• Germany edition
 
Court lifts ban on domestic military ops
Photo: DPA

Court lifts ban on domestic military ops

Published: 17 Aug 2012 11:24 GMT+02:00
Updated: 17 Aug 2012 17:53 GMT+02:00

The strict ban on German military operations within the country was adopted following World War II, in reaction to the Nazi regime having used the army and paramilitary forces for its domestic agenda.

On Friday, the Federal Constitutional Court said the Bundeswehr armed forces could deploy under strict conditions in case of an assault in Germany with the potential for scores of casualties.

The deployment of troops in Germany was only acceptable in "states of emergency of catastrophic proportions," the judges ruled, but never "in reaction to the threat posed by demonstrating crowds".

The use of combat weapons was only acceptable "as a last resort" and must be approved by the federal government, not simply delegated to the defence minister.

Shooting down a hijacked passenger plane with civilians on board remained illegal after the ruling - but fighter jets could attempt to force such an aircraft to land with warning shots.

The ruling marked a reversal of a decision by the same court in 2006 and was a response to complaints from two of Germany's 16 federal states.

The German government had attempted to allow more flexibility in its military response to a possible terror attack in the wake of the September 11, 2001 suicide hijackings in the United States.

But it ran into resistance from the court, which cited strict restrictions on the deployment of the military in Germany set down in the post-war constitution.

Fears also ran deep that the armed forces could be used as an instrument of political power.

The decision effectively broadens Article 35 of the constitution which only permits a domestic military deployment in case of a natural disaster or a particularly serious accident.

Defence Minister Thomas de Maiziere and Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrich welcomed the decision in a joint statement.

"Ensuring the security of our citizens, particularly in extreme cases, is one of the most important duties of our state," they said.

The ruling "fills a legal void", added defence affairs expert Ernst-Reinhard Beck of the ruling conservative Christian Union parties' parliamentary group.

However Justice Minister Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberg stressed the importance of the "separation between internal and external security" and noted that "not everything that is constitutionally possible is politically right".

The opposition Social Democrats welcomed the "last resort" restrictions imposed by the court, home affairs expert Michael Hartmann said.

But the far-left party Linke warned that the decision "opens the door to a further militarisation of home affairs and hollows out democratic rights".

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Reinhard Gaier said the court had gone beyond its powers, and that the government should seek an amendment to the constitution if it aimed to deploy the military on German soil.

AFP/The Local/hc

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

12:16 August 17, 2012 by elboertjie
Following the USA's lead: using the military to combat its own citizens and to trample even more on people's liberties.

One small step at a time, the complete tyranny is approaching.
13:00 August 17, 2012 by pepsionice
You could go and waste another ten billion Euro a year on a separate domestic unit if you wanted to....or just use the standing military. You already use them for flood relief (remember, they filled sandbags by the millions when tasked). I don't see a big deal.....it's not like you have the leadership of the Chinese Army running running the German military.
13:10 August 17, 2012 by Berlin fuer alles
Agreed elboertjie. Our world leadership are finding ways to restrict freedoms of it's citizens and all in the name of this unknown terror that cannot be seen or ever defreated. A beautiful scenario for eroding freedoms whenever the need or want arises. Having read the rise and fall of the third reich I can liken this to another scenario that happened in the first half of the last century.
14:22 August 17, 2012 by nemo999
27/2/1933 22:15 hrs followed by the search for the usual suspects and the issuance of the new rules (AKA the new Reichstag Fire Decree), and we will be off to the races.
14:57 August 17, 2012 by tdog1964
Sometimes we need to give up a little freedoms so we can have a freeer more secure society.
15:06 August 17, 2012 by iseedaftpeople
this indeed opens the floodgates to an accelerated rollback on civil liberties.

How fearful must Germany's political elite be of their own people, if they see the need to press for the use of military force against them.

It would be harrowingly naive to think that this decision will have no consequences and is merely a technicality. Remember how following the Bundesverfassungsgericht's ban on indiscriminate data retention, politicians of all parties never ceased to stress the importance of reintroducing it; and often enough, they touted it precisely as a remedy for petty crimes that fell outside the intentionally narrow scope of what the court saw as reconcilable with Germany's constitution.

And the same is going to happen with domestic military operations - directly ignoring even the scope this appallingly lenient decision by the Bundesverfassungsgericht, "law and order" politicians from all parties will call for routine deployment of troops for crowd control at ordinary political rallies, perhaps even plain old football riots. And you can bet your behind that the next time there is going to be a Castor container delivery of radioactive waste to the Wendland, demonstrators will be up against the Bundeswehr.

What we are witnessing here is the early stages of neo-conservativism (which Angela Merkel and the German political elite have adopted from the U.S. hook line and sinker) turning into neo-fascism. Mark my words, and remember them when you start seeing tanks and troops wielding machine guns at political rallies.
17:09 August 17, 2012 by Major B
@ elboertjie,

U.S. domestic law does not allow its active military to intervene in domestic affairs. We do have a national guard that is authorized to in civil defense only if an emergency is declared. Hurricane Katrina and in riots in the past are situations in which our state governors have relied on their guard forces. But, the Americans are traditionally and historically a non-militaristic nation and would never have tolerated what took place in Germany during the 1930's.

But otherwise, we are blessed to have a large peaceful country, despite our political differences, in which one can travel for thousands of miles under the same set of laws.

Of course many German citizens know this and thousands travel to the USA each year and enjoy the vast variety of activities our great and rich land offers.
17:33 August 17, 2012 by frankiep
"But, the Americans are traditionally and historically a non-militaristic nation and would never have tolerated what took place in Germany during the 1930's."

I'm sorry, but you cannot be serious.

The US has existed since 1776 and has fought in the following wars:

War of Independence

War of 1812

Barbary War

Mexican-American War

Civil War

Spanish-American War

World War I

World War II

Korean War

Vietnam War

Gulf War

Afghanistan

Iraq War

These are just the "major" military conflicts the US has been involved in.

Not to mention the countless wars against Native American tribes and military incursions in Panama, Grenada, and the Phillipines - amongst many others. All in a span of just under 240 years.

Barring all of that, I don't know how anyone can say that a country which spends more on it's military than the next 26 countries in the world COMBINED is not militaristic.
00:33 August 18, 2012 by Leo Strauss
As the Flecktarn turns to Eichentarn...

Wie schön ist Deutschland im Herbst. ;)
21:32 August 18, 2012 by DickShawnsDiction
"Barring all of that, I don't know how anyone can say that a country which spends more on it's military than the next 26 countries in the world COMBINED is not militaristic."

Easy: brainwashing. Topnotch brainwashing. The only thing the US is good at any more.

But back to the dismal topic at hand: I miss "Old Europe". Come back, Gerhard! All is forgiven...!
14:23 August 19, 2012 by A pen
Poster #1 nailed it. The rest of you complaining about the US better educate yourselves before spouting off. It takes two sides to start a war. Pick one. That's right, if you believed your militaristic rants you'd be living under a totalitarian government like N Korea and be happy. Read the Federalist Papers some time. You'll find the price of liberty is suffering the cycle of tyrants and patriots as education for the next generation. That the unchangeable laws of nature prevent man from being stripped of his right to use any means to put tyranny back in a book is the key. Samuel Adams had it right, education and virtue prevent subjugation.
17:10 August 21, 2012 by Major B
@ frankiep

I stand by my comment that Americans(the American People) are non-militaristic. Before you go off citing history again, just know from my heritage, I know very well what American governments, led by big business, have done in the past. I say this with the full knowledge of our constitution's guarantee of gun ownership and self-protection.

And I know very well some of the sorry episodes of native suppression and slavery. I didn't say Americans were aggressive.

But don't start anything. Why would you count the War of Independence and the War of 1812 in the above list? So the Americans went over and burned London in 1812? Right. Why would you count the Civil War? That was internal as well. Americans tried hard to stay out of the two world wars you listed. While I believe England and France were equally responsible for the first world war....... I won't complete the sentence.

And the Korean War(Cold War) and Vietnam(Cold War) were a consequence of the the second world war.

Just think, had that little man from Austria been suppressed by his own countrymen in 1933, people like you wouldn't have to continually complain about U.S. military dominance all these years.
Today's headlines
The Local List
Which high school cliche is your city?
Photo: DPA/Shutterstock

Which high school cliche is your city?

This week's Local List takes a leap of imagination and finds German cities fit perfectly into high school cliche categories. Who's the class clown? Who's the nerd? READ  

'German' hand grenades paraded by Isis in Syria
A screen grab from a jihadist video showing the grenades. Photo: DPA

'German' hand grenades paraded by Isis in Syria

The German military was on Wednesday investigating reports that Bundeswehr hand grenades have fallen into the hands of the Islamic State (Isis) terrorist group after a video appearing to show captured weapons surfaced on the Internet. READ  

North braces for storms and floods
Early signs of flooding at the Hamburg fish market on Wednesday morning.

North braces for storms and floods

The remnants of hurricane Gonzalo have drifted across the Atlantic and are now threatening North German cities with flooding, forecasters warned on Wednesday. READ  

Indian schools drop German teaching
Indian pupils enrolled in German classes prepare for Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier's visit to their school. Photo: DPA

Indian schools drop German teaching

Thousands of children in India will no longer be taught German after the country's education ministry allowed a contract to lapse. READ  

Syria-bound US teens stopped in Frankfurt
A passenger plane landing at Frankfurt airport. Photo: DPA

Syria-bound US teens stopped in Frankfurt

Three teenage girls from Colorado were arrested by German police at Frankfurt airport after running away from home, reportedly on their way to join Isis in Syria. READ  

Tourists stranded on cable car over Rhine
Tuesday night's rescue operation Photo: DPA

Tourists stranded on cable car over Rhine

Six people, including a family and two American tourists, were left dangling 40 metres in the air over the Rhine for hours late on Tuesday after Cologne's cable car came to a halt. READ  

7:1! Bayern celebrate record in Rome
Arjen Robben celebrates the first goal against AS Roma. Photo: DPA

7:1! Bayern celebrate record in Rome

Bayern Munich were elated on Tuesday night after securing a 7-1 victory against Roma in their group stage Champions League clash. READ  

Nazi U-boat wreck found off US coast
A preserved World War II U-Boat on the beach near Kiel, Germany. Photo: DPA

Nazi U-boat wreck found off US coast

A World War II German U-boat and an American merchant vessel it sank in battle have been found deep in the ocean off the coast of North Carolina, officials said on Tuesday. READ  

Fourth time lucky for free Berlin WiFi?
Coming soon? Photo: DPA

Fourth time lucky for free Berlin WiFi?

Berlin's bid to set up a free city-wide wireless network has so far come to nothing. But city bosses are now trying for a fourth time - and hope to have the project running next year. READ  

Opinion
Do German unions have too much power?
Lufthansa passengers rush to change their flights at Frankfurt Airport on Monday. Photo: DPA

Do German unions have too much power?

Germany's pilots and train drivers are taking it in turns to bring the country to a standstill with strikes that have cost the economy tens of millions of euros in the last two weeks. Are unions abusing their power or standing up for their rights? READ  

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Sponsored Article
An international school unlike any other : School on the Rhine
Photo: Fitzpatrick family
Society
'We still don't know what happened to Matthew'
Photo: Mariana Schroeder
Munich
Special Report: Hope and chaos at Munich's refugee shelters
Photo: DPA
Berlin
Robbers blow up Berlin bank
Photo: DPA
Culture
Can you top our history quiz leaderboard?
Photo: Facebook
Society
German motorcycle gang joins Isis fight
Photo: DPA
Politics
UKIP ‘seeks EU pact’ with German satirical party
Photo: DPA
Gallery
PHOTOS: World's biggest erotic fair opens in Berlin
Photo: DPA/Shutterstock
Gallery
11 things Germans are afraid of...
Photo: DPA
Gallery
The ten richest people in Germany
Photo: DPA
Business & Money
JobTalk: All you need to know about working in Germany
National
Share news tips with The Local Germany
Sponsored Article
Bilingual education from nursery to graduation at Phorms
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

3,490
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd