Is Germany segregating women on trains? Not quite
Emma Anderson · 29 Mar 2016, 12:41
Published: 29 Mar 2016 12:41 GMT+02:00
Updated: 29 Mar 2016 12:41 GMT+02:00
- First suspect charged with sexual assault in Cologne (24 Mar 16)
- Germany tightens rape law in wake of Cologne assaults (16 Mar 16)
- Photos help police nab New Year sex assault suspects (09 Mar 16)
One private regional train operator said last week that one of its train lines will offer the option for women travelling by themselves or with children to sit with other women.
But the optional seating arrangement, offered by Mitteldeutsche Regiobahn (MRB), is not as novel nor far-reaching as some international headlines make it seem.
1. Just one private company has made the offer, not all German railways
First of all, the offer is just for the line travelling between Leipzig and Chemnitz in eastern Germany and is optional rather than mandatory, a spokesperson from MRB told The Local.
Each train along this line will have in the coming weeks two seating areas for women and travelling mothers, located next to already designated quiet zones and customer service sections.
2. 'Nothing to do with sexual harassment'
Many have speculated that the new offer is a response to the mass reports of sexual assaults against women on New Year's Eve in Cologne and elsewhere.
But the company has insisted that the section for female travellers is simply in line with what other rail operators have already offered for some time.
An MRB spokesperson told The Local that the company created the sections at the request of families, seniors and women travelling alone with children.
"The proposal for this came from passengers who want more privacy," the spokesperson told The Local.
"It has nothing to do with sexual harassment," an MRB spokesperson told broadcaster MDR last week. "This is an extra service offer, using the examples of the Austrian train system and the ICE and IC train operators."
Which brings us to the third point:
3. This is not a new idea
Deutsche Bahn, whose single shareholder is the German government, offers a "ladies compartment" on the City Night Line overnight sleeping cars for women travelling by themselves.
The ICE, EC and IC trains run by Deutsche Bahn often also offer optional sections for parents travelling with small children.
A Czech rail operator in 2012 also rolled out a women's only section where men could also sit, unless the women there said no, and Austrian operator ÖBB also has ladies' sections.
4. And it's not just trains that have offered women-only spaces
Photo: JG-NF / Wikimedia Commons.
Since the 1990s, various regions around Germany have put in "women's only" parking spaces which were well-lit, monitored by security cameras and closer to car park exits after female drivers expressed concern about sexual assault.
Women's parking spaces at places like Frankfurt Airport are also larger, which some say is based on the stereotype that women are bad drivers.
5. Helpful security measure or simply not right?
News of the train company's offer has set off a storm of debate online about whether such compartments are effective safety measures, whether they discriminate against men or men of a certain ethnicity, or whether they are simply not enough to stop everyday sexism.
In response, the German hashtag #imzugpassiert (it happened in a train) has started trending on Twitter with women sharing examples of times they felt harassed while travelling.
"I travelled with two 13-year-olds. It was hot and they both wore short dresses. A man by the corridor held his phone and took pictures under their skirts," wrote one Twitter user.
#imzugpassiert fahre m zwei 13-Jährigen.Es ist heiß,beide tragen kurze Kleider.Typ amGang hält Handy in Abteil u fotografiert unter dRöcke— Julya Rabinowich (@JulyaRabinowich) March 25, 2016
"Women's compartments mean 'the world belongs to men and they are allowed to move freely through it. For women, there are special spaces.' #NotOKAtAll," wrote another.