• Germany's news in English
 
app_header_v3
Opinion
A new prostitution law would harm sex workers
File photo: DPA

A new prostitution law would harm sex workers

The Local · 3 Dec 2015, 12:22

Published: 03 Dec 2015 12:22 GMT+01:00

After two years of negotiations, the German Federal Ministry for Families, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth shared its second draft of a new prostitution law last week.

A reform has been on the cards since elections in 2013, with the governing coalition agreeing that prostitution should be reformed, in part to better protect the victims of human trafficking.

But so far there has been no consensus on what exactly has changed – and how to respond – since the law was last updated in 2002.

Why should the law be changed?

Researchers agree that the 2002 law, widely decried as "legalizing prostitution" and blamed for an increase in human trafficking, has never been fully implemented.

But that hasn't stopped politicians and the media from loading blame for the supposed catastrophic state of sex workers in Germany onto these three paragraphs – using the law to score easy points with the public.

Few in Germany or abroad questioned the idea that the law had led to an explosion of human trafficking in Germany and left many sex workers “unprotected”.

The idea that trafficking had increased was even aired in the recent campaign to prevent Amnesty International adopting a stance supporting the decriminalization of sex work.

SEE ALSO: Bitter battle greets call to decriminalize sex work

But nobody bothered to fact-check the claim of increased trafficking.

If they had, they would have found that that sex work had been legal long before 2002, and that human trafficking has actually been steadily decreasing according to official statistics of the Federal Criminal Bureau (Bundeskriminalamt).

Currently, every year about 600 people (557 in 2014) are officially recognized as victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation – a fall of 43 percent since the peak in 2004, when 972 victims of human trafficking were identified.

A concerted campaign against legal sex work

So if trafficking isn't the scourge it's presented as, what's behind the push for reform?

It's certainly been spurred by a perceived increase in sex businesses and migrant sex workers from Romania and Bulgaria.

But most of all there has been a concerted campaign to backtrack on the 2002 law and to restrict the legality of sex work.

Two years ago, just after the elections, an anti-prostitution campaign launched by media entrepreneur Alice Schwarzer decried the supposed failure of the 2002 law, denouncing a rise in sex trafficking. She called Germany "Europe’s Brothel".

SEE ALSO: Calls grow to raise sex worker age limit

Veteran left-wing feminist Schwarzer has long sided with law-and-order hardliners from the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and Christian Social Union (CSU) on prostitution.

She agreed with their calls for sex workers to be subject to compulsory medical checks and forced to register with the police, as well as overall police surveillance of sex workers and sex businesses.

At the same time, she ignored that politicians for the CSU were involved in the construction of a brothel as investors in the Bavarian town of Dachau. For them, it was just a “business like any other”.

Protection through coercion is bound to fail

While compulsory medical checks – a measure that today is considered a human rights violation – are off the table in the draft law, the establishment of what activists call a national “whore database” is not.

Before registration, sex workers (but not clients) would need to undergo mandatory health counselling, where leaflets on their rights and duties will be handed out. One of the explicitly mentioned duties: pay taxes.

Both registration and mandatory counselling have been widely criticized by NGOs, such as the German Women’s Council and the German Association of Women Lawyers, but also NGOs with a religious background such as the Diakonie.

All of them oppose the introduction of compulsory measures expected to stigmatize sex workers.

The introduction of additional layers of bureaucracy would also worsen the lack of trust many sex workers have towards the authorities. This is especially true for migrant sex workers from countries where police violence and corruption thrives.

SEE ALSO: Job centre adviser demanded sex for work

But the idea of compulsory registration goes further: The goal is to prevent those pushed into sex work by force or circumstance from registering.

That means women who sell sex for survival would be pushed into working illegally if refused registration, risking fines of up to €1,000 - on top of the poverty that drove them into sex work.

So much is obvious from prostitution rates in, for example, the USA, where sex work remains illegal across much of the country.

What's more, the new law shows staggering naiveté by suggesting that a bureaucrat could recognize a victim of trafficking in the sterile environment of an office.

Research shows that even experienced police officers and social workers find it hard to recognize trafficking. Trust towards the authorities is essential to exposing it. But that trust would be destroyed by compulsory registration under threat of a fine.

And what if officials do decide to someone may be a victim of trafficking once they've already been registered as a sex worker?

It's very likely that proving that status to the police would be much more difficult – after all, the state would have declared that person to be doing sex work "willingly" by allowing them to register in the first place.

It's not hard to imagine the authorities dismissing claims by sex workers with reference to the “Whore ID” – the proof that sex work is “voluntary”.

Sex workers' rights don’t matter

Critics have drawn on the Constitution and human rights law to oppose what they call the "Whore ID". But Germany's government is keen to wriggle around such rights.

They've already abolished sex workers' right to “inviolability of the home”, essentially allowing the police to enter their apartments whenever they wish.

Story continues below…

Suspicion of sex work would be enough to enter the premises – thus putting anyone, especially women, with an active sex life and multiple partners at risk of such raids - unlike the situation now, when all sex work is legal.

In times of increasing attacks on women’s sexual self-determination, it's easy to imagine sexist neighbours denouncing such a woman as an unregistered “whore”.

Such critique is unwelcome and unheard among the governing parties, who insist they want to protect women – despite being made aware of the failings of their proposed law.

In official commentary on the draft law, they have admitted that sex workers may not submit to it and simply not register. In that case, the law would have failed.

Whorephobia against sex workers

Despite the obvious weaknesses of the proposed law, critics and in particular sex workers’ rights organizations, such as the newly founded BesD, the federation for sexual and erotic services, are being attacked as the “prostitution lobby”.

DON'T MISS: Prostitutes vow to resist sex work law

Anti-prostitution campaigners have been quite successful in publicly discrediting anyone who critically engages with calls to abolish prostitution or to tighten the policing of sex workers.

Instead of asking sex workers with good working conditions how everyone in the sex industry could achieve them, the best-off sex workers are being discredited as “privileged” - as if such "privilege" wasn’t something every person selling sex deserves.

SEE ALSO: The cop who switched from blue light to red

And while sex workers are attacked as “prostitution lobbyists”, CSU politicians, and more generally, male brothel owners are barely ever criticized in the media. The media bias against sex workers remains.

No wonder that the planned law reflects what sex workers call “whorephobia” – the hatred, disdain and sense of disgust that many still feel towards sex workers.  

Sonja Dolinsek is a researcher at the University of Erfurt working on the politics of sex work and anti-trafficking. Find her on Twitter here.

For more news from Germany, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Five sure-fire ways to impress Germans with your manners
Chancellor Angela Merkel showing up French President François Hollande in a neighbourly battle of table manners. Photo: DPA.

Despite what stereotypes might have you believe, Germans aren't that different from the rest of us when it comes to social interactions. But these tips should at least help guide you through the minor quirks that come with your next dinner invitation.

Thugs' ‘dream cop’ in court for not investigating 100 cases
Fans at a VfL Bochum match set off flares. Photo: DPA

For three years a police officer in western Germany simply ignored many of the cases he was supposed to investigate. His trial started on Tuesday in Bochum.

Police arrest suspect in murder of Chinese student
Police secure the crime scene where Yanjie Lie's body was found on May 13th. Photo: DPA

Police have made an arrest in the case of a Chinese student murdered while she was out jogging a week ago, media reported on Tuesday.

Berlin thief shows heart in surprising act of kindness
Photo: DPA

Pickpockets are an ever more common phenomenon in the German capital. But sometimes they can surprise you.

Bayer's Monsanto bid
Monsanto takeover would be 'diabolical': environmentalists
An anti-Monsanto activist at a protest in Brandenburg in 2014. Photo: DPA

A proposed tie-up between Bayer and Monsanto has inflamed opinion in Germany where most people oppose genetically modified foods.

Why Greece is top of Germany's to-do list - again
Unemployed Greek workers with symbolically chained hands march on May 1st in Athens. Photo: DPA

Greece has been in the headlines more often this year for its front-line role in the refugee crisis than its finances – so just why is it top of Germany's agenda again all of a sudden?

Far-right AfD turns on itself over failed Muslim meeting
Jörg Meuthen. Photo: DPA

The co-leader of the far-right Alternative for Germany party has criticized his party colleagues after talks with Muslim leaders collapsed after just an hour on Monday.

Here's why Munich is worth 20 times more than Berlin
BMW's headquarters in Munich. Photo: DPA

The Bavarian capital leaves other German cities in the dust when it comes to where the highest-valued companies choose to plant their flag.

Bavaria tries to coax migrants into police force
Joachim Herrmann (cr) with police recruits in Nuremberg. Photo: DPA

Bavaria’s interior ministry has started a campaign to encourage more migrants to join up as officers of the law - whether they have a German passport or not.

Extremist violence 'exploded' in record year for refugees
Left-wing violence at the Blockupy protest in Frankfurt in March 2015. Photo: DPA.

It is now official: 2015 smashed all records for political violence, as the far right attacked refugee homes and the far left responded by attacking them in turn, Interior Ministry figures show.

Sponsored Article
Eat, learn, live: unforgettable holidays in France
Lifestyle
6 things about Munich that will stay with you forever
Technology
Church plans to connect with faithful at Wi-Fi 'Godspots'
Technology
Online hate speech can cost users thousands of Euros
Society
Bavarians in rush for non-lethal weapons licenses
Sport
Here's Germany's Mannschaft for Euro 2016
Culture
The Syrian pianist playing his way into Germans' hearts
The parrot who flew fast enough to trigger a speed camera
Business & Money
Surprise results give Germany strongest growth in two years
Technology
New law could let free Wi-Fi bloom across Germany
Politics
Berlin's plans to beef up the German army
Munich
The bloody knife attack that shocked a Bavarian town
National
Supermarkets must pay massive fine for fixing beer prices
Sport
Lufthansa's Euro 2016 ad takes aim at England
Culture
The 6 German words you need to know for spring
Culture
6 weird and wonderful ways Germans celebrate May 1st
Gallery
Feast your eyes on Germany in springtime bloom
National
4/20: Five things to know about weed in Germany
Berlin
Police break up hipster swarm at vegan restaurant opening
Politics
Merkel allows Erdogan case against German satirist to go ahead
Travel
7 of Germany's most jaw-dropping national parks
Hamburg
Gay penguins move to Hamburg to settle down
Business & Money
See-through €5 coin has collectors lining up
Health
Vegan hemp powder recalled over fear toddlers getting high
7,734
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd