• Germany edition
 
Baby hatches turn 10 amid calls for closure
Photo: DPA

Baby hatches turn 10 amid calls for closure

Published: 08 Apr 2010 15:38 GMT+02:00
Updated: 08 Apr 2010 15:38 GMT+02:00

There are some 80 such Babyklappen across the nation, set up to provide parents with a safe and legal way to surrender newborn infants for adoption. The idea, which dates back to medieval Catholic churches, was instituted in Hamburg by the Sternipark charity organisation on April 8, 2000 to help prevent infanticide in reaction to the discovery of a dead infant at a recycling centre.

“If we save even one child, our work has been worth it,” leader of the Sternipark project Findelbaby Leila Moyisch told news agency DPA.

Thirty-eight babies have been left in the organisation’s two baby hatches since 2000. Of these, 14 mothers have returned to reclaim their children, and the number of abandoned or killed babies has dropped in the city, Moyisch said.

The organisation’s motto is: “No questions, no witnesses, no police.”

But critics say that the presence of baby hatches has not actually reduced infanticide in Germany and takes away a child’s right to know its origins.

“If you take a sober look, the number has not gone down nationwide,” said Michael Heuer, spokesperson for the German arm of child rights organisation Terre des Hommes.

An estimated 30 to 40 babies die each year in Germany due to abandonment or infanticide. This number is believed to be relatively constant, though exact numbers are hard to define because infanticide no longer appears as an offence in the country’s criminal statistics.

“Baby hatches seem to be a choice that has not reached its target group,” said Heuer, explaining that most women who kill their infants are acting out of panic and would not make the rational decision to safely deposit their child at a nearby hospital.

President of Germany’s DKSB children’s protection federation Heinz Hilgers said he favoured closing the baby hatches “in principle,” if something “practical” were to take their place.

“We want lawmakers to make the so-called anonymous birth possible,” he said.

But Moyisch of Hamburg’s Sternipark organisation argued that the life of a child is more important than their family history or ethical questions.

“The right to life comes before the right to heritage,” she said.

DPA/The Local (news@thelocal.de)

Your comments about this article

16:03 April 8, 2010 by William Thirteen
do they pick the babies up every two weeks or every month?
19:13 April 8, 2010 by Bushdiver
I'd say it's better to have this option available than to have some idiot throw the unwanted child in the dumpster.
20:26 April 8, 2010 by dbert4
What's unethical about saving the lives of babies?
06:43 April 9, 2010 by Thames
@william thirteen

Not funny. The lives of children is a serious matter.
10:20 April 9, 2010 by dcgi
@dbert4: I think the argument against this service is that the mother is allowed to deny all responsibility for the baby, when you think about it they have a point that should be considered.. after so many weeks you cannot legally get an abortion so why after the baby is born should you just be allowed to dump it off onto someone else and walk away? Some would say they shouldn't just be allowed to shun the help that is out there through counseling, social services etc.

The other point I think they raise is that such a service like this sets a dangerous precedence, some would see that it effectively lowers our moral standards and that justifications like "well infantcide will always happen, we're providing a safety net" is not a reasonable justification.

I also remember hearing a news story about the lack of effectiveness of the service in that there have still been cases of infanticide despite it being available. I can't quote you any stats, but I agree it would be really good to know if it's actually effective at saving lives or not, rather than assuming it is or sensationalising it with statements like "if it saves even one it's worth it".

Food for thought.
21:03 April 9, 2010 by cobalisk
@DCGI

I would recommend examining practical matters rather than moralistic or hypothetical ones in a case like this. Actual analysis of infant mortality rates combined with case studies of the children put in baby hatches will prove if they are effective or not.

Claiming baby hatches 'lower our moral standards' is actually backwards. They enhance our moral standards because we the society claim that saving the life is most precious and now provide a means to allow someone who has no interest in their child to give it a fighting chance for adoption rather than abandonment or mistreatment. If a society is going to stand on principle the principle of 'all are equal and valued' is a hell of a lot more morally defensible than 'self-reliance'.
05:13 April 10, 2010 by amperrymd
"Infanticide no longer appears as an offence in the country¦#39;s criminal statistics." What could be the significance of this statement?

Is killing a baby in Germany not considered a crime?
06:56 April 10, 2010 by Midnightpromises
Another one of those dysfunctional American ideas that has been imported?
19:57 April 10, 2010 by JackieSixty
@Midnightpromises,

no, it is not another one of those "dysfunctional American" ideas; as was clearly stated in the article, the concept of the baby hatch was first put in to practice by medieval Catholic churches.

Reading is fundamental, try it.
22:06 April 10, 2010 by wenddiver
@jackiesicty- That would make it a dysfunctional european idea, if we where impolite or just a European idea.

We shouldn't reject it, just because we didn't invent it. Probably better than chopping the baby up in an abortion or throwing it in a dumpster like a drugo.
14:57 April 11, 2010 by beeker
In 2008 Nebraska, USA passed a similar law that allowed parents to turn in children at any hospital. The Legislators neglected to put an age range in the wording. Don't know how many lives it saved, but one man turned in his 9 kids aged 1 to 17. People drove from other states to turn in their "problem" teens.

All 50 states have a safe haven law, but abondoned and killed babies are still found. Statistics would be hard to quantifiy, but one life saved is better than none.
15:48 April 13, 2010 by wenddiver
Good way to get rid of Gitmo derainees, sedate, strip naked, put disposable diaper on, shove thru baby hatch, run like hell.
17:40 April 14, 2010 by Hebbellover
@Thames - "Not funny. The lives of children is a serious matter."

I Would agree, however, where is the same concern for the unborn?
06:27 April 15, 2010 by wenddiver
You guys ever think of making the baby ejection seats out of something a little more baby friendly than hard stainless steel with-out bumpered edges?
14:22 January 26, 2011 by KAZRCRW
Hm

@DCGI

@dbert4

Can anyone send me the link for the statistic.. that infants. in germany is actually not goes down in nationwide?
Today's headlines
Oettinger blames celebs for nude photo hack
Oettinger (l) appeared to misunderstand how the internet works in his comments about the photo hack which has reportedly affected celebrities including Amber Heard (r). Photo: DPA/EPA

Oettinger blames celebs for nude photo hack

German newspapers on Tuesday ridiculed incoming EU Digital Commissioner Günther Oettinger after he blamed "stupid" celebrities for having their private nude pictures hacked and spread online. READ  

Shots fired as ‘seniors’ rob Berlin security van
Police outside the Apple Store in Berlin where a security van was robbed. Photo: DPA

Shots fired as ‘seniors’ rob Berlin security van

A gang disguised as pensioners opened fire on a Berlin security van on Monday night, escaping with cash before setting their getaway car on fire. It is the second such attack in ten days. READ  

Pickpocket fools minister at anti-crime event
Ralf Jäger in front of a sign reading "eyes open and pockets closed" at the pickpocketing awareness event. Photo: DPA

Pickpocket fools minister at anti-crime event

North Rhine-Westphalia's interior minister Ralf Jäger was pickpocketed by a magician at a press conference he called on Monday to launch a campaign against pickpocketing. READ  

Berlin heart centre fiddled transplant list
Photo: DPA

Berlin heart centre fiddled transplant list

A probe into German transplant centres sparked by an organ donor scandal has revealed 14 cases of a doctor fiddling medical records at one of Germany’s leading heart centres. READ  

Lufthansa strike hits 20,000 passengers
A stranded group of travellers from Vancouver, Canada, sit and wait at Frankfurt Airport on Tuesday. Photo: DPA

Lufthansa strike hits 20,000 passengers

UPDATE: The fourth pilots’ strike in recent weeks hit Germany’s biggest airport on Tuesday morning, with long-haul Lufthansa flights grounded at Frankfurt. Around 20,000 passengers have been affected. READ  

View from Germany
'Criminals are at work in refugee homes'
Photo: DPA/Police

'Criminals are at work in refugee homes'

A photo appearing to show a refugee being abused at a home for asylum seekers has caused outrage in Germany. The photo has been compared to those from Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib. Police are now investigating six cases of abuse at three different centres. READ  

Police suspect neo-Nazis of Reichstag attack
An investigator gives a sniffer dog the scent of an object found at the scene. Photo: DPA

Police suspect neo-Nazis of Reichstag attack

Investigators believe a Molotov cocktail thrown at the Reichstag building in Berlin early on Monday morning was the work of a far-right group, a police spokeswoman said on Tuesday. READ  

Unemployment rate stagnates in September
Photo: DPA

Unemployment rate stagnates in September

Unemployment in Germany stagnated in September, as clouds continue to build over Europe's biggest economy, official data showed on Tuesday. READ  

Germany struggles with Turkey Nato mission
A Bundeswehr Patriot missile in southern Turkey. Photo: DPA

Germany struggles with Turkey Nato mission

A shortage of trained troops caused more embarrassment for Germany's military on Tuesday when it emerged that more than one in four soldiers taking part in a Nato mission in Turkey are not getting their allotted time off between deployments. READ  

Spielberg to shoot spy thriller in Berlin
Spielberg (l), Amy Ryan (c) and Tom Hanks (r). Photo: DPA

Spielberg to shoot spy thriller in Berlin

Director Steven Spielberg is to shoot his next film in Germany, the Berlin-Brandenburg Film Board announced on Monday. The Jurassic Park and Saving Private Ryan director is turning his attention to a Cold War spy thriller. READ  

RECEIVE OUR NEWSLETTER AND ALERTS
Photo: DPA
Business & Money
Immigrants have created how many German jobs?
Photo: DPA
Munich
Brit raped at Oktoberfest while going to toilet
Photo: DPA
National
Revealed: Germany's military feet of clay
Marks & Spencer
Sponsored Article
Marks and Spencer: Win €300 toward your new autumn wardrobe
Photo: Shutterstock
Society
Quiz: How good is your German?
Photo: DPA
Gallery
Thousands take to Berlin's streets for marathon
Photo: DPA
Society
'Incest should be legal,' says ethics board
Photo: DPA
Gallery
Ten noises that sound very different in German
Photo: DPA
Society
QUIZ: Can you pass the German citizenship test?
Photo: Shutterstock
Gallery
Ten German words you'll never want to hear again
Sponsored Article
Bilingual education from nursery to graduation at Phorms
Photo: DPA
Business & Money
JobTalk: All you need to know about working in Germany
National
Share news tips with The Local Germany
Latest news from The Local in Austria

More news from Austria at thelocal.at

Latest news from The Local in Switzerland

More news from Switzerland at thelocal.ch

Latest news from The Local in Denmark

More news from Denmark at thelocal.dk

Latest news from The Local in Spain

More news from Spain at thelocal.es

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Italy

More news from Italy at thelocal.it

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no

Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

3,154
jobs available
Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd