how well they did concerning the tea.
17:11 April 27, 2009 by Oblomov
The Aldi coffee is pretty good. I do wonder about the "packaging" criteria, though. All the different coffee brands seem to be packaged exactly the same way.
18:20 April 27, 2009 by siskebap
if anybody is interested, I could give you the results of my personal tests with Aldi coffee last year and Rewe Espresso this year

Aldi coffee bags, 20 pieces 1,59 Euro. Total 144 gramms or each bag 7 gramm.

I open them and put them into the Aldi Filter and add boiling water for 1 cup.

Aldi Red = best coffee, mild and full flavour

Aldi Black = used it for a month, very good coffee, but really strong. Would only recommend one in the morning

Aldi Green = Says "Mild". Roasted too much. Has the burned taste.

Aldi White = Decaf. Is o.k. as a substitute, but doesnt have the fire of the red one

I also tried out the low-cost Rewe Coffee bags, they do cost 1,69 Euro for 18 pieces. Also have a similar color scheme. But none of them can beat the taste of the Aldi Red.

You can see at Aldi that the Aldi Red 20 Bag box and the Aldi Black 20 Bag box are mostly sold out - like this afternoon at Aldi Schwanthalerstrasse.

The White and Green stack up.

Where Rewe wins is the Ja Coffee cream, 20 pieces for 49 Cent. If you like to drink your Coffee with cream, this one tastes better than the products from Aldi/Lidl/Plus

Where Plus wins is the Day Plus Süßstoff, 1200 sweeteners for 99 Cent. That may be an individual thing, but I only buy them.

Best Coffee Filter is the inexpensive one at Aldi. I tried out the inexpensive filters from Lidl/Rewe/Plus/Kaufland and for me the Aldi Coffee Filter transports the flavour the best.

Espresso, prepared with the 50 Euro Aldi Espresso Machine - which you unfortunately can´t buy any longer

Rewe - Segafredo casa - best taste, good flavour, pretty strong, you feel that it is a good espresso. ~3,50 Euro, mostly sold out

Rewe - Lavazza crema e gusto - a very good mild espresso, it is very funny this one feels a little bit colder for me. But the preparation is the same. ~3,30 Euro

Rewe - Lavazza Black in a can - I know 2 girls that do have 1-2 of that cans in their kitchen, but I do not like this one. But the can is o.k. ~5,50 Euro

Rewe - Rewe Espresso - tastes good. This is a dark one and even if it is prepared in an espresso machine, it has something of the taste that you get out of a steam cooker. 3,00 Euro

Rewe - Lilly Espresso. I never tried this one out, it is very expensive with ~7,50 Euro for 250 gramm

One more test, the Tschibo Cafissimo Espresso/Coffee Machine. 10 Capsules are 2,49 Euro. The Red Espresso is mostly sold out

Red Capsules - Espresso. Very good, has taste and fire. Better than the espresso in most Restaurants/Cafes

Orange Capsules - Caffee Crema. I don´t like it, it tastes like if it is roasted too much.

Blue Capsules - Caffee. I don´t like it, doesn´t have much flavour or much fire

I don´t like the other Espresso capsules, I buy them sometimes if the red box is sold out, they may taste a little bit spicier or more mild, but they do not have the same fire.

So far I looked into the Rewe 30 times to buy Capsules and the Red Espresso was sold out maybe 20 times.

I would recommend to heat up the empty cups in a microwave 30/60 seconds at 600/300 Watt - that is really the only use for a microwave oven for me.

You could also put some boiling water into the cup for 5 seconds, that will do the same thing.
03:37 April 28, 2009 by idmacg
Surely, we must recognise that the main reason we are switching to the Bio and Fair Trade Coffees are on the grounds firstly of health (Organic coffees use no poisons and chemical fertilisers) and of 'Fair Trade' which means that we do our part to ensure that the farmers in Ethiopia, or Brazil, Mexico etc... get a fair price for coffee

Fetilisers and bug sprays are posion - they kill things, if a substance kills a grasshopper or whatever, then it is highly probable, that that substance is not too good for human consumption either

+There is a government imposed Kaffeesteur on all coffee imported or roasted in Germany. - That steuer is 2.19E per kilo, 1.10 per 500g. If the final price - retail is Euro 2.50, considering packaging, transport, storage and retail mark-up, can you imagine what the farmer is recieving for those beans?

Their is a very good film. Black Gold. Worth a view. When you purchase the products listed above you are supporting a rampant abuse of power.
06:40 April 28, 2009 by silty1
I like my rampant abuse of power with a little skim milk, no sugar.
09:54 April 28, 2009 by lordkorner
I have tried many different types of coffee and I have to say that the Markus double pack from Aldi won hands down every time,wouldn't buy anything else now.
10:28 April 28, 2009 by fraufruit
We like the Aldi espresso beans - I think the name is Tizio. Better than or as good as Segafredo and the others at half the price of what we were paying in Italy.
11:49 April 28, 2009 by siskebap
When you purchase the products listed above you are supporting a rampant abuse of power.
existence is pollution and existence is support for big global companies.

You could maybe change the balance, but I think it is still difficult to get around companies like Nestle or Oil-companies. If you do avoid their products direct, you will buy their products indirect under other labels or you will pay profit to people that buy their products. These people may give their part to the save-the-whales-foundation, but could also buy again products from big global companies.

In the worst case, you pay 10 Euro for the amount of the coffee/tea that you get at Aldi for 1.50 Euro. What happens with the other 8,50 Euro? One can not say.
11:59 April 28, 2009 by Katrina
If you like espresso, try Dinzler. I was loyal to Illy for a long time, but this is great - I don't drink coffee often but when I do, I want a great one. That's what Dinzler is.
12:23 April 28, 2009 by RainyDays
existence is pollution and existence is support for big global companies.

You could maybe change the balance, but I think it is still diffi…
Thanks for the evaluation of different coffee brands in your post #7. However, I disagree with your above statement. There still are smaller coffee companies. For example, I drink Darboven fairtrade coffee, which is listed among the best in the Stiftung Warentest table Bipa posted. Sure, the Aldi coffee isn't bad either, but I prefer to pay more because coffee is one of the goods which is most affected by volatile, so to speak "unfair" world market prices (while the production costs remain the same).

Just a quick glance at the wiki article about coffee reveals that there are huge differences between the different beans (Arabica being more demanding than Robusta; other rarer bean types), the cultivation (forest or sun cultivation and its ecological consequences) and the harvesting method (hand-picked or by machines). I guess (hope) that is where the remaining 8,50 Euros go ? into avoiding ecologically harmful production methods as much as possible and paying the workers better. I also think that the overall quality of coffee deteriorates if there is a competition for the most cost-effective production instead of for best value for price.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
For comment quoting and other advanced formatting features,
try posting via this article's discussion forum page instead.
Today's headlines
Photo: DPA

Sarrazin sparks calls for new integration debate

With President Christian Wulff expected to announce soon the dismissal of central banker Thilo Sarrazin over inflammatory race and immigration comments, leading politicians called on Friday for a renewed integration debate. READ (4 COMMENTS) »

The ordination in Leipzig. Photo: DPA

New rabbis signal Jewish renaissance in Germany

Judaism is making a comeback in Germany 65 years after the Holocaust, thanks largely to immigration from the former Soviet Union, as shown by this week’s ordination of two rabbis in the eastern city of Leipzig. READ »

Nicholas Berggruen (left) with von der Leyen and Görg. Photo: DPA

Deal to keep Karstadt alive moves closer

The prospects for 25,000 employees at the beleaguered department store chain Karstadt are looking brighter after it emerged Thursday night that negotiators were close to striking a deal on reduced rent on the chain’s properties. READ »

Photo: DPA

Germany faces big expectations in Euro 2012 qualifier

Germany faces Belgium on Friday with coach Joachim Löw expecting three points from his team's opening Euro 2012 qualifier as the Germans look to build on their momentum from the World Cup. READ »

Photo: DPA

'Generation porno' more chaste than debased

Teens today may not be growing up too quickly after all. A new study on German youth sexuality revealed on Thursday that boys and girls are waiting longer to have sex and then having less of it than they were just five years ago. READ (2 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Court rules sacking man for charging e-scooter unlawful

The state of North Rhine-Westphalia’s labour court ruled on Thursday that a company had acted unlawfully when it fired an employee of 19-years for using less than two cents worth of electricity to charge up his scooter. READ (7 COMMENTS) »

Photo: Samsung

Samsung unveils wannabe iPad killer

Samsung on Thursday unveiled a gadget at the IFA electronics trade fair in Berlin that it hopes will eventually rival Apple's highly successful iPad tablet PC. READ »

Photo: DPA

Vegetarian activists dupe media with 'cannibal eatery' hoax

Vegetarian activists exposed their hoax on the German media on Thursday, revealing a new Berlin restaurant supposedly looking for human 'donors' was a public relations stunt to highlight the human cost of eating meat. READ (13 COMMENTS) »

More Society
Highlights
Photo: Frankfurt's Rheingau wine festival
LIFESTYLE »
What's on in Germany: September 2 - 8
Photo: Universal Pictures
LIFESTYLE »
The Local's English-language movie listings for Germany
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
Inflammatory comments on Muslims and race by Bundesbank board member Thilo Sarrazin have caused widespread outrage. The Local’s media roundup explores the repercussions.
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
The atomic energy industry is pushing to delay Germany’s phase-out of nuclear power. But Marcus Gatzke from ZEIT ONLINE warns doing so could hurt the country’s switch to renewable energy – and consumers’ pocketbooks.
Photo: DPA
SPONSORED ARTICLE
Beyond Oktoberfest: A guide to German beer and wine festivals

See all ads | Join the Marketplace

Jobs in Germany, in English

745 jobs available
449 new jobs this week
70 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Latest news from The Local in Sweden
Blog
Essentials

Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your style? Find a German sweetheart here.

Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather section.

Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.

Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of charge.

Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

News from the Goethe-Institut
News from Young Germany
News from DeutschlandOnline
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd
Flat rate internet + free calls to USA, UK, Canada and more
Surf‘n’Talk service from TKS offers a powerful combination of high-speed Internet connectivity along with an around-the-clock flat for calls to your “home country”. Find out more at the TKS website.
INFO > www.tkscable.com

The Local Europe GmbH
Schwedter Strasse 227
10435 Berlin
Germany