• Germany edition
 
Leftists demand 100 percent tax on the rich
Photo: DPA

Leftists demand 100 percent tax on the rich

Published: 01 Feb 2013 10:25 GMT+01:00
Updated: 01 Feb 2013 10:25 GMT+01:00

“We are suggesting that no-one should earn over 40 times the societal minimum,” said The Left's co-leader Katja Kipping in the party's draft election platform, which was seen by regional newspaper the Mitteldeutsche Zeitung.

The party paper said the total tax on those taking home over €40,000 per month would be used to fund social welfare and investing in the country's future.

“Explosive inequality is threatening democracy,” said co-leader Bernd Riexinger. “I call capping income at half a million euros a democracy tax.”

The upcoming campaign for Germany's election in September was going to be one focused on wealth redistribution, said Riexinger.

The Left, born from a merger of former East German communists and disgruntled trade unionists, has struggled to raise its profile under its new leadership after failing to make political capital from the global financial crisis. It sits in the Bundestag and several state parliaments, but failed to win representation in Lower Saxony last month.

Tacking hard to the left with its 100 percent tax idea could mean the party has given up all hope of tempting the centre-left Social Democrats into a coalition at the federal level after this September's general election.

French President Francois Hollande tried recently to impose a 75 percent tax on top earners, but was struck down by the country's courts.

DPA/The Local/jcw

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

10:56 February 1, 2013 by zeddriver
From the article. The Left, born from a merger of former East German communists and disgruntled trade unionists.

What! They just don't get it. Their system collapsed. It is human instinct to want to do better for ones self. Whether it be gathering grain and meat to save for the bad times. Or making more money to put away for the bad times. Or to hand down to your heirs.

As I recall. The heads of the communist/socialist parties throughout history always treated them selves rather nicely. But we must not talk about that. Communists/ socialists always operate on a theoretical ideal. And minus the innate human drive to do more to secure the future of ones self. This communal everybody shares equally might work. But I dare them to show a point in history that it has actually worked.
10:57 February 1, 2013 by pepsionice
We can do better than this....let's go to 101-percent taxation. Make it bold and interesting....as you flame out. And while at this redistribution business...let's force people living in Stuttgart to move to Hamburg, and people in Munich to move to Wiesbaden. Onward and forward, or such.
11:06 February 1, 2013 by whiteriver
very populist action and most probably the extra income is not significant. Like in France, people will move their assets abroad to avoid the high tax.
11:21 February 1, 2013 by Aasvogel
"¦quot;We are suggesting that no-one should earn over 40 times the societal minimum,¦quot; said The Left's co-leader Katja Kipping in the party's draft election platform, which was seen by regional newspaper the Mitteldeutsche Zeitung."

No you are not.

You are suggesting that the state loot and redistribute every euro fairly earned by anyone capable of doing so above an arbitrary limit of 40 times the minimum wage, which is also an arbitrary amount. Well, not quite every euro. A big chunk of euros will feed the bloated state bureaucracy that runs this highway robbery.

There is nothing new in state looting of successful individuals. Nothing good, either.

This will simply accelerate the departure of the most able, the future employers, job creators and innovators to more tax-friendly countries.

Another own goal from the left wing. Well done.
11:30 February 1, 2013 by DoubleDTown
You'd think since Katja grew up in DD that she'd have some familial experience with the tragedy of the commons and have learned that Socialism doesn't work. On the other hand, since she has never had a real job (as far as I can tell from her Linke bio) and continued her studies while already supposedly serving full time as a politician, perhaps she has closed a blind eye to the tragedy of the commons and that is why she mistakenly soldiers on believing that some other phantom "rich" person will always refresh the resources of the commons so that society has a commons to enjoy. Put this up there with her idea that there should be no politics on weekends so that politicians can enjoy a better family life... When does she think her few supporters are going rally for her? While they are at work Monday to Friday?
11:31 February 1, 2013 by Eastard
There is a global perception evolving that rich and poor are accidents requiring a fix. In each country there are groups who seek attention/votes with orations of where to get more money for those who want it... In the US it is Obama selling wealth with his union attitude speeches that are attractive to anyone believing they will benefit. That is now the plural voter in the US...and Greece... and France.... Be careful that you, Germany, do not end up with the same imbalance. Yes 100% tax is ridiculous, however be careful because it is also attractive to a growing number of have-nots who really don't care... "I'll take care of you at someone else's expense" has been used to buy allot of votes in recent times...
11:35 February 1, 2013 by pjnt
Stupid article. TL brings out this same story every month or two. I guess it generates activity on their site.

Doh! Got caught again.
13:04 February 1, 2013 by ichbines
I hope they take region and marital status into consideration because 40k does not get you very far here, at least not in Frankfurt. In Berlin it gets you an only mildly luxury lifestyle, for example you could maybe buy a car, but not a house at least not if you eat bio and wear suits to work. But of course 500k is above and beyond what any normal person/family would need regardless of region and marital status.
15:47 February 1, 2013 by taiwanluthiers
Now we know the Deutsche Democratik Republik has won and has taken over the EU.
19:00 February 1, 2013 by agbjr
¦quot;Explosive inequality is threatening democracy,¦quot; said co-leader Bernd Riexinger. ¦quot;I call capping income at half a million euros a democracy tax.¦quot;

Typical Marxist, wants to take everything away from those who actually produce to distribute to those they themselves deem more deserving and calling it "fair" and in the name of "democracy". Asinine. Just remember there was no democracy in the "equal" DDR.
20:35 February 1, 2013 by Englishted
@ zeddriver

"As I recall. The heads of the communist/socialist parties throughout history always treated them selves rather nicely. But we must not talk about that. "

Throughout history ?, the very first would be Russia in 1917 hardly along time although your other points are valid .

Personally having read Marx ,I find very little difference between that and "love thy neighbours as yourself" do unto others as you would have them do to you.

Just because the people who implemented got it very wrong does not mean that the principle and the theory is incorrect.
23:23 February 1, 2013 by vonSchwerin
100% tax? What planet do these people live on? (Wait, I know: Planet Marxengelsulbrichthonecker.)

Obviously, this will never be enacted, but the day it does, that is the day that the German economy completely collapses and Siemans, VW, Daimler, and every other German firm loses its entire upper management to American or even, Chinese and Russian firms. 500.000 Euros sounds like a massive sum if you are a Hausmeister making 20.000 Euros a year. If you are a heart surgeon making 300.000 Euros a year, 500.000 isn't that far off. We're not talking about 5.000.000 Euros a year, which still -- obviously -- should not be taxed at 100% or anything close to it.

This is so laughable in its pathetic populism, it wasn't even worth publishing.
00:34 February 2, 2013 by zeddriver
@Englishted

history. "the study of past events" That would apply to even a minute ago. :)

I disagree with the premise that those in the past just got it wrong. It went wrong due to human nature. But you are correct in that the theoretical idea of "from each according to their means. To each according to their needs"

Sounds great for sure. But until you totally eliminate the instinctual human trait of trying to better ones self and "getting ahead" Or the corrupting influence of power. It will never work.

I might ask the communist/socialist next door the following.

Did you go to collage or learn a skill? If so why? Did you do it "just because". Or was it to better yourself by gaining knowledge or to get a better job. If everyone gets paid equally. Why would you want to go through 8 years or more of higher education to become a Dr. and then get paid the same as an unskilled laborer.

That's why the theoretical ideals of communism won't work. And always has to be forced upon the population. Look at modern China. How did they as communist's become so successful? Easy. The communist government backed off the pure hard line commy ideals and adopted capitalist policies. OPPS!
09:43 February 2, 2013 by Englishted
@zeddriver

Looking at modern China ,I would put down most of the growth to Western companies who are prepared to sacrifice workers jobs in search of a quick profit,that and the fact China pays so poor wages and totally unsafe working conditions that production cost attract greed minded capitalist with no interest in the long term well being of anyone or anything but themselves.

I would also point out that according to your ideas none of the world religions can work and only the one with the biggest gun can dictate the lifestyle of the rest .

Which is probably true but a damming indictment if one were needed on mankind.

With unemployment high in the €uro zone and not likely to go down because of no job creation and outsourcing that would be a better OPPS! ;-(
12:40 February 2, 2013 by Louie
Comment removed by The Local for breach of our terms.
14:20 February 2, 2013 by Vargaz
The real question is: What are the cigars these leftists smoking made from? Sounds like a combination of crack, fantasy dust, and jealousy. Keep huffing and puffing pinko all you want, this is one haas you'll never blow down.
19:16 February 2, 2013 by Englishted
@ Louie

With a low tax rate ,"they have fled to other countries to organize industries that outsell and bankrupt yours."

It is called selfish greed in my book.
20:04 February 2, 2013 by raandy
communism what a failed ideology, and yet there are these dupes than continue to promote it, kinda like beating a dead horse.
02:59 February 3, 2013 by alliskool
It seems that taxing the rich is the new norm, or the idea of it anyways. Per the German news source, the German leftist party is considering a 100% tax on anyone making over €500,000.

If anyone has read any economics course, or has common sense, would see why this would be a terrible mandate. Also, what is not clear is that if it only applies to people? And how much is corporate tax is going to be affected by the mandate. However, a 100% taxation on income after a certain threshold will discourage hardworking and geniune people from working and creating social value through their businesses. There is limited data on how many persons make such money. It is to be noted that it may work some very smart people from joining specific area of work. For example, if the same mandate is applied to income from financial institutions (or capped to per say a million euros), it will actually drive smart people to other industries (small businesses, technology), which may create increased value in socity as compared to banks. (read more at http://laymanfinance.com)
00:07 February 4, 2013 by Eric1
Leftist, communist, socialist, are the greediest people on Earth.
12:01 February 4, 2013 by Steve Potts
And will the rich people pay 100% tax or just flee?

The UK Labour part tried this in the 1970s by imposing a 97% tax rate on the very wealthy and of course most of the wealthy just up sticks and moved. Not a very bright idea...
14:59 February 13, 2013 by hboag
There is a growing cry from the liberal left in America that want to do the same thing; tax the "rich" and redistribute it to the Presidents voting blocks in order to shore up the next election in 2014 and 2016.
Today's headlines
German of the Week
This professor is Putin's favourite German
A photo of Haag by Russian news agency TASS.

This professor is Putin's favourite German

If you read reports sourced from Russia's state media, you might be forgiven for thinking that Professor Professor Lorenz Haag of the “Global Communication Agency” is a titan of academia. READ  

Jihadist caught on German shopping trip
The man came from Syria for the shopping trip which included a visit to Aldi. Photo: DPA

Jihadist caught on German shopping trip

An alleged jihadist will go on trial in Stuttgart next week after being caught on a shopping trip to pick up goods for Islamic fighters in Syria. READ  

Kidnapped German 'rescued' in Nigeria
Photo: DPA

Kidnapped German 'rescued' in Nigeria

UPDATE: A German national who was kidnapped by gunmen last Friday in southwest Nigeria has been released, police said on Thursday. READ  

Fall of the Wall - 25 years
See how Berlin has changed since Wall fell
The East Side gallery in Friedrichshain. Photo: DPA

See how Berlin has changed since Wall fell

Germany is gearing up to celebrate 25 years since the fall of the Berlin Wall on November 9th 1989. The city has changed more than any other in Europe in that time, as these 11 photos of scenes from then and now show. READ  

Conservatives agree on foreigner road toll
Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt. Photo: DPA

Conservatives agree on foreigner road toll

UPDATE: Germany's conservative alliance has finally agreed to charge foreign motorway users a toll and hopes to raise €500 million a year, but critics say their plan isn't roadworthy. READ  

Court gives Autobahn shooter ten years' jail
The Autobahn shooter faces judges at the beginning of his trial in August. Photo: DPA

Court gives Autobahn shooter ten years' jail

A trucker who fired hundreds of bullets at vehicles and drivers on German motorways for years was sentenced to ten and a half years in prison on Thursday. READ  

Soldiers get more cash and flexi-time
The Bundeswehr hopes the reforms will make it a more attractive employer. Photo: DPA

Soldiers get more cash and flexi-time

Germany's military hopes to become the most attractive employer in the country with better pay and more part-time work in a series of reforms agreed by ministers on Wednesday. READ  

Strikes cost Lufthansa €170 million
A passenger waits at Düsseldorf Airport which was hit by a Lufthansa strike last Tuesday. Photo: DPA

Strikes cost Lufthansa €170 million

Lufthansa, Europe's biggest airline, cut its profit forecast for 2015 on Thursday and said a series of pilot strikes in Germany this year had cost it €170 million. READ  

Fall of the Wall - 25 years
'Little Berlin' remembers fall of its wall
Tractors not tanks at Mödlareuth on the Bavaria-Thuringia border. Photo: DPA

'Little Berlin' remembers fall of its wall

Germany, November 1989: Snow falls as an excited crowd breaks through the Wall and people tearfully embrace loved ones after decades of living apart. But this is Mödlareuth - population 50 - not Berlin. READ  

Police in manslaughter trial over woman's death
The two policemen (pixelated) and their lawyers in court. Photo: DPA

Police in manslaughter trial over woman's death

Two policemen in western Germany are on trial for manslaughter for allegedly standing by as a woman was gunned down by her husband. READ  

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Photo: DPA
Gallery
Want to study in Germany? These are the subjects to choose
Shutterstock
Sponsored Article
Offer: Unlimited airmiles from British Airways
Photo: DPA
Society
Germans are wide of the mark on immigration
Photo: DPA
Society
Halloween: Where are the spookiest spots?
Photo: DPA
Business & Money
Who wants to work in Germany? A third of the world
Photo: DPA
Society
'We can't allow a proxy war on German streets'
Sponsored Article
International School on the Rhine: a legacy
Photo: DPA
Society
QUIZ: How well do you know Germany?
Photo: DPA/Shutterstock
Gallery
11 things Germans are afraid of...
Photo: DPA
Business & Money
JobTalk: All you need to know about working in Germany
National
Share news tips with The Local Germany
Sponsored Article
Bilingual education from nursery to graduation at Phorms
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

3,520
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd