• Germany edition
 
eBay blocks online retailers' Cuba products
Photo: DPA

eBay blocks online retailers' Cuba products

Published: 29 Jul 2011 08:40 GMT+02:00
Updated: 29 Jul 2011 08:40 GMT+02:00

The daily Die Welt reports that German website owners selling items such as Cuban cigars have had their transactions blocked and have even seen their PayPal accounts closed in recent days.

The move is apparently in response to the long-standing US embargo against Cuba, which generally prohibits American companies from doing business there. But there are no such restrictions against European Union companies and, EBay, which is based in California, has allowed Cuba-related transactions by Europeans to go through in the past.

Thomas Altman, who sells Cuban cigars and spirits through his internet store, told Die Welt that PayPal has closed his account despite his protests, making it impossible for him to sell his products.

“We offered a compromise, but PayPal has not addressed it at all,” he said.

A PayPal spokesman confirmed the closure of Altman’s shop and several others to the newspaper, stating that its acting on the policies of its US parent company.

But he offered no alternatives for merchants such as Silke Wolf who said she had lost up to 60 percent of her business through PayPal.

“This has now disappeared and we have no substitute,” she told Die Welt, speculating the move was actually calculated to protect American alcohol brands.

Aggrieved online retailers say they’re mulling their legal options and a class action lawsuit is one possibility.

International trade expert Lothar Harings, with the law firm Graf von Westphalen, thinks they’d likely be successful. He called eBay’s actions “grossly unlawful” in Germany.

“eBay itself is violating EU law, mainly EU blocking regulations,” Harings said.

The regulations, which explicitly allow Europeans to do business with Cuba, were formulated in response to US sanctions against the communist caribbean state.

The Local/mdm

The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Don't miss...X
Left Right

Your comments about this article

14:18 July 29, 2011 by cmcintir
Hang on. PayPal isn't keeping anyone from doing business in Cuba. They may not facilitate it, but they're certainly not stopping it. That's like me blaming Visa when my local drink market only takes GiroCard. US companies are prohibited from doing business with Cuba. Stupid or not, that's the rule. PayPal is a US company. I doubt Cuba takes GiroCard. Should we be upset about that? I know the issue is inconsistency. They should pick a side and stick to it.
14:58 July 29, 2011 by ChrisRea
You are correct, PayPal isn't keeping anyone from doing business in Cuba. The article is however about something else: eBay/PayPal is preventing a German trader to sell Cubanese products through his own website. So the German guys have a German website which employed PayPal service as payment solution. But when the German website is to sell Cuban cigars, PayPal closes its account. By providing the payment solution, PayPal does not do business with Cuba, but with Germany.

If PayPal wants to do business in Europe, it has to follow European regulations. Or to pay fines if it does not respect them.
17:21 July 29, 2011 by ErnestPayne
Ebay - managing to shoot itself in the foot with every business decision.
18:09 July 29, 2011 by beatriceco
I've had my own issues with PayPal in the past, and have used Amazon Payments as an alternate to PayPal. Don't be held hostage, there are alternatives, and it is a shame that eBay/PayPal arbitrarily will shut you down and harm your business without much recourse. Here is the Amazon Payments web site link: https://payments.amazon.com/sdui/sdui/index.htm
18:58 July 29, 2011 by cmcintir
ChrisRea, PayPal isn't preventing a German trader selling Cubanese products either. They're only preventing him from using PayPal. If he allowed other forms of payment, there would be no problem. PayPal is in a difficult position. If they are the middlemen for the money, they are doing business with Cuba - transferring money. I can't use a Discovercard at Hornbach. I can't use GiroCard in the UK.

If PayPal was the only way to bank on-line, I would agree with you. They're not. They're a US company that has to follow US law. Are these people forced to use PayPal??
20:59 July 29, 2011 by Bushdiver
What is a Cubanese product? Is it like Vietnamese, or Chinese or just plain Cuban products.
21:16 July 29, 2011 by willowsdad
Sounds like PayPal could use a boycott.
21:26 July 29, 2011 by rick86
Good start,now add N Korea,China,Iran,Syria and several other ''bad guy'' nations and they'd be doing something right.
00:22 July 30, 2011 by ChrisRea
@ cmcintir #5

The German trader counted on PayPal honoring their contract according to the EU legal regulations (as PayPal Europe is registered in Luxembourg). Therefore they did not needed to use another payment service provider. By closing down their account (and this is done on illegal grounds), PayPal prevents them to do business until they enter an agreement with another provider.

The irony is that in this case PayPal would need to transfer money from/to Cuba only if some Cuban guys would like to buy Cuban cigars from Germany. So actually they cannot be the middle man in doing business with Cuba. They would only service a German trader who already bought its merchandise from Cuba.
08:45 July 30, 2011 by gnteichrib
Germany and the E.U. & U.K. have legislation in place to protect their sovereignty as Canada does, regarding the Torricelli and Helms Burton Acts. These are the U.S. legislation in force that attempt to bully U.S. foreign based subsidiaries to comply with the trade embargo against Cuba.

The E.U. Council Regulation (EC) No. 2271/96 of 22 November 1996 protects against the effects of the extra-territorial application of legislation adopted by a third country, and actions based thereon or resulting therefrom.

In Canada, my Parliament enacted the Foreign Extraterritorial Measures Act (FEMA) amendments forbidding Canadian companies and Canadian-based U.S. subsidiaries, involved with Cuba, from complying with any directive from any U.S. entity attempting to influence or harass any company operating in Canada. Enacted in 1992 in response to ratification of the Torricelli Act, the amended FEMA responded, once again, to infringements on Canadian sovereignty found in the Helms Burton Act.

The E.U. has to "man-up" and follow their legislation in place!
09:44 July 30, 2011 by Landmine
What it boil;s down to is Ebay and PayPal are US companies subject to US laws. I am sure they don;t like doing this but they have no choice. If as a user you can't do business with Cuba, then use a non US base company -very simple...
13:54 July 30, 2011 by ChrisRea
Yes, Landmine, Ebay/PayPal might be forced to follow US law. However, their operations in the EU are subject to EU regulations as well. So if they do not respect them, they have to pay. If they do not want to respect EU regulations, they should do no business in Europe.
20:59 July 30, 2011 by PierceArrow
Three cheers for PayPal! Fidel Castro is a Stalinist scumbag, and so are his henchmen. BTW, if Richard Nixon had been elected in 1960 instead of the brat Kennedy, Nixon would have take Castro out by giving air support to the Cuban rebels at the Bay of Pigs and scared the scheiBe out of USSR dictator Nikita Kruschev. Think about it! No Cuban missile crisis. No Che Guevara making terror all over the world. Perhaps even no Berlin wall and no JFK going to West Berlin to say (in the exact English translation) "I am a jelly donut!"
08:35 July 31, 2011 by ChrisRea
:D Ha, ha, ha! You made my day, PierceArrow! I think you could make a fortune if you start writing comic fiction. Stay away however from science fiction, because there things have to make a bit of sense.
16:09 July 31, 2011 by wenddiver
That's the image Germany needs, let's all get behind another totalitarian Government, a real Dictatorship, that shoots women and Children down in cold blood who try to escape the Dictatorship. You get bonus points on the bad guy scale for helping a group that has provided the weapons for every tin pot genocidal Dictator in Africa.

Torture,firing squads, exporting violent revolution, a Cuban Coast Guard that mahine Guns people trying to escape or imprisions them for life and a real Old Time Soviet Stooge to boot, who wouldn't want to support that??? I mean if you can make a couple of EUROS, pull yourself up by your own Jack Boots and go ahead, you may be to busy selling stuff to Iran to do it tomorow.

Respect. Don't ever change.
03:54 August 1, 2011 by DavidtheNorseman
There is a simple alternative. Set up a European-based PayPal-style online bank and have EU ebay transactions offered through it (by legislation if necessary).

This is just another example of the wild new World we live in....one evening in about 45 seconds I bought something in in overseas from myself (Hong Kong or such as I recall) then payed out my ebay balance since I was there to ebay whose servers are in California if I recall correctly and the amount went into their Swiss accounts. Since I do not live in Asia, the US or Switzerland it boggles the mind how many legal jurisdictions were involved....the technology is ahead of the legal agreements at present. My condolences to the German merchants, because having the rug pulled out is rough and I would think they may certainly have a legal case. For what it is worth, PayPal probably had zero choice since they must obey the direct government orders of the jurisdiction of where they do business (or find themselves in jail shortly).
Today's headlines
Lightning rods further delay Berlin Airport
Closed until further notice: Berlin's troubled new airport. Photo: DPA

Lightning rods further delay Berlin Airport

Too few lightning rods and an undersized emergency generator have prevented part of Berlin's new airport from opening. Safety inspectors refused to sign off on the airport's north pier, thwarting progress on the massively delayed construction project. READ  

Two thirds of Berlin's tourist flats now illegal
Photo: DPA

Two thirds of Berlin's tourist flats now illegal

Two thirds of Berlin's 12,000 tourist apartments advertised on sites such as Airbnb were being run illegally from Friday following a law change, leaving hosts open to potential punishment. READ  

Lost goat halts Munich Airport trains
Fritzi underneath the train. Photo: Freiwillige Feuerwehr Unterschließheim/DPA

Lost goat halts Munich Airport trains

A lost pet goat called Fritzi halted trains to Munich Airport and had to be rescued from the tracks after suffering a concussion. READ  

Germany crowned U19 European Champions
Photo: EPA/Tibor Illyes HUNGARY OUT

Germany crowned U19 European Champions

Germany’s U19 football team added to a glorious summer of sport for the country by winning the European Championships in Budapest on Thursday night. READ  

World War I anniversary
100 years ago, Germans celebrated war's outbreak
August 1914. German soldiers march off to war in France. Photo: DPA

100 years ago, Germans celebrated war's outbreak

A hundred years ago on Friday Germany declared war on Russia and was preparing for an attack on France in the hope that Britain would stay neutral. Four years on, famine was ravaging the country and two million soldiers had been killed on the battlefield. READ  

Environment Agency urges fast fracking ban
Photo: DPA

Environment Agency urges fast fracking ban

Germany's Federal Environment Agency (UBA) is encouraging lawmakers to hurry up and ban fracking in all but name, saying the process is too dangerous to even consider allowing. READ  

German of the Week
'Now I can grow cannabis at home'
Günter Weiglein. Photo: DPA

'Now I can grow cannabis at home'

Günter Weiglein is one of three men in Germany who is allowed to grow his own cannabis thanks to a court ruling last week. But he tells The Local he’s not celebrating just yet. READ  

Germany tops penis enlargement table
Do your wurst, doc. Photo: DPA

Germany tops penis enlargement table

Germany is the world’s leader in penis enlargements, with five times as many people in the country undergoing the procedure than anywhere else in the world. Globally, Germany carries out the fourth highest amount of cosmetic surgery operations. READ  

The Local List
The best words in Austrian German
Which one is the Austrian word for tomato? Photo: APA/dpa

The best words in Austrian German

If you’ve lived in Germany, or you learnt Hochdeutsch at school, you may be surprised by some of the language differences between Austria and parts of Germany. READ  

Turks in Germany vote for first time
Voters at Berlin's Olympic Stadium on Thursday. Photo: DPA

Turks in Germany vote for first time

Germany’s large Turkish community headed to polling stations on Thursday to vote for the first time in a Turkish election. The Local visits Berlin’s Olympic Stadium which has been turned into a giant voting booth. READ  

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Photo: DPA
Gallery
Five reasons to visit Oktoberfest (and five not to)
Photo: DPA
Society
Huge Bavarian crop circle puzzles crowds
Photo: DPA
Analysis & Opinion
Have Your Say: Should Germany legalize cannabis?
Photo: DPA
Education
Germany's students fail to graduate in time
Photo: DPA
Gallery
Hamburg harbour lit up in blue
Business & Money
JobTalk: 'Application process is failing'
Photo: Bundesarchiv/Bild 183-S45825
Culture
Germany puts 700,000 WWI docs online
Photo: DPA
Society
This man wants to give all of us €12,000 a year
Photo: DPA
Education
Top university switches master's courses to English
Travel
Plans unveiled for bike trail along former Iron Curtain
Photo: DPA
Gallery
The Local List: 12 best words in German
Photo: Europeana.de 1914 - 1918
Gallery
A German soldier's life behind WWI lines
Education
Raising the bar for law & business in Germany
Photo: DPA
Business & Money
JobTalk: All you need to know about working in Germany
Photo: DPA
Features
The Local List Archive - Your guide to all things German
National
Share news tips with The Local Germany
Sponsored Article
Bilingual school turning education on its head
Sponsored Article
CurrencyFair: Why it pays when making overseas transfers
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

3,296
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd