• Germany's news in English
 

School allowed to ban Muslim pupil's praying

The Local · 30 Nov 2011, 17:18

Published: 30 Nov 2011 17:18 GMT+01:00

However, the Leipzig-based federal administrative court found that the right to pray even at school was guaranteed by religious freedom under the constitution.

In the case of the 18-year-old pupil, who took his school to court, it justified the ban at his Berlin high school because the issue of praying had already sparked conflict among Muslim pupils.

The court said the school, in Berlin's ethnically diverse Wedding district, was right in stopping him from praying as "sometimes very severe conflicts" had broken out among Muslim pupils over the interpretation of the Koran.

Capping a more than two-year legal battle, it ruled that a pupil "is not entitled to perform prayer during school outside of class when this can disrupt the running of the school."

The pupil, identified only as Yunus M., is the son of a German Muslim convert. He had insisted on his basic right to religious freedom after the school principal told him praying at school was not permitted.

With an estimated four million Muslims living in Germany, the case sparked interest after two earlier regional court rulings first found in favour of the boy, only then to be overturned.

It began in November 2007 when Yunus M. and several other pupils laid down their jackets in the school corridor to pray during a break from class.

The following day the principal informed the boy and his parents that praying was not permitted on the grounds of the school which has students of about 30 different nationalities and nearly all major religions. She feared for the peaceful running of the school, she said.

Yunus M. had argued that because prayer times depend on the rising and setting of the sun, he had no other choice during the winter but to pray around midday while at school.

News weekly Der Spiegel said that the consequences of Wednesday's ruling

would be closely watched nationwide.

"Yunus M. kicked off proceedings which could write legal history," it said in its online edition.

Tilman Nagel, an expert in Islam who appeared as a witness at an earlier court hearing, said that postponing midday prayers was acceptable if there was a good reason.

He also argued that the Islamic ritual of praying undertaken with other people was very different to the Christian private act of praying, and was thus disruptive in a public space.

Germany has grappled with the thorny issue of the integration of its Muslim population since it signed a "guest worker" pact with Turkey 50 years ago.

This has sometimes fuelled tensions, with a former central banker publishing a runaway bestseller last year saying Germany was being made "more stupid" by millions of purportedly undereducated and unproductive Muslim migrants.

AFP/mry

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

19:40 November 30, 2011 by brnskin2010
Comment removed by The Local for breach of our terms.
20:11 November 30, 2011 by Simon_Kellett
Is this a "public school" as in a school open to the general public for free, or "public school" in British sense: i.e a private, fee paying school?
20:23 November 30, 2011 by nolibs
Comment removed by The Local for breach of our terms.
22:29 November 30, 2011 by marimay
Haha, nolibs is scared. What a fool.
04:39 December 1, 2011 by ChrisRea
Disruptive? If the school bully does not like the colour, probably wearing purple is also disruptive, isn't it?

@nolibs - Did you take a look at the history between Catholics and Protestants in Ireland? Then I guess you are also scared by those who chose to become Christians (don't worry too much though, there are not so many compared to those who are born into Christianity and have no idea about it).

If in the last sentence you were referring to the original ruling of the court, then I am with you on this one.
04:45 December 1, 2011 by Nemo2010
Comment removed by The Local for breach of our terms.
08:53 December 1, 2011 by GregAbdul
First, I would say the story is biased, It cites an "expert" saying that Muslims don't have to pray at a specific time? Now who doesn't know that Muslims are commanded to pray a midday prayer and to miss it is a sin. It's like saying you can murder....if you have a good excuse. Muslims are in every country in the world. A lot of you have a lot of growing up to do. We are not going to go back to anywhere and especially not to please you. You have to live with us, just as we have to live with you. We all need to be adults. The writer of this article is not being an adult because this article is biased and not balanced. The simple solution for all in this case is to simply assign the kids a room to pray in during lunch hour. Then they will be out of sight and still meeting their religious obligation, which actually does encourage them to be as private and out of the way as they can in making their prayers. The problem is them praying in the halls and that only happens because someone for some silly reason is not giving them a private prayer space.
09:23 December 1, 2011 by ChrisRea
@Nemo2010

Most probably the Muslim in case is already in his homeland, namely Germany. I am glad that you realise that the Western world is still a "boy's club" and women are not treated as equals. And yes, it is sad that followers of main religions (Christian, Muslim etc) kill each other in the name of their beliefs.
09:28 December 1, 2011 by asteriks
Politicians mixed themselves 100%, therefore later ruling by the court was against this boy. School principal should loose job because of racism. And check that principal if he/she grew up in Nazi family.
10:48 December 1, 2011 by DULS
Honestly this couldn¦#39;t get better; education system should be maintained free of any religion reference. Germany is no longer a Christian and it is not Islamic republic as we should move on and start looking at religion as a private issue.

If these kids want to pray, they can do it at home (sorry @GregAbdul) and I don't see a reason why the school have any obligation whatsoever to give them a room. Islam is another religion out there and should be treated as equal as the many others, I don't see Christian, Buddhist, Jews, scientologies and who knows what else, demanding a room or performing their religious ritual on public spaces.
13:07 December 1, 2011 by psykos
well guys its very simple, this praying thing would never bother anyone, infact it never actually bothered, if it was pre 9/11 era. Its just Islamphobia nothing else. And in future if US+NATO gets bored of fighting against same enemy and creates a new one, praying+etc will be again no problem

@DULS So you want to make Germany like Stalin's USSR or China?
13:11 December 1, 2011 by bugger
Public schools are not the place for public prayer. They are schools and not churches.

Try to publicly pray if you are a Christian in a public school in Turkey or in Saudi Arabia LOL
13:27 December 1, 2011 by storymann
bugger you also could add America to your list.
22:16 December 1, 2011 by Redwing
@ Simon_Kellet. As nobody has so far answered your question, let me. Public schools in Germany are just the ordinary non-fee-paying schools. There are very few private (or public as in the UK) schools. I don't know about now, but in my day it was considered a shame having to go to a private school because it meant that you were either so badly behaved that you were chucked out of school or you were a dunce and could not keep up with the school's curriculum.
02:02 December 2, 2011 by Neanderthal75
Comment removed by The Local for breach of our terms.
10:39 December 2, 2011 by DULS
@psykos, I would like Germany to become a real secular state, where religion is a private issue, I know that is naive but the court decision was in the right direction.

Some women like to get spank others like to wear a burka, but who are we to decided for them.

everything else, it is part of the same bla bla bla.
02:14 December 3, 2011 by ron1amr
Well spoken Neanderthal 75. I agree with the school as the praying could disrupt the school. If the boy had to do his prayers on a certain time, then he with his parents should have made consultations with the school in advance. Or either he should take leave from school in these times.
21:51 December 3, 2011 by viperella
No one shall obstruct hallways: it's a safety issue. Praying or not, there must be clear access to exits. Simple.
12:04 December 6, 2011 by nolibs
@psykos - really, you think nobody would be bothered by a group of muslims clogging up the hallways, chanting and praying, if not for the muslim terrorist attacks on 9/11 and 7/7? The student(s) could easily bow their heads in the direction of their holy space rock and pray silently. Rather, this is purely an attempt to disrupt the school, with the added effect of making it harder to be Christian as well (Germany IS a Christian country).
Today's headlines
Whiff of foul play in Cologne mayoral election
An electoral poster next to Cologne Cathedral. Photo: DPA

Whiff of foul play in Cologne mayoral election

11 hours ago

Did the Social Democratic Party (SPD) deliberately skew voting slips in Cologne's mayoral elections to hand their candidate an advantage?

Refugee crisis
Five ways you can help refugees in Germany
Woman bring clothing donations to a German Red Cross station in Heidenau, scene of anti-refugee demonstrations last weekend. Photo: DPA

Five ways you can help refugees in Germany

9 hours ago

The Local's pointers for how to get started if you're interested in donating your money, unwanted possessions, time or skills to help refugees in Germany.

FC Bayern takes refugee kids under its wing
Players will walk into the Allianz Arena hand-in-hand with young refugees on September 12th. Photo: DPA

FC Bayern takes refugee kids under its wing

8 hours ago

FC Bayern Munich said on Thursday that it would help young refugees learn German and play football and donate €1m of the proceeds from an upcoming friendly match.

Berlin hotel extends beds for basketball giants
Dirk Nowitzki (r) - too tall for a normal hotel bed. Photo: DPA

Berlin hotel extends beds for basketball giants

8 hours ago

The Berlin hotel hosting the international basketball teams playing in the 2015 European championships matches here have extended their beds to 2.50 metres in order to accomodate the giant players.

Migrant crisis
Hungary says refugees are 'German problem'
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban (l) and refugees boarding a train at Budapest's Keleti station. Photos: DPA

Hungary says refugees are 'German problem'

12 hours ago

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban insisted Thursday the migrant crisis was a German problem, not a European one as he defended his government's handling of thousands of refugees flooding into his country.

Banks jack up ATM fees for non-customers
Photo: DPA

Banks jack up ATM fees for non-customers

13 hours ago

Germany's big private banks are increasing fees for customers at other financial institutions to withdraw cash from their ATMs, making ordinary people pay the price for a bankers' spat.

Berlin mayor christens brand-new U-Bahn trains
Berlin Mayor Michael Müller smashes a bottle of Berliner Weisse beer against the metal skin of a new U-Bahn train to christen it. Photo: DPA

Berlin mayor christens brand-new U-Bahn trains

15 hours ago

The first of an all-new model of Berlin U-Bahn trains was christened on Wednesday evening by city mayor Michael Müller in a typically Berlin ceremony.

Migrant crisis
Biggest EU nations want refugees shared fairly
A man leads migrants in a chant in front of police lines at Budapest's Keleti railway station on Tuesday. Photo: DPA

Biggest EU nations want refugees shared fairly

15 hours ago

Germany, France and Italy called for an overhaul of laws on the right of asylum and a fairer distribution of migrants throughout the European Union, Italy's foreign minister said on Wednesday.

The Local List
7 ways Germans get English totally wrong
Don't let their confidence fool you: Germans aren't always the best at English. Photo: DPA.

7 ways Germans get English totally wrong

1 day ago

As much as English-speakers might feel insecure about their Deutsch skills when faced with Germans' comparatively widespread grasp of English, Germans themselves often mess up English - in some pretty hilarious ways.

Mannschaft step forward to welcome refugees
Germany captain Bastian Schweinsteiger at a press conference earlier this week. Photo: DPA

Mannschaft step forward to welcome refugees

1 day ago

Germany's World Cup-winning footballers have condemned xenophobic attacks on the thousands of foreigners pouring into their country and led calls to help the refugees amidst the ongoing crisis.

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS

Features
'Berlin is kind of like the best American city'
Features
How Brits in Germany are facing Brexit fears
Sport
German named 'arse bombing' world champ
Travel
Retiree finds parked car after three-week search
National
Ten ways Germany puts Britain to shame
Business & Money
German gadget clamps down on Nutella thieves
Society
Is Germany now a nation of couch potatoes?
National
Half of Germans 'have had sex in their car'
Society
Deadly stew spooks home vegetable gardeners
Politics
The man who brought two Germanies together
Features
Where to get your culture fix in Cologne
Education
Fairytale world of Brothers Grimm brought to life
Rhineland
Thieves leave 1,000 open beers untasted
National
Way to some Germans' hearts is through their wallets
National
Germany's biggest challenge: European refugee crisis
Travel
Where to get your adrenaline pumping in Germany
Technology
Could thieves hack into luxury cars?
What to watch out for when snapping your lunch
National
German lefties through history
National
The fight over prostitution heats up
National
Merkel: migrants, not Greece, are the real challenge
Features
How I explained the Queen to the Germans
Education
Why Germany does 'back-to-school' traditions better
National
Germans are ‘not how foreigners think’
National
A mum and daughter reunite 70 years after WWII
Sport
Bra stops bullet in hunting mishap miracle
National
Cows trample German woman to death in Graubünden Alps
Business & Money
Start-up helps new Berliners short cut bureaucracy
National
The 1,000s of Germans massacred after the Second World War
Sport
Germany star scores own goal with PR gaffe
Features
'Women-only' parking: sensible or sexist?
Politics
Satire and reality blur in parody party's strife
National
13-year-old boy detained for trying to join Isis
Culture
Berlin restaurant serves up Greek Crisis Menu
Rhineland
Doctor on trial after woman wakes in morgue
Society
Six odd things Germans do in the summer
Society
Police bust kinky Bavarian couple over painful love-making
Politics
Merkel brings Palestinian girl to tears
Hamburg
Amateur archaeologist finds Nazi gold hoard
National
Could Merkel learn a lesson in love from this doppelganger?
Travel
Why you should stay in Germany for the summer holidays
Sport
German press tell Schweinsteiger 'good riddance'
National
Hamburg gets a bouncing 100kg baby girl
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

6,888
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd