• Germany's news in English
 

Erdogan criticizes German attitude to Turks

The Local · 2 Nov 2011, 14:01

Published: 02 Nov 2011 08:45 GMT+01:00
Updated: 02 Nov 2011 14:01 GMT+01:00

Erdogan's ceremonial trip to Germany has been free of friction so far. He was given an official reception at the palace of German President Christian Wulff on Tuesday evening, and he will met Chancellor Angela Merkel at an event on Wednesday.

Merkel praised the first Turks who came to support West Germany's booming economy five decades ago. "That was a courageous step," she said, adding that successful integration of immigrants was a "joint achievement" of both Turks and Germans.

"Living together is always a give and take," she said.

But Erdogan's remarks in the run-up to his visit were less harmonious.

“German politicians do not acknowledge the contribution of the three million Turks in Germany enough,” he told the mass circulation Bild newspaper. He said there were 72,000 Turkish employers in Germany who provide 350,000 jobs.

“The guest workers of yesterday are slowly becoming the employers, academics, artists,” the Turkish head of government said.

Erdogan also criticized the insistence on learning German as a condition of living in Germany. He said this was unsupported in the relevant EU guidelines. "Making knowledge of German an important condition is against human rights," he said.

Erdogan’s remarks have drawn a harsh response from German politicians. Green party spokesman Memet Kilic accused the Turkish prime minister of playing up to conservatives at home.

“The Turkish government of Prime Minister Erdogan consciously stokes up prejudices against Germany, in order to score points with hardliners in their own country,” he told the Neue Osnabrücker Zeitung on Wednesday.

Kilic also slammed Erdogan for accusing German NGOs working in Turkey of providing indirect financial support to the Kurdish separatist group PKK. “Erdogan should apologize in Germany for his statements,” he said.

German Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrich admitted Germany had made mistakes in its integration policy in the past 50 years. “Unfortunately we allowed them to live together in districts in which they don’t have, or don’t want to have, contact to Germans,” he told broadcaster ZDF on Wednesday.

But Friedrich also reiterated the government’s opposition to granting dual citizenship. He said if immigrants want to stay in Germany, they should become German citizens. “And then they’re not Turks anymore,” he said.

The intractable issue of Turkey's accession to the European Union is also a focus of this trip.

Erdogan said that Turks still regard the German people “with very positive feelings.” For that reason, he called on Germany to show more solidarity with Turkey. “German politicians should do much more to help Turkey enter the EU. That would drive integration forward a lot,” he said. “We feel like we’re being let down here.”

Turkey’s booming economy – currently reporting growth of ten percent – means that it is becoming less and less dependent on German imports.

A recent statement by Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle suggests the scale of the concern for industry in this country. “We have to open the door to Europe very wide for Turkey, instead of constantly putting up new obstacles until one day Turkey turns away.”

DAPD/The Local/bk

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

10:03 November 2, 2011 by Kurd_007
Mr Erdogan may have a point, but for his argument to be credible his government should first recognise the universal rights of Kurdish and other minorities who lived in north mesopotamia and anatolia long before Turks arrival from central asia.

there may be racism in germany as in anywhere else in the world, but from our experience as Kurds..despite Turkey's pressure, Germany is much more respective of our cultural rights than our native country Turkey.
10:24 November 2, 2011 by TheCrownPrince
Erdogan has no point at all. Saying that the demand for turks in Germany to speak proper German is violating human rights is ridiculous. They decided to live here, so let them learn the language. I would like to know what Erdogan said if 3 million "Germans" (or people of german descent) lived in Turkey without knowing (or hardly speaking) Turkish; or what he said if every two years or so the German President flew over to Turkey making big speeches telling those "Germans" please not to integrate too much in turkish society, after all they were still "Germans", not Turks! Erdogan would be very amused, I bet.

If he cares so much about the wellbeing of the Turks in Germany maybe he can take some of them home with him to care even more. Speaking of human rights, Erdogan is one of the last to open his mouth, regarding the situation of the Kurds, the genocide of the Armenians, the situation of Christians in Turkey etc. I'm so tired of this muscle-playing, hopefully Merkel gives him a cold shoulder.
11:14 November 2, 2011 by LecteurX
This Erdogan bloke is really ridiculous. Since when is learning a new language a "violation of human rights"? It's very sad that for reasons of realpolitik, no European politician can stand up to him and give him a middle-finger answer, which he has deserved for a while now.
11:58 November 2, 2011 by Germanium
I must tell you that, of course, Turkish people must learn German if they live here, like Kurdish people must learn Turkish who lives in Turkey.

But for sure, people do not have to use it if it is something in their personal life. I mean, nobody can tell people "if you are in Germany, you must speak to people (friends etc.) in German in your private life." (like Kurdish people in Turkey). This is clear. If you are in a government office in any country, you are expected to speak the native language.

The things which are told in previous comments are pointless and will only serve mess and fascism.

Also, in that news, to tell truth, I could not see anything which is related to "genocide!" (which EU people like most to talk about in every matter). This is really funny.
12:09 November 2, 2011 by storymann
I do not believe Erdogan thinks for one nano second Turkey will ever enter the EU.

He has moved his government towards the east and an Islamic republic.

I would think he is more inclined to think in terms of a future Arabic coalition.

Remarks that people of other descents asking for citizenship, should not be required to learn the host countries language is obtuse.

Belgium is a good example of in house language problems.
12:54 November 2, 2011 by Joseph Thomas
I visit friends in Germany for a week or two each year, and I've been studying and learning to speak German for several years........just to be a better part of the society for that annual visit. It certainly would be one of my highest priorities to learn any language if I lived there year round. I can't imagine otherwise, unless I was elderly or cognitively impaired.
13:40 November 2, 2011 by SchwabHallRocks
Whether it's Erdogran complaining about the treatment of Turks in Germany, or the President of Mexico complaining about the treatment of Mexicans in the USA, it's all due to the same problem.

"Native" Germans, Americans, French, Japanese, etc. are not reproducing enough to maintain the population "pyramid" needed to support domestic economic growth or the welfare / pension plans.

These countries (Germany, USA, France) truly need these people (Turks, Mexican).

So, either "get busy" and start having more children or just accept that they (Turkey, Mexico) are going to be complaining more, and more, and more, since they are essential to the survival of the economic systems of the industrialized countries. Or... invent a new economic system.

But, "getting busy" would be a lot more fun.
15:55 November 2, 2011 by finanzdoktor
Herr Prezident Erdogran should get his facts correct. If I, a non-Turk (and also a non-European) want to be employed in the German private sector, I must be certified to have obtained a certain level of understanding the German language. Now, if this is the same for myself and everyone else, why shouldn't it be the same for others?????
16:03 November 2, 2011 by Sastry.M
In my opinion, attrition of population in the so called highly advanced countries, is due to the spirit of their people tied up to profitable financial management of living rather than bear the responsibility procreative sustenance of human life as willed by Providence. For example, pornographic industry may generate more finances to live comfortably by couples than procreated offspring, creating burden on both family and government, implying many responsibilities.

Muslims in India, although generally poor financially, breed large families and somehow survive amicably. They answer any question to mean that God's Grace cannot be abridged with ephemeral wishes of human beings, by simply saying, it is all "Allah ki Dua" or the 'Grace of God'. Probably it serves no purpose blaming contracted guest workers with imbued contentment.
16:06 November 2, 2011 by catjones
The article implies that when Turks were lured to DL as guest workers, there was no language requirement; probably because of the 'temporary' (aka stupid) expectation of their stay. To post facto make language a requirement may be the reference.
18:10 November 2, 2011 by ovalle3.14
"Making knowledge of German an important condition is against human rights," - Funny comment from the leader of a country that requires you to change your name to a Turkish one in order to gain citizenship.
18:39 November 2, 2011 by koll
@kurd-007

Majority of Turkey's kurdish population came from iran at 16. century long after Turks came to Anatolia at 11. century.And southeast anatolian kurds accepted ottoman hegemony with free will for protection against the iran.
21:32 November 2, 2011 by zubuque
"Making knowledge of German an important condition is against human rights,"...

This is a distorted news. He made this comment about the proof of basic German requirement for family reunification visa. This is a common belief that it is a violation of constitutional protection of family. What he meant was that this procedure violates German constitution and European laws.

It is very simple to distort a news...but it is very hard to understand a comment if you don't want to really understand it..

Finally, take a look at this case : http://www.lg2g.info/Foreigners-Law_Articles-on-Residency/proof-of-german-knowledge-when-immigrating-to-a-german.html
22:02 November 2, 2011 by Englishted
The more he speaks the less chance of Turkey getting into Europe so it is not all bad
23:43 November 2, 2011 by hanskarl
"The more he speaks the less chance of Turkey getting into Europe so it is not all bad ." Well, true but he could take all of the Turkish immigrants and Turkish Germans back to Turkey and then he create his own "little European Union."
00:22 November 3, 2011 by hardrada
As being a Turk, I have never imagined myself defending PM Erdogan one day but I think some of you here really need to get educated: As the only informed commentator under this article, namely, zubuque points out (I think the rest of the most of the commentators here are quite biased and as in the case of hanskari and some others indeed quite racist, too), Erdogan's objection to learning German as a condition is as to the German law that you cannot marry a non-German and live together in Germany as your spouse does not speak German; yes, in the most ideal world you would expect every resident of the country to speak its major language but come on, just think about it! Can you imagine the US passing a law about the Mexican immigrants in the US, which prohibits to have your spouse from Mexico if he/she does not speak English? Would you really keep a straight face and naturally expect someone's wife to learn German then get married before arriving in the country? The German state tells you whom to marry and then you can claim that there is no violation of human rights in that? The very same Erdogan just two days ago called on the Turkish immigrants to learn German as good as they can and contribute to the society in the best way they do (I guess, The Local simply puts this aside as it is not in harmony with its own agenda - what is easier in journalism than defaming Turks in the country, right?) and a month ago when President Gül visited Germany, he actually again called on the Turkish immigrants to learn and speak German without an accent (which is quite stupid if you really think about it). Yeah, Turks are not übermensch unlike Germans but at least you can try not to distort the news and take someone's speech into quite different directions if you are a journalist on one hand (especially if you dare to report from Bild) and you can first verify through a more objective website and then bash on Turkey and Turkish people if you would like to comment on the other hand.
02:30 November 3, 2011 by hanskarl
Nothing racist intended. Merely a response after reading the article. But if one wants to discuss diversity and the feel good mentality inculcated in its presentation, that is a different story.

Prime Minister Erdogans remarks prior to the visit while appeasing the conservatives back home could possibly bolster and incite the intentions of others with a nationalistic passion. It doesn't take much research to realize there are vast differences culturally between Europe and Turkey let along between each individual EU country. And a cursory review of history tells us much. Germany is Germany and when one commits to making Germany their home they are committing to follow the Basic law and all of its tenets. Ones personal rights and culture while acceptable back home are usurped with ones decision to live here even if it is temporary, which is hardly the case in most instances.

Cultural diversity is a wolf in sheeps clothing. There are big differences in how one views personal responsibility, religion, society, attitude, education, relationships. Add to that the vacuum created by one of the lowest birthrates in the EU and the extremely large families among immigrants and an uneasiness among nationals should be expected. This trend I suggest somewhat exists in the US as well. Only there it is a matter of tens of millions of illegals. The US has its own set of problems in this area but they are similar in many ways. My sense on the toughness of the immigration laws in Germany is this is the governments attempt to stem the tide of immigration if not get those in country to accept Germany as it is and not demand change.

When one looks at what is happening in the EU and in the US with immigration one begins to realise and see recognise and understand the subtle change in demographics. The result is some see the change and do not like it yet they remain silent. But while remaining silent they may begin to wonder if the shrill cry of the far right , while not at all in a agreement with their philosophy and policy, may have a grain of in it.

If you want to live in Germany become a German through and through. You still have your cultural heritage to relate to and you still have your former homeland to visit and consider. Don't impose your culture and your nationalism on your new homeland. One gives up that right when they determine to live somewhere else. And when your former homelands Prime Minister makes scurrilous commentary prior to visiting your new homeland let them know they are wrong.
10:54 November 3, 2011 by LecteurX
So The Local Germany says this: "Erdogan also criticized the insistence on learning German as a condition of living in Germany. He said this was unsupported in the relevant EU guidelines. "Making knowledge of German an important condition is against human rights," he said."

And this was about the spouses of immigrants? Oh dear, then this is the worst piece of journalism ever. This site is a rag.
10:30 November 4, 2011 by Asgarli
"Making knowledge of German an important condition is against human rights,"

So true! Immigrants should not be FORCED to learn German, but SEDUCED to it! Like does Spain force immigrants to learn Spanish, France to learn French or UK to learn English? Immigrants in those countries do it themselves, without anyone forcing them to do so! German politicians should take example from them!
13:22 November 4, 2011 by Dizz
Wait! hold on, let me find a chair. Whoo! Okay, okay. A sensible comment from Westerwelle. Nearly fell over right then. Phew.
22:19 November 4, 2011 by nebulon
10:30 November 4, 2011 by Asgarli

"So true! Immigrants should not be FORCED to learn German, but SEDUCED to it! Like does Spain force immigrants to learn Spanish, France to learn French or UK to learn English? Immigrants in those countries do it themselves, without anyone forcing them to do so! German politicians should take example from them! "

Thank you Asgarli, and in the meantime let the taxpayer keep paying for Interpreters because your Countrymen can't be bothered to learn the language, and why should they? Der Staat keeps on paying, Good night Europa.
01:37 November 5, 2011 by Motorhead
Let's see, 50 years in Germany and some Turks haven't (won't) learn German. Hmmm. Gee, Mexicans in the US would never consider being so obstinate.
04:50 November 2, 2012 by censored
Actually, being a resident of a border state between Mexico and the U.S. I can tell you that having a rudimentary ability to speak and read English is supposed to be a condition of U.S. citizenship. The number of mexican citizens that have become legal American citizens without having any English comprehension is astonishing. Why make rules that nobody enforces?
Today's headlines
Whiff of foul play in Cologne mayoral election
An electoral poster next to Cologne Cathedral. Photo: DPA

Whiff of foul play in Cologne mayoral election

3 hours ago

Did the Social Democratic Party (SPD) deliberately skew voting slips in Cologne's mayoral elections to hand their candidate an advantage?

Refugee crisis
Five ways you can help refugees in Germany
Woman bring clothing donations to a German Red Cross station in Heidenau, scene of anti-refugee demonstrations last weekend. Photo: DPA

Five ways you can help refugees in Germany

1 hour ago

The Local's pointers for how to get started if you're interested in donating your money, unwanted possessions, time or skills to help refugees in Germany.

FC Bayern takes refugee kids under its wing
Players will walk into the Allianz Arena hand-in-hand with young refugees on September 12th. Photo: DPA

FC Bayern takes refugee kids under its wing

45 minutes ago

FC Bayern Munich said on Thursday that it would help young refugees learn German and play football and donate €1m of the proceeds from an upcoming friendly match.

Berlin hotel extends beds for basketball giants
Dirk Nowitzki (r) - too tall for a normal hotel bed. Photo: DPA

Berlin hotel extends beds for basketball giants

47 minutes ago

The Berlin hotel hosting the international basketball teams playing in the 2015 European championships matches here have extended their beds to 2.50 metres in order to accomodate the giant players.

Migrant crisis
Hungary says refugees are 'German problem'
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban (l) and refugees boarding a train at Budapest's Keleti station. Photos: DPA

Hungary says refugees are 'German problem'

4 hours ago

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban insisted Thursday the migrant crisis was a German problem, not a European one as he defended his government's handling of thousands of refugees flooding into his country.

Banks jack up ATM fees for non-customers
Photo: DPA

Banks jack up ATM fees for non-customers

5 hours ago

Germany's big private banks are increasing fees for customers at other financial institutions to withdraw cash from their ATMs, making ordinary people pay the price for a bankers' spat.

Berlin mayor christens brand-new U-Bahn trains
Berlin Mayor Michael Müller smashes a bottle of Berliner Weisse beer against the metal skin of a new U-Bahn train to christen it. Photo: DPA

Berlin mayor christens brand-new U-Bahn trains

7 hours ago

The first of an all-new model of Berlin U-Bahn trains was christened on Wednesday evening by city mayor Michael Müller in a typically Berlin ceremony.

Migrant crisis
Biggest EU nations want refugees shared fairly
A man leads migrants in a chant in front of police lines at Budapest's Keleti railway station on Tuesday. Photo: DPA

Biggest EU nations want refugees shared fairly

7 hours ago

Germany, France and Italy called for an overhaul of laws on the right of asylum and a fairer distribution of migrants throughout the European Union, Italy's foreign minister said on Wednesday.

The Local List
7 ways Germans get English totally wrong
Don't let their confidence fool you: Germans aren't always the best at English. Photo: DPA.

7 ways Germans get English totally wrong

22 hours ago

As much as English-speakers might feel insecure about their Deutsch skills when faced with Germans' comparatively widespread grasp of English, Germans themselves often mess up English - in some pretty hilarious ways.

Mannschaft step forward to welcome refugees
Germany captain Bastian Schweinsteiger at a press conference earlier this week. Photo: DPA

Mannschaft step forward to welcome refugees

23 hours ago

Germany's World Cup-winning footballers have condemned xenophobic attacks on the thousands of foreigners pouring into their country and led calls to help the refugees amidst the ongoing crisis.

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS

Features
'Berlin is kind of like the best American city'
Features
How Brits in Germany are facing Brexit fears
Sport
German named 'arse bombing' world champ
Travel
Retiree finds parked car after three-week search
National
Ten ways Germany puts Britain to shame
Business & Money
German gadget clamps down on Nutella thieves
Society
Is Germany now a nation of couch potatoes?
National
Half of Germans 'have had sex in their car'
Society
Deadly stew spooks home vegetable gardeners
Politics
The man who brought two Germanies together
Features
Where to get your culture fix in Cologne
Education
Fairytale world of Brothers Grimm brought to life
Rhineland
Thieves leave 1,000 open beers untasted
National
Way to some Germans' hearts is through their wallets
National
Germany's biggest challenge: European refugee crisis
Travel
Where to get your adrenaline pumping in Germany
Technology
Could thieves hack into luxury cars?
What to watch out for when snapping your lunch
National
German lefties through history
National
The fight over prostitution heats up
National
Merkel: migrants, not Greece, are the real challenge
Features
How I explained the Queen to the Germans
Education
Why Germany does 'back-to-school' traditions better
National
Germans are ‘not how foreigners think’
National
A mum and daughter reunite 70 years after WWII
Sport
Bra stops bullet in hunting mishap miracle
National
Cows trample German woman to death in Graubünden Alps
Business & Money
Start-up helps new Berliners short cut bureaucracy
National
The 1,000s of Germans massacred after the Second World War
Sport
Germany star scores own goal with PR gaffe
Features
'Women-only' parking: sensible or sexist?
Politics
Satire and reality blur in parody party's strife
National
13-year-old boy detained for trying to join Isis
Culture
Berlin restaurant serves up Greek Crisis Menu
Rhineland
Doctor on trial after woman wakes in morgue
Society
Six odd things Germans do in the summer
Society
Police bust kinky Bavarian couple over painful love-making
Politics
Merkel brings Palestinian girl to tears
Hamburg
Amateur archaeologist finds Nazi gold hoard
National
Could Merkel learn a lesson in love from this doppelganger?
Travel
Why you should stay in Germany for the summer holidays
Sport
German press tell Schweinsteiger 'good riddance'
National
Hamburg gets a bouncing 100kg baby girl
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

6,953
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd