• Germany's news in English
 

Court rules Muslim girl must take swim class

Published: 29 Sep 2012 09:11 GMT+02:00

The 12-year-old, originally from Morocco, is going to school in Frankfurt. She had refused to take part in swimming lessons and had been marked down.

She filed to be given the right to skip the classes, her lawyer arguing that according to the Koran, she was not only forbidden from showing herself to boys but also from seeing boys topless.

An administrative court in Kassel, near Frankfurt, rejected her application.

It said in its ruling that she could wear the full-body swimsuit, known as the "burkini" already used by several girls at her school, which would be enough to guarantee her religious freedom.

The court added that the family had chosen to live in Germany where mixed swimming classes were the norm.

One of the aims of the school system was to promote integration and tolerance, the court added, citing a ruling by Germany's constitutional court.

The applicant would have to put up with the sight of her classmates in their swimming costumes, the court said.

AFP/mw

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

10:28 September 29, 2012 by GolfAlphaYankee
" her lawyer arguing that according to the Koran, she was not only forbidden from showing herself to boys but also from seeing boys topless."

this is BS ! there is no such thing in the Quran....... people will tray to get away with anything by claiming religion freedom .... I suspect the poor girl just can't swim and made up that ridiculous excuse ... her parent, instead of trying to find why she really want to skip the swim class they went along with her.

good for the court !
11:09 September 29, 2012 by Onlythetruth
My son should be excused from swimming class because he cannot control his urge to laugh uncontrollably at the sight of girls in his class dressed from head to toe in ridiculous bathing costumes.
11:20 September 29, 2012 by bwjijsdtd
Well, lets see ... a couple of things come to mind. (1) She can get a pair of swim goggles and paint the lensQuit black, that way she cannot see anything ... (2) Quit having unclean thoughts when see sees bearbreasted boys ... (3) Return to her own country ... (4) Read the Koran for herself to see if what she is being taught is the truth ...
13:15 September 29, 2012 by ATM
This is German please accept the customs and laws of the fine country. I did. If these people do not like then there are planes going back to where they came from That is the one thing about Germany you have Freedom of Choice to stay or go.
13:59 September 29, 2012 by auniquecorn
your right ATM, That is the one thing about Germany you have Freedom of Choice to stay or go.

But you don't have the freedom of choice to skip swim class...
14:33 September 29, 2012 by joysonabraham
ha ha ha..

this should serve as an eye opener to people who try to bringing religion into every sphere of life.

First thing to teach in schools

Religions are for us and we are not born for the religion.
16:43 September 29, 2012 by lordkorner
Burkini ha ha ha , its almost like an april fool article...
17:12 September 29, 2012 by bob searcy
i dont agree with this court ruling. what kind of free country would tell a person you have to wear this and you have to get in the water. i assure you i would not do something i didnt want to do. the young ladys individuality is being taken from her. she doesnt want to be like everyone else. the athourities should respect that..
17:18 September 29, 2012 by marimay
Religion aside, no one should be forced into a situation they are uncomfortable with. This is just a spiteful ruling.

Luckily we did not have such classes in my schools. I KNOW I would have felt the same way as her. I'm sure a lot of kids do.
17:25 September 29, 2012 by nemo999
to tell you the truth, I am rather uncomfortable being so close to bare-chested boys, on the other hand I do not seem to have an issue with bare-chested women, go figure.
18:58 September 29, 2012 by ovalle3.14
Unless this girl has some unmentioned issues, I think that the legal system of any country should not make it easy for you to be a quitter, but rather to face your fears and do something about them.

Oh, and, we're in Germany. The Koran is as legally binding here as, say, Asterix and the Vikings.
20:21 September 29, 2012 by Herr Rentz
Comment removed by The Local for breach of our terms.
20:32 September 29, 2012 by Jushe
Way to stand up for your culture Germany, good for you. Its your land your rules, they choose to move there.
22:40 September 29, 2012 by marimay
Why are you focusing on religion and culture? What does that have to do with forcing someone to do something they don't want to do? Do you honestly think she is the only one with this problem? Especially with all the image issues 12 yr old girls have these days?
04:04 September 30, 2012 by sonriete
The question to me is;

Why should anyone be forced to take swimming lessons in the first place?

I understand requiring children to take some sort of physical activities but why not have a menu?

After all, most other team sports are sex segregated for all children.
07:29 September 30, 2012 by kellyvanrijn
Well, if she doesn't want to swim next to bare chested boys, might I suggest moving back to whatever country she is from? Immigrants need to learn that it is their responsibility to assimilate into the country they are moving to, not the other way around.
09:05 September 30, 2012 by lordkorner
The reason that she must take swimming lessons is that in Germany it is part of the curriculum, its not something trivial like religion that you can just opt out of. You fall into deep water and you can't swim,you drown.
10:12 September 30, 2012 by StefanMuc
Seems reasonable. She is allowed to wear what she wants according to her religion, she is not allowed to tell other people what they should wear. And Germany is not required to accommodate every person's personal preferences in the curriculum.
20:07 September 30, 2012 by tercel
@ 17:12 September 29, 2012 by bob searcy

" she doesnt want to be like everyone else. the athourities should respect that.."

Yes, yes I totally agree. I don't like being poor like everyone else in my neighborhood, so the athourities should let me print my own money and respect that.

@ 17:18 September 29, 2012 by marimay

"no one should be forced into a situation they are uncomfortable with. This is just a spiteful ruling. "

How true, I am being forced into a situation I am uncomfortable with, being ¦quot;Sharia- compliant¦quot;, the EU authorities are just being spiteful.
20:44 September 30, 2012 by marimay
Oh, I see. Tercel is nuts.
21:21 September 30, 2012 by tercel
I see marimay has no idea what sarcasm is, so I'll give you the definition:

scar-casm

noun

the use of irony to mock or convey contempt
21:49 September 30, 2012 by Pakistani
u know am not a bit surprised that no one here regards the court's ruling as oppression. Would be nice to imagine what would the court and the civil society would have done if these girls happened to be jewish and if they had similar religious or cultural concerns. It would have been politically incorrect to give a pass out a decision like this.

You have to see that muslims are the new jews now a days. It is cool to push them down under. The "civilized world" sees it as a duty. Integration should be stressed upon BUT u have to see that east and west have totally opposite customs, cultural and religious values.... good and bad ones. Turks and arabs in germany should adopt the local customs but not at the cost of loosing their identity.... there are alot of germans living permanently in UAE and saudi arabia as professionals etc... du u ever see them wearing hijab and abstaining form alchohol?.... NO u wont see that.

The only reason why the west gets to impose it's values cos it is in the position to do so. if (God forbid) arabs controlled the world's economy, owned major media houses etc....... the conversation here would have been different.

lastly, I cant imagine what kind of delusions make people say things like "love it or leave it" ............. does it makes sense to bring foreigner unskilled labor into your country, have your way with them and afterwards when u dont need them tell them to 'k off. why weren't integration related concerns no an issue when germany was in need of man power........ why didn't you bring your beloved americans to work in your factories? what was so special with Achmet's illiterate family?
22:06 September 30, 2012 by jg.
For the record, when the Koran allows considerable leeway for Muslims when they are not in an Islamic country i.e. if they cannot find halal food or local law prevents them from dressing modestly, etc. Interestingly though, the Koran is very clear that Muslims should not settle in a Kaffir land.

So, if swimming lessons are mandatory, this young lady would not be in breach of her religion's rules - but she is in breach of them by choosing to live in Germany.
00:24 October 1, 2012 by marimay
Yes, I have no idea what sarcasm is.
02:11 October 1, 2012 by Wrinkled38
I completely agree with the ruling of the court - the family chose to settle in Germany, and whilst they should be free to practise their religion, they shouldn't be allowed to use it as an excuse to avoid doing something that their "holy book" doesn't even forbid until they're considered an adult.

This is not oppression - this is a family trying to use their religion to weasel their kid out of doing something, and being told clearly and decisively "forget it. You came here, you abide by our law - we don't abide by yours."
03:07 October 1, 2012 by Pakistani
"abide by the law"?????.............what if the law says that every western woman should wear burka?? like in Iran (where they are actually crazy)...........would you actually condone that kind of decision?.............. like I said ...living in a delusion
03:18 October 1, 2012 by marimay
You cant expect simple minds to see the big picture. A lot of people here would rather focus on the stories that make them feel good about hating other people while ignoring the issues that are harder to deal with, like their country falling apart thanks to their government's love affair with banks and taxes and china. Distract these simple minds and they can get away with anything. It is working in the US as well. Sad. Just wait til these courts start forcing you to do things you don't want to do as well. :) Oh wait, they already have.
04:05 October 1, 2012 by Wrinkled38
marimay - they already did that, and I took the only route out I could. I only moved to Germany a month ago, and despite being Catholic, I refuse to pay the church tax. I'll be damned if I'm going to pay for the right to go to church. So I wrote a letter to my priest, and I've renounced my membership of the church.

and Pakistani - if the law says, whatever the law says, I will condone it. That's what the law is there for. To be followed.
07:47 October 1, 2012 by Herr Ed
@ Pakistani- There's an old Linda Rondstadt song titled Poor Pitiful Me". You might want to check it out since it sounds like it might be a good theme song for you.

As far as the girl wanting to skip swim class...I've seen just almost as much skin walking down the streets on a hot day as she would see in swim class. I suppose she'll have to stay inside and have no contact with the outside world. Wait, that's the whole point, eh?
08:49 October 1, 2012 by tj_piela
I am very glad with the court's decision, there are plenty of countries in the world, where no one would ask this girl to have swimming lessons, they decided to come to Germany, so automatically they need to understand, that in the country there are certain rules, like in any country in the world. The same story is with non Muslims, who come to Islamic countries, they have to stick to the rules, otherwise they can be punished. Why Europe should be the good auntie and let everyone to do whatever they want...?
08:56 October 1, 2012 by sqwimpy
@marimay - The simpleton sounds like you. The point of immigration is integration, not segregation. I am surprised she was able to wear the barkini. The only people I see belly aching about their rights as immigrants is people of that faith.

Why can't you go back to your country? Oh ya, they didn't want them either.

@ Pakistani - I have to concur with Herr Ed. They need to get their kid to a muslim school so their rights are followed. We should not be conforming to your religion, you need to follow the law or find a country more conforming to your needs, like Sweden.
09:09 October 1, 2012 by renton66
wahhh. she's being oppressed in germany because she has to follow the rules.

meanwhile, back in saudi arabia...

'Ikea 'erases' women from Saudi catalogue'

http://www.thelocal.se/43540/20121001/
20:35 October 1, 2012 by sonriete
To me this is a crazy debate, people are saying the girl is trying to "weasel out" of taking an exercise class in school, huh? ... Obviously she is motivated in this case by deep convictions. She doesn't want to be exposed to boys naked chests. Can't we find a way to accommodate her modesty? Are we that small? For that matter, is Christianity, the dominant religion in Germany indigenous to this country? Or is it imported from the middle east, just like Islam? Just asking.....
02:35 October 2, 2012 by Pakistani
@sonriete : the world needs people like you ..........

@Wrinkled38 : not the answer for the question that I asked.... would women in your family adopt hijab if they were working within the UAE eg.... NO! cos u think your values are superior......

@Herr Ed : keep syaing that. you do know that your children would reap the fruit of your attitude towards muslims in germany..... muslims are here to stay........... being a smart ass, dont you think it is better to some to a mutual compromise........ (I know what you would say next.... plz dont)

@sqwimpy

..... I would oppose a "muslim" school in germany (in the sense that you implied it to be)....... you cannot have a "muslim" school here in germany...... mosques in germany are not allowed to even make the call for prayer.......... BUT in Pakistan (what u regard as u know what kind of coutnry) you DO hear church bells every where.......... unbeleiveable????????? must be........ u are suckerz to you your media........... live in your delusion.......... good bye peace.... lets call ourselves "arians", arabs and persians...........

do you think yours,mine and any other random immigrant 's children would co-exist peacefully............ or would be like arabs and jews ................. we should make a difference
05:20 October 2, 2012 by lewis69
Islam is an out dated religion full of odd customs, violent customs and customs that opress women I think we should limit out intake of these wacked out people into our countries.
23:54 October 2, 2012 by Pakistani
@ lewis69: islam is and christianity is not right?.................... I know an american/christian immigrant family here in frankfurt ............... the woman has 14 children......... unbelievable right? since people normally accuse muslims for that kind of fertility (:) ) and the will to actually use it.................... whatever gets said in this and similar forums is just CRAP!................. unless the balance of power shifts from the west to the east..... those "jihadi" lunatics have realized that and that is what they are striving to achieve ......................... I mean just for the sake of your own "kind"............. imagine

lastly. "your" countries will keep importing immigrants till they get self sufficient in "man"-power....................... row some marbles to admit that would you?
Today's headlines
Greece crisis
No Greece talks before referendum: Merkel
Pro-EU Greeks demonstrate outside the Athens parliament on Tuesday. Photo: DPA

No Greece talks before referendum: Merkel

Chancellor Angela Merkel said Tuesday that Germany won't enter into new aid negotiations with Athens before Greece's weekend referendum, after a last-minute request for an aid programme from Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras. READ  

Germanwings tragedy
Germany learns lessons on pilots’ mental health
Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt (left) and aviation safety task force leader Matthias von Randow. Photo: DPA:

Germany learns lessons on pilots’ mental health

In response to the Germanwings flight tragedy, Minister of Transport Alexander Dobrindt presented plans to strengthen mental health care for pilots while Germanwings announced further compensation for relatives of the flight's victims. READ  

Germany: land of cheap beer and drunkards?
Getting müllered? Football star Thomas Müller enjoys a Mass. Photo: DPA

Germany: land of cheap beer and drunkards?

It's official. If getting drunk on a park bench is your thing, look no further than Germany as an ideal location. A study released on Monday shows it's cheap. And you'll have plenty of company. READ  

Greece crisis
Schäuble: Greece will stay in Euro regardless
People demonstrate in favour of a 'no' vote in Greece's Sunday referendum on Monday night. Photo: DPA

Schäuble: Greece will stay in Euro regardless

UPDATE: Speaking to MPs from his Christian Democratic Union (CDU) on Tuesday, Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble said that Greece will stay in the eurozone even if the Greek public vote 'no' on July 5th. READ  

Fare-dodging fine jumps from €40 to €60
Photo: DPA.

Fare-dodging fine jumps from €40 to €60

Nationwide fines for people who ride public transit without a proper ticket will increase from €40 to €60 starting on Wednesday in some cities, the first time the penalty has been increased in 12 years. READ  

Far-right attacks on asylum homes soar
A sign reading "stop Nazis" hangs from a lamppost. Photo: DPA

Far-right attacks on asylum homes soar

The number of attacks on asylum seekers' accommodation by violent far-right groups in Germany is on course to double in 2015 after tripling between 2013 and 2014, the Interior Ministry said on Tuesday. READ  

How Germany will deal with the leap second
A scientist works with an atomic clock at the Federal Physics-Technology Institute (PTB) in Braunschweig. Photo: DPA

How Germany will deal with the leap second

Germany's top time scientists are ready to spring into action in the dead of night on Tuesday, inserting an extra second into the clock while everyone else is asleep. READ  

German unemployment hits historic low
Photo: DPA

German unemployment hits historic low

German unemployment remained at historically low levels in June as the recovery in Europe's biggest economy remained on track, data showed on Tuesday. READ  

Greece crisis
Germany's Greeks look anxiously homeward
Antonius Chantzaras in his kiosk. Photo: DPA

Germany's Greeks look anxiously homeward

As crisis engulfs their homeland, members of the Greek community in Germany look anxiously homeward and reflect on how the crisis is already traveling back to Germany. READ  

Women's World Cup
Semi-final clash with US 'like a final'
Germany coach Silvia Neid. Photo: DPA

Semi-final clash with US 'like a final'

Ahead of Tuesday's semi-final clash against the Unites States in the Women's World Cup, Germany coach Silvia Neid warned that her team would not be relinquishing their status as the world's number one team yet. READ  

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Society
An eye for an eye? Mum protects child in playground with pepperspray
Politics
Follow our LIVE blog as Europe holds breath over Greece crisis
National
As it happened: Queen Elizabeth's final day in Germany
National
As it happened: Queen Elizabeth's second day in Germany
National
Queen Elizabeth II's first day in Germany - as it happened
National
Bus passengers tell fake racists where to get off
Politics
What's really in the Queen's handbag?
National
Germans say USA doesn't respect freedom
National
Yes, you CAN buy adult e-books before 10pm in Germany
VIDEO: Watch a 93-metre turbine crash to earth in slow motion
Gallery
Who's got a shot at the German Film Awards
Rhineland
Anger over 'child-free' beer garden
National
How do you do, Majestät?
National
Man defends right to pee in public with tear gas
Features
The Germans who won Waterloo for the British
Frankfurt
Should Germany ban circus animals?
Hamburg
Where people are having the most sex in Germany
Culture
Who Wants to be a Millionaire? Not this student...
National
Dresden's three-decade-long red light
Politics
Upper house calls for gay marriage now
Berlin
Berlin named 3rd-best city worldwide
Sport
In search of the toughest firefighter
Business & Money
German firms shine for European engineering students
Gallery
Hitler's paintings up for auction
National
German's 70-year search for murdered US pilot
Politics
What the G7 leaders agreed at Elmau
Business & Money
What really makes Germans happy
National
Playmobil builder leaves worldwide legacy
National
The car share that became a drug run
Politics
What Snowden revealed to Germany
Rhineland
Why wolf cubs are being raised by hand
National
Hitler's booze cave found
National
Environment makes Germany worth living in
Culture
What's top of the charts in June
Gallery
Germany's most beautiful cycle routes
Business & Money
The business case for Britain in the EU
Rhineland
Why farmers are free to pong up the countryside
National
German restaurants among world's best
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

6,736
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd